The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), New Delhi, has set aside an appellate order in a service tax dispute involving electrical installation, maintenance and related contracts, directing the adjudicating authority to reconsider the contractor’s claims for exemption and abatement after examining supporting documents.
The Bench of Ashok Jindal (Judicial Member) and Hemambika R. Priya (Technical Member) remanded the matter for fresh adjudication after noting that the complete documents supporting the claims had not been furnished earlier. Supporting material, including a chartered accountant’s certificate, had been placed before the Tribunal.
Buy Now: Indirect Tax Judgments E-Compilation – October 2026
The contractor has been directed to submit all relevant documents to the adjudicating authority within 15 days of receiving the Tribunal’s order. The authority must examine the documents, fix a hearing and pass an appropriate order in accordance with law.
The dispute concerned services provided during the financial years 2011–12 to 2014–15. The appellant was registered for erection, commissioning and installation services, construction services, management, maintenance and repair services, and works contract services.
During investigation, the department examined work contracts, balance sheets and Form 26AS. According to the department, the appellant had executed labour contracts but had incorrectly treated the services as works contract services.
The department alleged that this classification resulted in service tax being paid on 40% of the total value of taxable services, whereas tax should have been paid on the entire value.
This distinction formed a central part of the demand: whether the contracts justified the treatment adopted by the appellant or were labour contracts taxable on their full value, as alleged by the department.
The Tribunal did not resolve that classification issue on merits. It directed the original authority to reconsider the matter with the supporting evidence.
The order records that the appellant provided services to Ajmer Vidhyut Vitran Nigam Limited involving erection, commissioning or installation of high-tension and low-tension lines, shifting of such lines, replacement of meters, GSS work, line maintenance, civil work connected with HT/LT lines, oil filtration and other related activities.
The appellant also provided services to recipients including Hindustan Zinc Ltd., Rajasthan State Road Development Corporation, Wonder Cement, Sadbhav, RK Marbles, UIT, Nagar Nigam and ReGen Powertech.
The department separately disputed certain exemptions claimed for services supplied to Rajasthan State Road Development Corporation and Sadbhav. It alleged that the appellant was not entitled to those exemptions.
Following the investigation, a show cause notice proposed recovery of differential service tax, interest and penalties.
The adjudicating authority confirmed the service tax demand along with interest and imposed a penalty. The appellant challenged that decision before the Commissioner (Appeals).
The Commissioner (Appeals) found that complete documents necessary for proper adjudication had not been provided and upheld the adjudication order. The contractor then approached CESTAT against the appellate order dated August 21, 2018.
The Tribunal’s order does not specify the amount of the demand, interest or penalty.
After hearing both sides, CESTAT noted the earlier failure to provide the complete documentary material supporting the claims for exemption or abatement. It also recorded that material, including a chartered accountant’s certificate, had been placed before it.
In these circumstances, the Bench considered a remand appropriate in the interests of justice.
The decision allows the claims to be examined afresh by the adjudicating authority on the basis of the relevant records. It does not hold that the certificate or other documents conclusively establish the appellant’s eligibility.
Setting aside the impugned order, CESTAT directed the appellant to furnish all relevant documents supporting its exemption or abatement claims within 15 days of receiving the order.
After receiving the documents, the adjudicating authority must examine them and fix a hearing before passing an appropriate order in accordance with law.
The 15-day period applies to the appellant’s submission of documents. The Tribunal did not prescribe a separate deadline for completion of the fresh adjudication.
The appeal was disposed of by way of remand. Consequently, the decision does not finally establish that the contracts qualify as works contracts, that payment of service tax on 40% of the value was correct, or that the disputed exemptions were available.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.

