The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Bengaluru, has confirmed penalties totalling ₹22.62 lakh, distinguishing between tax already disclosed in GST returns but left unpaid and taxable receipts omitted from returns until audit scrutiny.
The bench comprising Srikanth Venkatraman (Judicial Member) and Sudha Koka (Technical Member) held that payment of the principal tax without applicable interest did not satisfy the conditions for penalty relief. It also restored a 100% penalty on a separate liability after finding that the disclosure followed audit intervention and involved wilful suppression.
Buy Now: All 200+ GSTAT Judgements Till November 2026 | Comprehensive E-Magazine
The taxpayer provided operation and maintenance services for desilting machines, including sewer cleaning services, to government departments and urban local bodies. It also supplied sanitation machinery and manpower services.
Officers of the Mysuru Audit Commissionerate examined its records for July 2017 to March 2020 under Section 65 of the CGST Act. The exercise involved reconciliation of GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, GSTR-2A, GSTR-9, audited financial statements and Form 26AS.
The proceedings concerned short-paid outward tax of ₹56,39,992 and disputed input tax credit of ₹1,20,860. A major component was a difference of ₹34,69,134 between the liability declared in GSTR-1 and the tax discharged through GSTR-3B for financial year 2018–19.
Other discrepancies concerned amounts recorded in the profit and loss account, receipts reflected in Form 26AS and an IGST difference.
Following audit observations, the taxpayer paid the principal outward tax before issuance of the show cause notice. However, applicable interest and the full penalty remained unpaid.
A show cause notice dated May 23, 2023 invoked Section 74 and demanded tax, interest and penalties. The adjudicating authority subsequently confirmed the demands and appropriated the amounts already deposited.
By an order dated April 13, 2025, the first appellate authority granted partial relief.
For the ₹34,69,134 difference between GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B, it held that the liability had already been disclosed and constituted unpaid self-assessed tax governed by Section 75(12). It upheld interest but dropped the penalty.
For another liability of ₹19,02,658, it converted the proceedings from Section 74 to Section 73 through Section 75(2), relying on disclosure in statutory returns before issuance of the show cause notice.
The appellate authority separately sustained Section 74 proceedings on an undeclared differential liability of ₹2,68,200. It also partly allowed the taxpayer’s challenge concerning ITC, confirming an unreconciled balance of ₹75,384 under Section 73.
The Revenue approached GSTAT against the complete dropping of the penalty on ₹34,69,134 and the conversion of the ₹19,02,658 demand from Section 74 to Section 73.
On the GSTR-1/GSTR-3B difference, the tribunal accepted that the outward supplies had been disclosed on the department’s portal. It therefore agreed that Section 74 could not be invoked on the basis of suppression of that turnover.
However, the bench held that this finding did not justify complete elimination of the penalty.
The taxpayer had failed to discharge the tax for more than three years and subsequently paid the principal amount without the mandatory interest under Section 50.
The tribunal reasoned that penalty relief under Sections 73(6) and 73(8), read with Section 75(2), required payment of both tax and applicable interest. Payment of the tax component alone did not fulfil that condition.
It consequently set aside the dropping of the penalty and confirmed ₹3,59,368 under Section 73, read with Section 75(2) of the CGST/KGST Acts and Section 20 of the IGST Act.
The tribunal reached a different conclusion on the ₹19,02,658 liability.
The taxpayer argued that the underlying figures appeared in audited financial statements and that discrepancies identified through reconciliation did not establish fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression with intent to evade tax.
The bench acknowledged that every instance of non-payment or mismatch cannot automatically be treated as tax evasion. It observed that invocation of Section 74 requires examination of the evidence and foundational facts of the particular case.
Nevertheless, it found that the present proceedings involved identifiable taxable receipts omitted from GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B, rather than a numerical mismatch alone.
According to the tribunal’s findings, the additional liability was disclosed in GSTR-9 only after the audit team commenced verification and confronted the taxpayer with financial records and Form 26AS particulars.
The tribunal therefore treated the disclosure as prompted by scrutiny rather than voluntary compliance.
The bench relied on Explanation 2 to Section 74, which addresses non-declaration of facts or information required to be disclosed in returns, statements, reports or other documents furnished under the Act.
Referring to the self-assessment obligations under Sections 39 and 59, it held that recording taxable receipts in internal accounts or financial statements did not by itself satisfy the requirement to declare them in the prescribed GST returns.
The tribunal discussed the Andhra Pradesh High Court’s decision in Sriba Nirman Company and the distinction between suppression and wilful suppression.
Applying that distinction to the evidence before it, the bench concluded that the omissions and subsequent audit-triggered disclosure justified Section 74 proceedings in this case.
It accordingly reversed the conversion to Section 73 and restored the 100% penalty of ₹19,02,658 under Section 74(1).
The taxpayer relied on an order in Form GST SPL-05 dated December 26, 2025 to argue that the dispute stood concluded under the Section 128A waiver mechanism.
The tribunal rejected the argument after examining the scope of that order.
It recorded that the waiver concerned a residual penalty of ₹40,000 under Section 73 and did not cover the two penalty issues raised in the Revenue’s appeal. It also held that Section 128A relief did not extend to the Section 74 liability in dispute.
The waiver order therefore did not prevent adjudication of the Revenue’s challenge.
A further objection concerned the absence of a Document Identification Number on the Principal Commissioner’s authorisation under Section 112(3).
The tribunal distinguished communications issued to taxpayers or external parties from an internal departmental direction authorising the filing of an appeal.
It held that the review authorisation was an internal administrative communication. Consequently, the absence of a DIN did not invalidate the authorisation or render the departmental appeal non-maintainable.
The tribunal rejected the challenge to bench allocation, observing that the surviving dispute concerned the imposition and quantum of penalties and fell within the penalty category assigned to the bench.
It also rejected the allegation that the original adjudication violated Section 75(4) by denying a personal hearing.
The record showed that the taxpayer’s authorised representative attended a hearing on November 24, 2023 and that a further hearing opportunity was extended and attended on November 30, 2023.
The tribunal modified the first appellate order to the extent challenged by the Revenue, confirming the ₹3,59,368 penalty on disclosed but short-paid tax and restoring the ₹19,02,658 penalty on the liability held to involve wilful suppression.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: Reimbursable Expenses Not Taxable For Pre-2015 Period: CESTAT Quashes Service Tax Demand

