Ask Jurishour AI

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
tdb_templates
saswp_reviews
saswp-collections
saswp_rvs_location
tdc-review-email
web-story-font
web-story
googlesitekit_email
tds_locker
tds_email
saswp
mailpoet_page
mailpoet_email
tdcpt_tunes
tdc-review
pronamic_payment
pronamic_gateway
pronamic_pay_subscr
wpcode
HomeIndirect TaxesOld VAT Bill Book Alone Can’t Prove GST Evasion: GSTAT 

Old VAT Bill Book Alone Can’t Prove GST Evasion: GSTAT 

Published on

🚀 Stay Connected With JurisHour

WhatsApp X Telegram

The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Prayagraj Bench, has set aside a demand of approximately ₹3.10 lakh against a book and stationery trader, holding that the use of a cash memo book bearing an old VAT identification number did not, by itself, establish suppression of turnover with intent to evade GST.

The Division Bench comprising Mahtab Ahmad (Judicial Member) and Ashish Varma (Technical Member) found that the department had neither established the foundational facts required to invoke Section 74 nor provided a rational basis for calculating the alleged unreported turnover.

Buy Now: All 200+ GSTAT Judgements Till November 2026 | Comprehensive E-Magazine

Allowing the appeal on November 16, 2026, the tribunal directed withdrawal of the consequential recovery proceedings and refund of the appeal pre-deposits with interest, subject to verification of the amounts actually paid and not already refunded.

The appellant/assessee is a partnership firm trading in books, notebooks and stationery at Civil Lines, Prayagraj, for July 2017 to March 2018.

The Special Investigation Branch surveyed its premises on March 31, 2018, at approximately 4:10 pm. The survey material recorded sales of around ₹70,000 up to that time and referred to entries in the Busy accounting software.

A stock list was prepared, but the tribunal noted that it had neither been totalled nor reconciled with the books, purchase invoices or stock register.

The department also relied on a cash memo book recording stationery sales of ₹16,909 between February 24 and March 28, 2018. The book carried a VAT TIN instead of the GSTIN.

A show cause notice issued on December 30, 2020, invoked Section 74, drawing adverse inferences from the survey observations, the old bill book, the absence of stock verification and the trader’s failure to produce its books pursuant to a summons.

The notice calculated tax on turnover of ₹1.67 lakh for each of the nine months under dispute. Every month, it applied aggregate GST rates of 5% to ₹1 lakh and 12% to ₹67,000.

This resulted in estimated turnover of ₹15.03 lakh and tax of ₹1,17,360. The tribunal found that the notice did not explain how these identical monthly figures had been derived.

An ex parte adjudication order subsequently confirmed the tax, interest and an equivalent penalty. The first appellate authority upheld the demand after recording that the trader had been given several hearing opportunities.

Before GSTAT, the trader challenged both the invocation of Section 74 and the computation. It submitted that printed books constituted more than 82% of its turnover and that the survey took place during the seasonal sales peak before the academic session.

The tribunal held that fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax are conditions for invoking Section 74, and the Revenue bears the burden of establishing them.

It found that the notice merely asserted suppression and misstatement without identifying facts demonstrating that tax had been withheld.

The notice did not identify information omitted from the returns, establish unaccounted purchases, demonstrate stock shortages or excesses, or reconcile the survey findings with returns available on the GST portal.

The tribunal also examined Explanation 2 to Section 74. It held that the explanation did not dispense with the requirement that the non-payment or short-payment must arise from suppression with intent to evade tax.

The bench rejected the contention that non-attendance pursuant to the summons established purchases and sales outside the books.

Such non-attendance was a default with its own statutory consequences. However, the inference that transactions had been concealed remained conjectural without supporting evidence.

Similarly, failure to respond to subsequent notices could permit the officer to decide on the available record, but could not supply foundational facts missing when the notice was issued.

The tribunal referred to Section 75(7), which prevents confirmation of a demand on grounds beyond those specified in the notice.

Examining the cash memo book, the tribunal observed that the memos recorded transactions. The Revenue had not shown that the ₹16,909 reflected in them was excluded from the books or returns.

The bench distinguished a defect in the format of a bill from evidence of suppression with intent to evade tax.

Any separate issue concerning invoice compliance under Section 31 and the rules could not be introduced into the Section 74 demand on grounds absent from the notice. The tribunal confined its observations to the disputed demand and did not decide whether use of the old bill book was inadvertent.

The tribunal identified a substantial contradiction in the adjudication order.

While the order described ₹15.03 lakh as declared turnover and imposed tax on that amount, its concluding finding referred to evaded turnover of only ₹1,30,200.

Tax of ₹1,17,360 on alleged evaded turnover of ₹1,30,200 implied a rate of approximately 90.14%, the tribunal noted.

It contrasted this with the combined statutory ceilings under Section 9(1) of the Central and Uttar Pradesh GST enactments. This was a comparison with the statutory ceilings, rather than a finding that those ceiling rates applied to the goods concerned.

If ₹15.03 lakh represented declared turnover, the order did not establish that tax remained unpaid or give credit for tax already paid. If it represented undisclosed turnover, the tribunal found no supporting material for that figure.

The bench also held that sales observed on one afternoon during a seasonal peak could not be extrapolated across the preceding nine months without corroboration.

The trader’s sales details showed total turnover of ₹36,98,572.75, including exempt or other supplies of ₹30,56,506.46, stated to be mainly printed school books.

Approximately 82.64% of the stated turnover therefore comprised exempt supplies. The Revenue had not demonstrated a mismatch with those details.

The tribunal referred to the exemption for printed books under Serial No. 119 of Notification No. 2/2017-Central Tax (Rate), dated June 28, 2017, and the corresponding State notification.

It also referred to Section 31(3)(c), read with Rule 49, concerning bills of supply for exempt supplies.

Neither the survey nor the notice separated exempt printed books from taxable stationery. A demand treating the entire turnover as taxable consequently lacked a basis.

The tribunal did not invalidate the proceedings merely because notices were served electronically. It recognised email and portal service as valid modes under Section 169(1)(c) and (d).

It also found no breach of natural justice arising from the hearing opportunities provided.

However, the authorities remained bound to examine the material and provide reasons.

Section 75(6) required the adjudicating officer to state the relevant facts and basis of the decision. Sections 107(11) and 107(12) required the first appellate authority to examine the appeal and record the points for determination, its decisions and reasons.

The tribunal found that the appellate order failed to address the returns, the exemption for printed books, the calculation of the demand and the absence of facts supporting Section 74. It also noted that the authority had mixed the language of Section 73(1) with the penalty under Section 74(1).

The tribunal declined to remand the case because the complete record was available and the defects went to the foundation of the notice and the calculation of the demand.

It separately considered Section 75(2), which provides for determination as if a notice had been issued under Section 73 where the fraud-related basis for Section 74 fails.

The bench held that its findings extended beyond the absence of fraud: the Revenue had not established any unpaid or short-paid tax. There was therefore no tax shown to be payable for redetermination under Section 75(2).

The tribunal set aside the adjudication and first appellate orders, together with their corresponding demand summaries.

ComponentAmount set aside
Tax₹1,17,360.00
Interest₹75,569.76
Penalty₹1,17,360.00
Total₹3,10,289.76

With the tax demand failing, the consequential interest and penalty could not survive.

The tribunal directed refund with interest of pre-deposits of ₹14,670 under Section 107(6) and ₹11,736 under Section 112(8), to the extent actually paid and not already refunded. No costs were imposed.

Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy

To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.

Membership Required

You must be a member to access this content.

View Membership Levels

Already a member? Log in here

Read More: Customs Penalties U/s 112, 114 Doesn’t Bar Special Warehouse Licence: CESTAT

Nikhil Bhandari
Nikhil Bhandari
Nikhil Bhandari is a Chartered Accountant and a Indirect Tax professional with over 5 years of post-qualification experience in tax advisory, compliance management, and tax process optimization. Associated with SDU LLP since August 2015 spanning his articleship through to his current role as Manager Nikhil has uniquely navigated India’s transition from the legacy tax regime into the GST era.His expertise encompasses both strategic advisory and Indirect Tax litigation, where he represents clients in complex disputes across the manufacturing, service, and e-commerce sectors. By providing high-level counsel to corporate leadership, he ensures that tax positions are not only robust and compliant but also structured for long-term operational efficiency.Beyond his core practice, Nikhil is a proactive contributor to the GST ecosystem. He is dedicated to tracking and analyzing judicial precedents from various High Courts and the Supreme Court, fostering greater clarity and ease of access to tax intelligence for the wider professional community.

Latest articles

GST Credit on IPO Expenses: Who Bears the Tax When Promoters Sell Their Shares?

A fresh issue raises capital for the company. An offer for sale pays the...

Customs Penalties U/s 112, 114 Doesn’t Bar Special Warehouse Licence: CESTAT

The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Kolkata, has held that penalties...

No Consignment Note, No GTA Service Tax: CESTAT Quashes Rs. 2.73 Crore Demand Against Truck Operator

The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Kolkata, has set aside a...

Budget 2027-28: Sitharaman Holds First Consultation With Economists; Industry Seeks Capital Gains Tax Relief

Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman chaired the first pre-Budget consultation with leading economists in...

More like this

GST Credit on IPO Expenses: Who Bears the Tax When Promoters Sell Their Shares?

A fresh issue raises capital for the company. An offer for sale pays the...

Customs Penalties U/s 112, 114 Doesn’t Bar Special Warehouse Licence: CESTAT

The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Kolkata, has held that penalties...

No Consignment Note, No GTA Service Tax: CESTAT Quashes Rs. 2.73 Crore Demand Against Truck Operator

The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Kolkata, has set aside a...