The Supreme Court has set aside a judgment of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) that had invalidated a resolution plan under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC), holding that the decision was unsustainable in law as it was passed without affording an opportunity of hearing to the successful resolution applicant, whose rights were directly affected by the order.
A Bench comprising Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva held that the NCLAT had committed a flagrant violation of the principle of audi alteram partem by invalidating the resolution plan submitted by Valentis Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. (VLPL) without even impleading the company as a party or giving it an opportunity to defend its interests.
The Court observed that the denial of hearing to the most vitally affected party was, by itself, sufficient to render the NCLAT’s judgment unsustainable in law. Accordingly, the Supreme Court set aside the NCLAT judgment dated March 19, 2026, while leaving all substantive issues concerning the resolution plan open for consideration in the appeals already pending before the NCLAT.
Buy Now: 90+ Supreme Court Judgments E-Magazine – October 2026
The judgment was delivered on November 16, 2026, in Birendra Kumar Agrawal v. S2 Tech.com India Pvt. Ltd. & Anr., 2026 INSC 1225, in appeals arising under Section 62 of the IBC.
Background of the Insolvency Proceedings
The proceedings arose out of the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) initiated against Manjeera Retail Holdings Private Limited, the principal borrower, and its corporate guarantor, Manjeera Constructions Limited (MCL).
Catalyst Trusteeship Limited, a financial creditor, initiated proceedings under Section 7 of the IBC owing to defaults in repayment by the principal borrower and its corporate guarantor. Insofar as MCL was concerned, the insolvency petition was admitted by the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Hyderabad Bench-II, on July 18, 2023.
During the CIRP, S2 Tech.com India Pvt. Ltd., another financial creditor of MCL, held a 3.3% voting share in the Committee of Creditors (CoC).
Following an invitation for Expression of Interest issued by the Resolution Professional, four prospective resolution applicants submitted their resolution plans. These included Vasavi Realty Pvt. Ltd., Valentis Laboratories Pvt. Ltd., Boorugu Infra Projects Pvt. Ltd. and Gajjala Yoganand.
At its 12th meeting held on June 10, 2024, the CoC approved the resolution plan submitted by VLPL with a majority voting share of 91.64%.
Financial Creditor Challenges Resolution Plan Over Earnest Money Deposit
After the CoC approved VLPL’s resolution plan, S2 Tech.com India Pvt. Ltd. filed an application before the NCLT on July 18, 2024, seeking rejection of the resolution plan.
One of the principal objections raised by the financial creditor was that VLPL had failed to remit the earnest money deposit (EMD) within the prescribed deadline stipulated under the Request for Resolution Plan (RFRP).
The NCLT rejected the application by an order dated July 30, 2024. It observed that S2 Tech.com India Pvt. Ltd., which held only a 3.3% voting share in the CoC, had participated in the meeting in which the resolution plan was approved and could not challenge the majority decision on the grounds raised.
However, the NCLT also noted that the resolution plan was required to be examined within the parameters prescribed under the IBC.
NCLT Approves Resolution Plan Despite Pending Challenge
Meanwhile, the Resolution Professional, Birendra Kumar Agrawal, filed an application under Sections 30(6) and 31(1) of the IBC seeking approval of VLPL’s resolution plan.
The NCLT subsequently approved the resolution plan on March 26, 2025.
In the meantime, S2 Tech.com India Pvt. Ltd. had filed an appeal before the NCLAT on September 14, 2024, challenging the NCLT’s order dated July 30, 2024, which had rejected its application seeking rejection of the resolution plan.
The Supreme Court noted that when the appeal was filed, S2 Tech.com India Pvt. Ltd. was already aware that the CoC had approved VLPL’s resolution plan. Nevertheless, it did not implead VLPL, the successful resolution applicant, as a party to the appeal.
The Court further noted that even after the NCLT approved the resolution plan on March 26, 2025, the successful resolution applicant was not made a party to the pending appeal.
Although an application seeking impleadment of VLPL was reportedly filed before the NCLAT, the same was not pursued and had not even been numbered by the time the appeal was finally decided.
NCLAT Invalidates Resolution Plan Without Hearing Successful Resolution Applicant
By its judgment dated March 19, 2026, the NCLAT allowed the appeal filed by S2 Tech.com India Pvt. Ltd.
The NCLAT held that the NCLT’s order rejecting the financial creditor’s application was passed without application of mind and consequently held that VLPL’s resolution plan was liable to be declared invalid. It also issued various directions to the Resolution Professional.
However, while arriving at this conclusion, the NCLAT invalidated the resolution plan even though VLPL, the successful resolution applicant, was not a party to the proceedings and had not been afforded an opportunity to present its case.
The Supreme Court also noted that the NCLAT had travelled beyond the issues raised by S2 Tech.com India Pvt. Ltd. in its original application before the NCLT. Nevertheless, the Court expressly declined to examine the validity of the NCLAT judgment on that ground, as the violation of natural justice itself was sufficient to dispose of the appeals.
Supreme Court: Denial of Hearing to Affected Party Violates Principles of Natural Justice
Examining the circumstances in which the NCLAT invalidated the resolution plan, the Supreme Court found that the order had been passed without hearing the party whose interests were most directly affected by the outcome.
The Bench observed that the NCLAT had invalidated the resolution plan submitted by VLPL despite the fact that the company was not even a party before it.
The Court emphasised that the successful resolution applicant was subjected to serious civil consequences without being afforded an opportunity to defend its interests.
The Bench held:
“In essence, without even affording a hearing to the affected party, viz., VLPL, the successful resolution applicant, the NCLAT passed a judgment to its detriment and visiting it with dire civil consequences.”
The Supreme Court further observed that this constituted a flagrant violation of the principle of audi alteram partem, which forms an essential component of the principles of natural justice.
It held that such a violation was sufficient to render the NCLAT’s judgment dated March 19, 2026, unsustainable in law.
Supreme Court Declines to Remand Matter; Substantive Issues Left Open
The Supreme Court was also informed that separate appeals had already been filed challenging the NCLT’s order dated March 26, 2025, approving VLPL’s resolution plan.
These included an appeal filed by Gajjala Yoganand, one of the resolution applicants, being Company Appeal No. 200 of 2025; an appeal filed by the homebuyers of MCL, being Company Appeal No. 7 of 2026; and an appeal filed by Saasa Villa LLP, being Company Appeal No. 348 of 2025.
All these appeals were pending consideration before the NCLAT.
The Court further noted that the objection concerning the alleged failure of VLPL to deposit the earnest money within the prescribed time had also been raised in those pending appeals.
In view of the pending proceedings, the Supreme Court considered it unnecessary to remand the matter to the NCLAT for fresh consideration after providing VLPL an opportunity of hearing.
The Bench observed that the NCLAT had proceeded without taking into account the intervening development of the NCLT having already approved VLPL’s resolution plan. This development had a direct bearing on the subject matter of the appeal before it.
The Court, therefore, considered it appropriate to set aside the NCLAT judgment solely on the ground of violation of natural justice and leave all substantive issues to be adjudicated in the pending appeals challenging the NCLT’s resolution plan approval order.
It clarified that this approach would enable all concerned parties to effectively present their respective positions in the duly constituted proceedings.
Final Decision
Accordingly, the Supreme Court allowed the appeals and set aside the NCLAT judgment dated March 19, 2026, passed in Company Appeal (AT) (CH) (Ins) No. 456 of 2024.
The Court left all issues open for consideration in the appeals pending before the NCLAT, in which the NCLT’s order dated March 26, 2025, approving the resolution plan submitted by Valentis Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. had been challenged.
The Court did not adjudicate the merits of the objection concerning the timeline for payment of the earnest money deposit or finally determine the validity of the resolution plan on substantive grounds.
The judgment thus reinforces the requirement that an adjudicatory authority cannot invalidate an approved resolution plan while imposing serious civil consequences upon the successful resolution applicant without first providing it an effective opportunity of hearing.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: No Prior Sanction Needed to Prosecute Survey Officer Over Alleged Land Record Forgery: Supreme Court

