The Supreme Court has set aside a GST demand of ₹53.36 crore, including penalties, holding that the 70:30 valuation mechanism introduced for specified renewable energy projects from January 1, 2019 could not be compulsorily applied to solar power generating systems supplied and installed before that date.
The Bench of Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva held that the subsequent clarification permitting taxpayers to adopt the mechanism for earlier supplies gave them an option. It did not authorise tax authorities to impose the formula on taxpayers who had not chosen it.
The company undertook the supply and installation of solar power generating systems through Engineering, Procurement and Construction contracts at locations specified by its customers across several States.
Buy Now: 210+ GST Judgments E-Magazine – October 2026
The dispute concerned supplies made between July 1, 2017 and December 31, 2018. During this period, the company paid GST at an aggregate rate of 5%, comprising 2.5% CGST and 2.5% SGST, treating the systems as covered by Serial No. 234 of Schedule I to Notification No. 1/2017-Central Tax (Rate), dated June 28, 2017.
The tax authorities took the view that the contracts attracted the subsequently introduced mechanism under which 70% of the consideration was treated as the value of goods and 30% as the value of services. Under the rates discussed in the judgment, this produced an effective GST incidence of 8.9%.
Following a show cause-cum-demand notice dated March 29, 2023, the Joint Commissioner passed an adjudication order on January 17, 2025. A consequential summary order followed on January 24, 2025.
The CGST component was ₹13,33,95,241, with an equal penalty, totalling ₹26,67,90,482. Equivalent SGST and penalty took the total demand to ₹53,35,80,964.
High Court Should Have Examined The Challenge
The Bombay High Court dismissed the company’s writ petition on July 28, 2025, citing the availability of an efficacious statutory appellate remedy. It left the company free to pursue that remedy after complying with the prescribed pre-deposit requirement.
The Supreme Court found that the dismissal was unjustified because the writ petition raised arguable issues warranting consideration. It also noted that the High Court had referred only to the summary order, although both the adjudication order and the consequential order had been challenged.
The Bench explained that the alternate remedy rule is not an inflexible formula. Whether a High Court should entertain a writ petition depends on the individual facts of the case.
Although the matter would ordinarily have been remitted to the High Court, the Supreme Court decided the merits itself because the parties had argued the issues at length and the Andhra Pradesh High Court had already adjudicated the same controversy.
Original Entry Covered The Solar Power Generating System As A Whole
The Court examined the original rate notification alongside the GST Council’s deliberations on renewable energy.
Serial No. 234 covered specified renewable energy devices and parts for their manufacture, expressly including a solar power generating system. The Court attached significance to the inclusion of the system as a whole.
It noted that the original 5% aggregate rate reflected the policy of encouraging renewable energy production through tax incentives. The GST Council had considered concerns that higher taxation of renewable energy inputs could increase electricity costs.
Against that background, the Court found that the company’s payment of 5% GST on the supply and installation of the systems during the disputed period was consistent with the governing regime.
70:30 Valuation Mechanism Was Prospective
Following recommendations made at the GST Council’s 31st meeting, Notification No. 24/2018-Central Tax (Rate), dated December 31, 2018 inserted an explanation prescribing the deemed division of consideration.
For qualifying supplies, 70% of the gross consideration was deemed to represent goods and the remaining 30% the taxable service component. Notification No. 27/2018-Central Tax (Rate), issued on the same date, inserted the corresponding service entry in Notification No. 11/2017-Central Tax (Rate).
Both amendments took effect on January 1, 2019. The Court held that the new mechanism had no retrospective operation requiring earlier transactions to be split in that manner.
Using the judgment’s illustration, a ₹10,000 supply attracted ₹500 GST under the earlier 5% treatment. Under the subsequently introduced mechanism, 5% on ₹7,000 amounted to ₹350, while 18% on ₹3,000 amounted to ₹540, producing total GST of ₹890.
This comparison concerns the historical rates and periods examined in the judgment.
2021 Circular Gave Taxpayers An Option
The Revenue relied on Circular No. 163/19/2021-GST, dated October 6, 2021, issued following the GST Council’s 45th meeting.
The circular permitted GST on specified renewable energy projects supplied between July 1, 2017 and December 31, 2018 to be paid using the 70:30 mechanism. It also stated that refunds would not be granted where tax already paid exceeded the amount determined under that mechanism.
The Supreme Court held that the language of the clarification placed the choice with taxpayers. Permission to adopt the later mechanism for earlier supplies could not be converted into an obligation applicable to every assessee.
The authorities’ approach of applying the option compulsorily across the board, including to taxpayers who had not exercised it, was therefore erroneous and unsustainable.
The judgment also discussed Section 168 of the CGST Act, under which the Board may issue instructions or directions to secure uniform implementation. Officers must follow such directions, but the clarification at issue did not contain the retrospective mandate that the authorities sought to enforce.
Civil Foundations Did Not Automatically Make The Systems Immovable
The department had treated the contracts as works contract services under Section 2(119), referring to site development, structural foundations, cable trenches, inverter-related civil works, control buildings and other structures.
The Supreme Court held that the inclusion of civil work in an EPC contract did not automatically make the transaction a works contract.
Section 2(119) requires the relevant activity to concern immovable property. Section 2(30), by contrast, defines composite supply by reference to naturally bundled supplies provided together in the ordinary course of business, one of which is the principal supply.
The Court endorsed the distinction drawn by the Andhra Pradesh High Court: every composite supply does not necessarily qualify as a works contract. For works contract classification, the end product must involve immovable property.
In this case, it was undisputed that the solar photovoltaic panels or modules could be detached from the foundations and used elsewhere. The foundations provided stability and improved the functioning of the systems. Their purpose was not the beneficial enjoyment of the foundations themselves.
The Court therefore rejected the contention that fixation to a civil foundation, by itself, converted the systems into immovable property.
Nature And Purpose Of Attachment Matter
The Bench considered precedents addressing when installed machinery or equipment becomes immovable property, including Commissioner of Central Excise v. Solid and Correct Engineering Works and Bharti Airtel Limited v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Pune.
The relevant considerations included the nature and purpose of annexation, the parties’ intention, whether fixation merely improves operational efficiency, whether the equipment can be dismantled and relocated without damage, and whether it remains marketable.
The need to dismantle equipment before moving it does not invariably establish that it is immovable. The Court discussed the distinction applicable where equipment is brought to a site in parts, assembled there, and can subsequently be dismantled and reassembled elsewhere without damage.
Applying these principles, it approved the Andhra Pradesh High Court’s consistent approach to detachable solar power systems.
The judgment nevertheless recognised that classification depends on the individual facts of the contract and installation.
Earlier Andhra Pradesh Ruling Supported The Company
The company had relied on the Andhra Pradesh High Court’s January 10, 2025 decision in its own case concerning a separate tax demand.
That High Court had held that the solar system was attached to a civil foundation for the beneficial use of the system, rather than for permanent enjoyment of the foundation. It consequently found that the transaction did not fall within the statutory definition of a works contract.
The Supreme Court noted that the Revenue had not challenged that decision, which had attained finality.
It also discussed the Andhra Pradesh High Court’s decisions concerning wind turbine generators in Siemens Gamesa Renewable Power Private Limited and solar power pumping systems in Arka Green Power Private Limited. These decisions applied the distinction between movable equipment and immovable property to the installations before them.
Section 74 Could Not Be Invoked Through Unsupported Allegations
The adjudicating authority had alleged wilful misstatement, deliberate suppression and misclassification, invoking Section 74 and imposing penalties.
The Supreme Court held that there was no basis to attribute fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression to the company for failing to apply the 70:30 mechanism to transactions undertaken before the mechanism came into existence.
It consequently held that invocation of extended limitation was unsustainable both on facts and in law.
Referring to its decision in Tata Steel Limited v. Union of India, the Court reiterated that the foundational facts supporting allegations of fraud, wilful misrepresentation or suppression must be evident from the notice itself. Merely using those expressions does not demonstrate the application of mind required to invoke extended limitation.
Later Change In Rate Entry Could Not Be Applied Backwards
The Bench also examined Notification No. 8/2021-Central Tax (Rate), dated September 30, 2021, which omitted the earlier entry and introduced Serial No. 201A in Schedule II.
The Court noted the distinction between the earlier reference to a solar power generating system and the later reference to a solar power generator. It treated that change as supporting the conclusion that the earlier entry covered the entire system as a unit.
The subsequent substitution could not retrospectively alter the treatment of supplies and installations governed by the earlier notification.
Demand And Consequential Order Set Aside
The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and set aside the adjudication order dated January 17, 2025 and the consequential summary order dated January 24, 2025. The parties were directed to bear their own costs.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.

