The Supreme Court has restored a trial court’s award of ₹8.70 lakh in compensation, along with interest at 6%, to a girl whose right hand was amputated after she suffered injuries from a live electricity wire. The Court held that a civil claim supported by credible evidence cannot be rejected merely because an appellate court considers the incident suspicious or unbelievable.
A Bench of Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar set aside the Rajasthan High Court’s judgment dismissing the compensation suit against Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited (JVVNL) and others. Justice Shree Chandrashekhar authored the reportable judgment delivered on November 16, 2026.
Buy Now: 90+ Supreme Court Judgments E-Magazine – October 2026
Girl Lost Her Right Hand After Contact With Live Wire
The claimant, who was a minor at the relevant time, alleged that she suffered electrocution injuries at around 7 a.m. on July 15, 2011. According to her case, transmission lines running between villages had loosened over the preceding days, leaving wires hanging approximately three to four feet above the ground.
While passing through Harivansh ka Pura-Pathaur ka Pura village, she attempted to move the wires out of her way. The wire was live, and the resulting electric shock caused severe burns over a substantial part of her body.
She was initially taken to the Primary Health Centre at Basedi and subsequently to a doctor at Badi. As her condition did not improve, she was taken to Agra four days later for further treatment. Her right hand was amputated, leaving her with a permanent disability.
She stated that a Daily Diary Report was recorded at Basedi police station on August 18, 2011, but no action followed.
Electricity Utility Disputed The Incident
The respondents denied negligence and described the account of electrocution as imaginary and concocted to obtain compensation. They contended that anyone coming into contact with an 11 kV electricity line would have died on the spot.
They also denied that an 11 kV line was hanging close to the ground at the alleged location. Their written statement further asserted that no low-tension electricity line passed through the village that could have caused the injuries in the manner alleged.
During cross-examination, the claimant was confronted with a suggestion that she had suffered an electric shock at home while removing a jumper wire. She denied that suggestion and maintained that the accident occurred because the respondents failed to maintain the transmission lines properly.
Trial Court Awarded Compensation, High Court Reversed It
The trial court decreed Civil Case No. 02 of 2015 and directed payment of ₹8,70,000 with interest at 6% until payment.
The High Court, however, allowed the utility’s first appeal. It referred to inconsistencies in the witnesses’ accounts concerning the hanging wires and the delay in reporting the incident to the police. It also questioned how the claimant could have survived contact with the wire in the manner described.
The High Court further held that documents had merely been exhibited without being proved and concluded that the incident itself was not established. On that basis, it rejected the compensation claim and held that strict or absolute liability could not apply when the occurrence was doubtful.
Civil Suits Must Be Decided On Evidence
The Supreme Court found that the High Court had committed serious errors of law by interfering with a well-considered trial court judgment on unsupported assertions.
“A civil suit should be decided on the basis of evidence produced by the parties and not by merely raising a doubt,” the Court observed.
It noted that the claimant had described the incident clearly and in sufficient detail. Her witnesses supported her account and stated that complaints had been made about the transmission lines hanging dangerously close to the ground.
The respondents had a full opportunity during trial to test these accounts and bring out material facts capable of undermining the witnesses’ credibility. However, their challenges were confined to insignificant matters, and the claimant’s evidence remained unshaken on the material aspects of the case.
Utility’s Witness Offered Hearsay Evidence
The Supreme Court attached significance to the admissions made by the JVVNL employee examined for the defence.
Although the employee repeated the version that the claimant suffered an electric shock at home, he admitted that he had not witnessed the incident and was not even on duty that day. He also acknowledged that maintaining the transmission lines was the respondents’ responsibility.
The Court consequently found that the defence advanced through this witness was hearsay. The suggestion concerning a jumper wire at home was unsupported by any proven fact or documentary material.
The respondents could have produced positive evidence showing that the transmission lines were in good condition and the wires were positioned properly. They failed to produce such evidence to substantiate their denial of responsibility.
Preponderance Of Probability Governs Civil Claims
The Court explained that a plaintiff in a civil suit need not establish the case beyond reasonable doubt. The applicable test is the preponderance of probability, requiring an assessment of how probable the plaintiff’s account is on the evidence before the court.
The Bench clarified that this standard involves more than a mere possibility: the evidence must demonstrate a fair degree of certainty. It held that the trial court had applied the correct test in accepting the claimant’s case and awarding compensation.
The Supreme Court also referred to Section 3 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, under which proof turns on whether the court believes a fact exists or considers its existence sufficiently probable for a prudent person to act on that basis in the circumstances.
Minor Inconsistencies Do Not Justify Rejecting The Entire Case
The Bench stressed that every omission or inconsistency in a witness’s testimony does not become material in a civil trial.
The High Court had disbelieved the entire occurrence because it appeared suspicious, without a finding that the claimant’s witnesses were unreliable or had lied. The Supreme Court held that the evidence had to be evaluated for its substance and truthfulness.
It also rejected the treatment of the medical documents as decisive against the claimant. Her case rested primarily on witness testimony, while the medical records were supporting materials. The objection concerning proof of the documents did not justify disregarding the oral evidence supporting the occurrence and injuries.
Limits On Appellate Interference
The Supreme Court explained that an appellate court may interfere where a trial court’s judgment suffers from a material irregularity, relies on inadmissible evidence or misreads the evidence.
However, suspicion alone cannot justify reversal. Trial court findings on witness testimony should normally prevail unless the trial judge has overlooked vital defects in that testimony.
The Bench cautioned against a fault-finding exercise that treats every mistake, delay or inconsistency as sufficient reason to overturn the result. In this case, the delay in lodging the complaint and the discrepancies relied upon by the High Court did not warrant rejection of otherwise credible evidence.
In discussing the opportunity to challenge witnesses, the Court referred to Sections 146 and 155 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, dealing with cross-examination and impeachment of a witness’s credit. It also discussed Section 4 in relation to statutory presumptions.
Strict Liability Applied; Compensation Restored
The Supreme Court concluded that the matter attracted the respondents’ strict liability and that the High Court should not have interfered with the compensation award.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.

