The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Chennai, has held by a majority that commitment charges collected by a bank for keeping sanctioned loan funds available to borrowers attract service tax under “Banking and Other Financial Services”.
The bench of Ajayan T.V. (Judicial Member), P. Dinesha (Judicial Member) and M. Ajit Kumar (Technical Member) restricted the tax and interest liability to the normal limitation period, set aside the extended-period demand and removed penalties. It also directed recalculation of the liability after granting cum-tax benefit.
Buy Now: Indirect Tax Judgments E-Compilation – October 2026
The proceedings concerned assessee Bank which collected commitment charges from customers who did not avail themselves of sanctioned loan facilities.
During the financial years 2007–08 to 2011–12, the bank collected ₹1,14,80,950 under this head. The department treated these receipts as consideration for taxable banking services and raised a service tax demand of ₹12,76,769.
The original adjudicating authority confirmed the demand under Section 73 of the Finance Act, 1994, along with interest under Section 75 and penalties under Sections 77 and 78.
The Commissioner (Appeals) upheld the demand but set aside the penalty under Section 77. The bank subsequently challenged the appellate order before CESTAT.
The bank argued that commitment charges compensate a lender for the loss of interest when a borrower delays drawing down a sanctioned loan.
According to the bank, the sanctioned funds remain available for the borrower despite not being disbursed. Charges calculated on the undisbursed amount therefore represent interest in substance, even though they are described differently for accounting purposes.
It relied on definitions of interest under the Interest Act and the Income-tax Act and contended that the receipts should be excluded from taxable value.
The bank also disputed the extended limitation period and penalties. It maintained that the dispute involved interpretation of the law, that there was no suppression or intention to evade tax, and that the department itself issued a clarification only in October 2011.
Alternatively, it sought cum-tax treatment and waiver of penalty on grounds of bona fide belief and reasonable cause.
Payment Secured The Bank’s Commitment To Lend
Member (Technical) M. Ajit Kumar held that commitment charges involved a direct exchange between the borrower and the bank: the borrower paid for the bank’s contractual commitment to lend the sanctioned amount at a future date.
The payment secured the assured performance of a service and was distinguishable from interest charged for the use of money already lent.
“The charge is not on the money lent; it is on the money that sits idle in the bank,” the Member (Technical) observed.
The reasoning was that the borrower obtained additional time to draw the sanctioned facility while the bank continued to honour its commitment to make the funds available.
Accordingly, the charges formed part of the gross amount charged for the taxable service under Section 67 of the Finance Act, 1994.
Definitions Under Other Statutes Could Not Be Automatically Applied
The Member (Technical) declined to determine the service tax treatment merely by importing definitions of interest from other enactments.
Relying on the Supreme Court’s decision in Hari Khemu Gawali v. Deputy Commissioner of Police, Bombay, the order cautioned against interpreting one statute through decisions concerning other statutes that may not address the same subject in the same manner.
The Member (Technical) also rejected the bank’s interpretation of Rule 6(2)(iv) of the Service Tax (Determination of Value) Rules, 2006. He treated the exclusion reproduced in the order as relating to interest on delayed payment of consideration, rather than the commitment charges under dispute.
Conflicting Decisions Triggered Judicial Discipline Issue
Member (Judicial) Ajayan T.V. took a different approach because two coordinate bench decisions had expressed conflicting views on the taxability of commitment charges.
The first was Punjab National Bank v. Commissioner of Service Tax, Raipur, reported at 2019 (4) TMI 813–CESTAT New Delhi, decided on December 20, 2018.
The second was Bank of Baroda v. Commissioner of Service Tax, Mumbai, reported at 2021 (45) G.S.T.L. 381, decided on August 21, 2019.
The earlier division bench decision supported exclusion of commitment charges from taxable value. The Mumbai decision, however, treated the creation of a clear line of credit as a service supplied for consideration.
The Member (Judicial) refrained from expressing an opinion on the merits. He considered a reference to a larger bench necessary to resolve the conflict in accordance with judicial discipline.
The original members also disagreed over the formulation of the questions arising from their difference of opinion. The records were directed to be placed before the tribunal’s President for further action.
Third Member Supported Taxability
On reference, Member (Judicial) P. Dinesha heard the parties on August 13, 2026, and agreed with the Member (Technical)’s conclusion on taxability.
The third member noted that the Bank of Baroda decision had considered an earlier ruling in Punjab National Bank’s own case, reported at 2015 (38) S.T.R. 498.
That earlier ruling treated commitment charges as integrally connected with lending and liable to service tax. The third member further noted that this decision had not been placed before the bench that delivered the subsequent December 2018 ruling in the bank’s case.
Finding the Mumbai bench’s reasoning just and reasonable, he held that commitment charges were liable to service tax and supported the Member (Technical)’s conclusion for the reasons recorded in his separate opinion.
Although taxability was upheld, the majority outcome granted substantial relief on limitation and penalties.
The Member (Technical) found that the dispute involved an interpretational issue, as reflected in the clarification issued through CBEC Circular No. 137/62/2011-ST dated October 21, 2011.
In those circumstances, a case of misdeclaration or suppression of facts was not established. Tax and interest therefore had to be confined to the normal limitation period.
The order also held that the circumstances did not justify penalties. Consequently, the extended-period demand and penalties were set aside.
The tribunal accepted the bank’s alternative claim for cum-tax treatment.
Under the directions adopted in the majority order, the consideration received would be treated as inclusive of service tax unless the customer had separately paid service tax.
The taxable value must therefore be calculated backwards from the amount received, consistent with Section 67(2) of the Finance Act, 1994. Tax must be recalculated on that basis, with interest computed accordingly.
Consequently, the original ₹12,76,769 demand does not represent the unchanged amount finally payable following the tribunal’s decision.
Final Majority Order
The final division bench order upheld the impugned Order-in-Appeal in terms of the findings and directions of the Member (Technical).
The resulting position is that commitment charges are taxable, but recovery is restricted to the normal limitation period, with cum-tax recalculation and without penalties. The bank is entitled to consequential relief in accordance with those directions.
The ruling concerns the service tax regime and receipts relating to April 2007–March 2012.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: Customs Penalties U/s 112, 114 Doesn’t Bar Special Warehouse Licence: CESTAT

