The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Hyderabad, has condoned a five-day delay in filing an excise appeal after accepting the taxpayer’s explanation that it initially approached the appellate sub-office at Visakhapatnam, only to discover that the office had shifted to Guntur.
The bench of Angad Prasad (Judicial Member) held that the Commissioner (Appeals) had adopted an “unduly technical approach” in refusing condonation, particularly when the appeal was filed within the additional 30-day period permitted under Section 35(1) of the Central Excise Act, 1944.
Buy Now: Indirect Tax Judgments E-Compilation – October 2026
The Tribunal set aside the order rejecting the appeal on limitation and remanded the matter for fresh consideration on merits. It did not decide the admissibility of the disputed Cenvat credit.
The appellant/assessee is a manufacturer of General Purpose and High Impact Polystyrene falling under Chapter 39 of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985.
The company had availed Cenvat credit on certain input services during April 2017 to June 2017. Through an Order-in-Original dated March 29, 2025, the adjudicating authority disallowed credit of ₹4,75,403, along with applicable interest, and imposed a penalty of ₹47,540.
The company challenged the adjudication order before the Commissioner (Appeals), Guntur. However, the appeal was rejected because it had been filed five days beyond the normal limitation period. The substantive question of whether the input service credit was admissible remained unexamined.
The appellant submitted that it received the adjudication order and attempted to file its appeal at the appellate sub-office in Visakhapatnam within the prescribed 60-day period.
On approaching that office, it was informed that the appellate sub-office had shifted to Guntur. The appeal was subsequently filed at Guntur on July 3, 2025.
The company maintained that the delay was neither deliberate nor attributable to negligence, but arose from circumstances beyond its control. It also pointed out that the adjudication order itself mentioned the Visakhapatnam appellate sub-office.
Since the delay was only five days and fell within the statutory condonable period, the appellant argued that the Commissioner (Appeals) should have condoned it and examined the appeal on merits. The Revenue supported the impugned orders.
The Tribunal identified the issue as whether the Commissioner (Appeals) was justified in refusing to condone the five-day delay.
Explaining Section 35(1) of the Central Excise Act, CESTAT noted that an appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals) must ordinarily be filed within 60 days. The provision permits condonation of a further delay of up to 30 days where sufficient cause is established.
In the present case, the appeal was admittedly filed only five days beyond the normal limitation period. It therefore remained within the period during which the Commissioner (Appeals) could exercise the statutory power of condonation.
The question was consequently whether the explanation furnished by the appellant constituted sufficient cause.
The Commissioner (Appeals) had relied on a verification report indicating that no record was available of the appellant’s interaction concerning the attempted filing at Visakhapatnam.
CESTAT held that the absence of an official record of attempted filing could not, by itself, conclusively establish a lack of bona fides.
The Tribunal considered the appellant’s specific explanation that it had approached the Visakhapatnam office because the adjudication order itself referred to that office. In the context of the short delay, it found the explanation plausible and deserving of consideration.
It also found nothing indicating that the delay was deliberate or occasioned by any mala fide intention.
The Tribunal referred to Singh Enterprises v. CCE, Jamshedpur [2008 (221) ELT 163 (SC)], which establishes that the Commissioner (Appeals) cannot condone delay beyond the additional period expressly prescribed under Section 35(1).
However, CESTAT explained that where the delay falls within the permissible condonable period, the Commissioner (Appeals) is empowered to condone it upon being satisfied that sufficient cause exists.
The Tribunal also relied on Collector, Land Acquisition, Anantnag v. Mst. Katiji & Others [1987 (28) ELT 185 (SC)], concerning a justice-oriented interpretation of “sufficient cause” so that substantial justice is not defeated by a technical approach to limitation.
CESTAT applied that principle to the assessment of sufficient cause within the discretion expressly provided by Section 35(1). The ruling does not extend the statutory outer limit for condonation.
The Tribunal observed that limitation provisions must be strictly followed, but the discretion expressly conferred by statute must also be exercised judiciously after considering the circumstances of each case.
Here, the delay was merely five days, the appellant had furnished a reasonable explanation, and the appeal was within the statutory condonable period.
On those facts, the Tribunal concluded that the Commissioner (Appeals) had adopted an unduly technical approach in declining condonation. It held that sufficient cause had been established and that the order rejecting the appeal on limitation could not be sustained.
CESTAT set aside the Order-in-Appeal dated March 23, 2026, and condoned the five-day delay.
Since the Commissioner (Appeals) had not examined the substantive issue concerning admissibility of Cenvat credit, the Tribunal remanded the matter for a fresh decision on merits in accordance with law.
The appellate authority was directed to provide the company a reasonable opportunity of hearing. The appeal was accordingly allowed by way of remand.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: Old VAT Bill Book Alone Can’t Prove GST Evasion: GSTAT

