The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), New Delhi, has held that the extended period of limitation could not be invoked against a subcontractor where the main contractor had already paid service tax on the activity and conflicting tribunal decisions had prevailed on the subcontractor’s tax liability.
The bench of Ajay Sharma (Judicial Member) and P.V. Subba Rao (Technical Member) also directed the adjudicating authority to examine whether the company’s fabrication activities amounted to manufacture rather than the provision of taxable services. It clarified that any service tax demand confirmed after reconsideration must remain confined to the normal period of limitation.
Buy Now: Indirect Tax Judgments E-Compilation – October 2026
The bench set aside personal penalties of ₹1 lakh each imposed on two directors under Section 78A of the Finance Act, 1994.
The proceedings arose from an investigation into appellant/assessee, which the department alleged was providing taxable construction and works contract services without obtaining service tax registration or paying tax.
According to the order, the company had undertaken subcontracting work in relation to Steel Authority of India Ltd. (SAIL) at Bhilai and National Thermal Power Corporation (NTPC) at Raigarh. The Tribunal recorded that the company’s turnover was significant during the disputed period, 2010–11 to 2015–16.
A show cause notice dated April 22, 2016, proposed recovery of service tax under the proviso to Section 73(1) of the Finance Act, 1994, together with interest under Section 75.
The notice also proposed penalties against the company under Sections 76, 77 and 78, and personal penalties against its directors under Section 78A. A subsequent statement of demand dated April 11, 2018, sought recovery for a later period.
The Commissioner adjudicated the proceedings through an order dated February 28, 2019, which the company and its directors challenged before the Tribunal.
The company contended that it was not independently required to pay service tax because the main contractors had already discharged tax on the entire value, including the work performed by it.
Its counsel also argued that the arrangement was revenue neutral. Had the company paid service tax and charged it in its invoices, SAIL and NTPC could have availed CENVAT credit, reducing their service tax payment in cash.
The company further submitted that different benches of the Tribunal had previously expressed conflicting views on whether a subcontractor was required to pay service tax when the main contractor had paid tax on the entire transaction.
That controversy was ultimately resolved by the Larger Bench in Commissioner of Service Tax, New Delhi v. Melange Developers Pvt. Ltd., 2020 (33) GSTL 116 (Tri.-LB).
As recorded in the present order, the Larger Bench held that the subcontractor was also required to pay service tax, while the main contractor could take CENVAT credit of the tax paid.
The company argued that the earlier divergence of judicial opinion prevented an inference that it had deliberately intended to evade tax.
The company raised an additional contention that its activities involved fabrication at site and amounted to manufacture. It argued that such activity could not be treated as the provision of a taxable service.
On a specific query from the bench, counsel acknowledged that this ground had not been raised before the Commissioner and, therefore, had not been examined in the adjudication order.
Nevertheless, counsel submitted that the plea raised a fundamental legal question: whether any taxable service had been provided at all.
The Revenue opposed the introduction of this ground at the appellate stage, arguing that the company could not make out an entirely new case after failing to raise it during the investigation or adjudication.
The departmental representative also emphasised that the company had not obtained registration and that its activities had come to light only after a detailed investigation.
The Tribunal observed that it would ordinarily be reluctant to allow an appellant to raise grounds that had not been taken before the lower authority.
However, it found that the manufacture plea raised a serious legal issue going to the existence of the taxable event itself.
The bench explained that if the activity amounted to manufacture, it could not be treated as a service either during the period before the negative list regime began on July 1, 2012, or thereafter.
At the same time, the Tribunal recognised that this question required factual examination. The nature of the fabrication work and whether it resulted in a new marketable good would need to be considered.
Since the Commissioner had not previously had an opportunity to examine these matters, the Tribunal remanded the case for a finding.
It clarified that if all the company’s activities were found to constitute manufacture, no service tax could be demanded.
On limitation, the Tribunal held that where the activity constituted a service supplied by a subcontractor and the main contractor had already paid service tax on it, the conflicting tribunal decisions prevailing before Melange Developers prevented invocation of the extended period.
The bench accordingly directed that any service tax demand confirmed in the fresh adjudication must be restricted to the normal period of limitation.
For the same reason, the Tribunal held that the personal penalties imposed on directors Anil Lohchab and Rajinder Singh Lohchab under Section 78A deserved to be set aside.
Their appeals concerned penalties of ₹1 lakh each imposed in connection with the first show cause notice. No personal penalties had been imposed on them in relation to the subsequent statement of demand.
The Tribunal set aside the impugned order and allowed the company’s appeal by way of remand. It separately allowed the directors’ appeals and removed their personal penalties.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.

