The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), New Delhi, has held that a bank guarantee equivalent to 210% of the proposed differential customs duty was disproportionate for the provisional release of a seized Cadillac Escalade V.
Reducing the guarantee requirement to 50% of the proposed differential duty, the bench of Dr. Rachna Gupta (Officiating President) and P.V. Subba Rao (Technical Member) observed that provisional release conditions must balance protection of revenue with the hardship faced by the importer.
Buy Now: Indirect Tax Judgments E-Compilation – October 2026
The Bench partly allowed the appeal against the conditions imposed by the customs authority. The separate requirement to execute a ₹5.80 crore bond remains unchanged.
The dispute arose from the import of a Cadillac Escalade V through the Inland Container Depot at Tughlakabad, New Delhi. The vehicle was imported under a bill of entry dated August 12, 2024, declaring a cost-and-freight value of USD 78,000, and was initially cleared by Customs.
The Ahmedabad Zonal Unit of the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence subsequently investigated the import. A statement of a director of the importing company was recorded on April 11, 2025.
The investigation also referred to a Dubai Customs export declaration dated July 19, 2024, reflecting a free-on-board value of USD 199,414 for the vehicle.
Relying on the director’s statement and the difference between the declared Indian import value and the foreign export declaration, the authorities seized the vehicle on June 13, 2025, under Section 110 read with Section 111(m) of the Customs Act, 1962.
A show cause notice dated December 6, 2025, proposed rejection of the declared value, redetermination of the assessable value, recovery of differential duty and other consequential action.
Customs Required ₹4.63 Crore Bank Guarantee For Release
The importer applied for provisional release under Section 110A of the Customs Act on April 17, 2026, followed by a reminder on April 23, 2026.
When the application remained unanswered, the importer approached the Delhi High Court. By an order dated April 30, 2026, in W.P.(C) No. 5940 of 2026, the High Court directed the competent authority to decide the matter within two weeks.
The customs authority subsequently permitted provisional release through an order dated May 14, 2026, subject to execution of a bond of ₹5.80 crore and furnishing a bank guarantee of ₹4,63,57,479.
Aggrieved by these conditions, the importer approached CESTAT.
The importer argued that the bank guarantee amounted to approximately 210% of the proposed differential duty and was excessive.
It relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in Commissioner of Customs, ICD, TKD, New Delhi v. Navshakti Industries Pvt. Ltd., where release had been ordered against a bank guarantee of 30% of the differential duty.
The importer also cited the Chandigarh Bench’s decision in Ventura Global Inc. v. Commissioner of Customs, Ludhiana, decided on July 15, 2026. According to the submissions recorded in the judgment, that decision considered a bond covering the full value of the goods and a bank guarantee of 30% of the estimated duty sufficient to safeguard revenue and the interests of justice.
The importer accordingly sought reduction of the guarantee requirement to 30% of the proposed differential duty.
The Department opposed the appeal, describing the matter as one involving substantial undervaluation of a luxury vehicle imported from Dubai.
It highlighted the difference between the USD 199,414 FOB value recorded in the Dubai export declaration and the USD 78,000 cost-and-freight value declared before Indian Customs.
Although the Department acknowledged that the guarantee was approximately 2.10 times the proposed differential duty, it maintained that the customs authority had considered the valuation discrepancy, the proposed duty liability, possible consequences under the Customs Act and the need to safeguard revenue pending adjudication.
Relying on Mala Petrochemicals & Polymers v. Additional Director General, DRI and Classic Interiors v. Commissioner of Customs, New Delhi, the Department argued that provisional release conditions must depend on the circumstances of each case.
It also sought to distinguish Navshakti Industries because that matter concerned newsprint, contending that there was no universal rule restricting bank guarantees to 30% of differential duty.
CESTAT observed that Section 110A gives the adjudicating authority discretion to determine the security and conditions for releasing seized goods pending adjudication. However, that discretion must be exercised fairly and reasonably.
The Tribunal explained that the provision does not prescribe a blanket rule requiring deposit of 100% of the duty demanded in every misdeclaration case. The relevant consideration is whether the authority relied on appropriate material and imposed conditions reasonable in the circumstances.
Drawing support from Mala Petrochemicals & Polymers, the Bench recognised that different categories of allegedly wrongful imports may justify different treatment. Treating all cases alike without considering their particular circumstances could itself result in injustice.
The Tribunal therefore assessed the guarantee requirement on the facts before it, without treating the 30% figure cited by the importer as automatically applicable.
Examining the customs authority’s calculation, CESTAT found that the guarantee included not merely the proposed differential duty but also quantified amounts towards proposed fine and penalties.
The Bench observed that the amount represented the maximum liability that could be called upon from the importer if it failed at final adjudication. Requiring security for that amount at the provisional release stage was an unreasonable exercise of discretion in the circumstances.
The Tribunal stressed that the guarantee must be proportionate and balance revenue protection against the importer’s hardship.
It also considered depreciation relevant, observing that the vehicle’s year of manufacture and year of import had a bearing on its declining value.
On this reasoning, the Bench held that a guarantee amounting to 210% of the proposed differential duty was disproportionate.
While reducing the guarantee, CESTAT also took account of the alleged misdeclaration involving a high-end luxury vehicle.
It therefore directed that the bank guarantee be fixed at 50% of the proposed differential duty, instead of the 30% requested by the importer.
The provisional release order was modified only to that extent, and the appeal was partly allowed. The ₹5.80 crore bond requirement was not altered.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.

