The Delhi High Court has dismissed the Customs Department’s appeal against an order setting aside the revocation of a customs broker’s licence, holding that exporters’ PAN and Aadhaar documents could not be rejected merely because the broker had not met them, particularly when the department had not alleged that the documents were forged.
The Bench of Justice Avneesh Jhingan and Justice Shail Jain upheld the findings of the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal that no violation of Regulation 10(n) of the Customs Brokers Licensing Regulations, 2018 had been established.
Buy Now: Indirect Tax Judgments E-Compilation – October 2026
The proceedings originated from an Analytics Report dated May 4, 2023, received from the Additional Director General, NCTC-DGARM, Mumbai. The report flagged alleged fraudulent exports by non-existent entities and referred to the respondent customs broker.
A show cause notice was issued on August 23, 2023, following which an inquiry officer was appointed. In a report dated November 15, 2023, the officer concluded that the broker had failed to comply with its obligations under Regulation 10(n).
The broker maintained that it had obtained the exporters’ KYC documents before processing the consignments. It stated that the Importer Exporter Code had been verified through the DGFT website, PAN through the Income Tax Department’s website and GSTIN through the GST portal.
The judgment also records the broker’s claim that field-level enquiries had been conducted to verify the exporters’ addresses.
Through an Order-in-Original dated January 31, 2024, the adjudicating authority revoked the broker’s licence, forfeited its security deposit and imposed a ₹50,000 penalty.
The authority proceeded on the basis that, for a proprietorship concern, at least two documents prescribed under Circular No. 09/2010-Cus were required to be submitted by the exporters. It concluded that the broker had violated Regulation 10(n).
However, the adjudicating authority also noted that the Analytics Report contained no physical verification report. Further, the exporters had filed GST returns even after the export period, and the broker had submitted their IEC and GST registration certificates as part of the KYC process.
The broker challenged the order before the CESTAT’s Principal Bench, which set it aside on February 24, 2025. The department subsequently appealed to the High Court under Section 130 of the Customs Act, 1962.
The department argued that the tribunal had overlooked the violations detailed in the adjudication order. It contended that the broker’s reply before the adjudicating authority indicated that the exporters’ KYC documents had not been produced at that stage.
According to the department, the tribunal had wrongly considered documents produced for the first time before it.
The department also claimed that documents annexed to the broker’s reply before the High Court bore different signatures and invited the Bench to compare them.
The broker relied on the tribunal’s factual findings and submitted that interference under Section 130 was confined to substantial questions of law.
The High Court examined the relevant portion of the circular dated April 8, 2010, alongside the inquiry report. It noted that the circular had been modified on February 12, 2015, to include Aadhaar among the prescribed documents.
The Bench agreed with the tribunal that obtaining the PAN and Aadhaar cards satisfied the circular’s requirements in the circumstances of the case.
Crucially, the inquiry officer had not rejected the broker’s submission that PAN cards, Aadhaar cards and authorisations had been submitted. Instead, the officer’s objection rested on the broker’s failure to meet the exporters and the perceived absence of proper verification through them.
The High Court endorsed the tribunal’s conclusion that the documents could not be rejected merely because the broker had not met the exporters, especially when the department had not alleged that they were forged.
The Court also recorded the admitted position that the authority which prepared the Analytics Report had not conducted physical verification.
The Bench rejected the department’s contention that the tribunal had granted relief based on documents submitted for the first time before it.
The tribunal’s decision, the Court explained, rested on the absence of a finding in the inquiry report that the KYC documents had not been produced or were forged. Consequently, the foundation of the department’s allegation of a Regulation 10(n) violation had not been established.
The Court additionally noted that the department itself had accepted and relied upon the inquiry report.
This distinction was central to the decision: the tribunal had examined whether the inquiry findings supported the alleged violation, rather than allowing the appeal on the strength of fresh documentary evidence.
The Bench declined the department’s invitation to compare signatures on documents annexed to the broker’s reply.
It held that undertaking such an exercise would require the High Court to act as an appellate authority on facts, rather than exercise its jurisdiction under Section 130 of the Customs Act.
The Court concluded that the tribunal’s decision was based on factual findings and disclosed no legal or factual error, much less perversity. Finding that no substantial question of law arose, it dismissed the department’s appeal and the pending application.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.

