The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Kolkata, has set aside a service tax demand of ₹2.73 crore against a truck operator transporting coal and iron, holding that road transportation undertaken without issuing consignment notes did not qualify as Goods Transport Agency (GTA) services under the Finance Act, 1994.
The Bench of R. Muralidhar (Judicial Member) and K. Anpazhakan (Technical Member) also held that the department could not mechanically treat turnover disclosed in income-tax records as taxable service receipts without independently establishing the nature of the transactions.
Buy Now: Indirect Tax Judgments E-Compilation – October 2026
The bench set aside the tax, interest and penalties under Sections 77(1)(c)(ii) and 78, while retaining the ₹10,000 procedural penalty under Section 77(2).
The appellant/assessee operated from Belpahar in Odisha’s Jharsuguda district and transported coal and iron for clients across India.
The department initiated scrutiny using information shared by the Central Board of Direct Taxes. The appellant’s income-tax return disclosed sales or gross receipts from services of ₹18,23,40,433, while payments or credits reflected under Sections 194C, 194H, 194I and 194J of the Income-tax Act amounted to ₹5,18,74,009.
The department adopted the higher turnover figure, treated the entire amount as consideration for taxable services and applied a rate of 15%, calculating service tax of ₹2,73,51,065, inclusive of cesses.
A show cause notice dated June 30, 2021 invoked the extended limitation period. The Commissioner subsequently confirmed the demand through an order dated July 3, 2024, together with interest, an equivalent penalty under Section 78, ₹2,98,000 under Section 77(1)(c)(ii), and ₹10,000 under Section 77(2).
The appellant argued that it functioned solely as a truck owner and operator undertaking physical transportation of goods. It maintained that it never issued consignment notes and therefore could not be classified as a GTA.
The nature of its business had been disclosed to the department in a reply dated July 2, 2020, accompanied by its income-tax return acknowledgement and audited balance sheet.
However, the appellant attributed its inability to produce fully collated vehicle-wise, party-wise and banking records during the initial inquiry to operational disruptions during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Before the tribunal, it submitted work orders, transport challans, vehicle lists, party-wise ledgers, bank statements and audited accounts to establish the nature of its activities and receipts.
The Revenue defended the adjudication order and objected that the specific argument concerning non-issuance of consignment notes had been raised subsequently.
The tribunal admitted the additional evidence under Rule 23(1) of the CESTAT (Procedure) Rules, 1982.
It observed that the documents directly concerned the actual activities undertaken, the legal character of the receipts and whether the statutory prerequisites for imposing service tax were satisfied. Their consideration was therefore necessary for an effective determination of the dispute.
Rejecting the objection to the consignment-note argument, the Bench held that legal questions concerning the taxability of a transaction could be raised at any stage.
It also noted that the appellant’s transportation business was already known to the department. Nevertheless, the adjudicating authority had failed to examine whether the appellant issued consignment notes.
The tribunal explained that transportation of goods by road fell within the negative list under Section 66D(p)(i)(A), subject to the exceptions concerning GTA and courier services.
For classification as a GTA under Section 65B(26), read with Rule 4B of the Service Tax Rules, 1994, issuance of a consignment note was an indispensable requirement.
On examining the contracts and supporting records, the Bench found that the appellant operated as a subcontracted goods transport operator providing physical road haulage.
The work orders restricted its role to transporting goods according to the requirements of principal contractors or customers. Freight was fixed on a per-metric-tonne basis and similar transportation terms, supporting the conclusion that the contracts concerned movement of goods rather than taxable hiring of vehicles or supply of tangible goods.
The tribunal further held that contractual provisions permitting recovery for shortages or imposing penalties merely allocated commercial risk between the principal contractor and subcontractor. Such provisions did not satisfy the statutory requirement of issuing a consignment note.
The tribunal examined the transport challans and loading slips and found that they were generated by the principal transport companies, rather than the appellant.
These documents omitted statutory particulars contemplated under Rule 4B, including consignor details and the declaration concerning service tax liability.
The Bench treated them as internal trip-tracking and advance-disbursement slips. They could not be regarded as consignment notes issued by the appellant.
Party-wise ledgers also corroborated the appellant’s position, with principal transporters generally recording its earnings as freight expenses.
The Revenue failed to produce contrary evidence showing that the appellant had issued consignment notes. The tribunal consequently held that its transportation activities fell within the negative list.
In reaching this conclusion, the Bench relied on its earlier decision in Tabassum Enterprises v. Commissioner of CGST & Central Excise, Kolkata South, which addressed transportation services undertaken without consignment notes.
As an alternative ground, the tribunal observed that even if the activities were assumed to constitute GTA services, the reverse charge provisions required consideration.
Under Rule 2(1)(d)(i)(B) of the Service Tax Rules, read with Notification No. 30/2012-ST dated June 20, 2012, liability in respect of freight paid by specified categories of recipients rested on those recipients.
The Bench noted that several payers appearing in the appellant’s records fell within the specified categories. The adjudicating authority should therefore have examined the recipient-wise liability before confirming the demand against the operator.
The tribunal independently found a foundational defect in the department’s reliance on income-tax figures without conducting an investigation into the underlying transactions.
It explained that, under Section 66B, the department had to identify the service provided, establish its taxability and determine the taxable consideration.
The entire turnover appearing in an income-tax return could not automatically be treated as taxable service income.
The Bench emphasised that the initial burden of establishing taxability rested with the Revenue. The appellant’s difficulty in immediately producing records supporting its position could not substitute for that inquiry.
Referring to decisions including Rishu Enterprise and Quest Engineers & Consultant Pvt. Ltd., the tribunal rejected the mechanical adoption of income-tax receipts as the basis for service tax liability.
The tribunal held that the demand depended entirely on the extended period under Section 73(1), since the normal limitation period had expired in 2019.
It found no deliberate act of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression with intent to evade tax. The receipts had been disclosed in income-tax records, and the appellant had explained its business and furnished financial documents during the inquiry.
The Bench observed that failure to obtain registration or file ST-3 returns did not automatically establish suppression, particularly where the operator acted under a bona fide understanding that its activities were outside the levy.
It further held that difficulty in producing historical vehicle-wise and trip-wise records during the pandemic could not retrospectively establish fraudulent intent for financial year 2016–17.
The tribunal also observed that pandemic-related extensions of limitation could not revive a demand whose normal limitation period had already expired before the pandemic began.
CESTAT set aside the ₹2,73,51,065 service tax demand, along with consequential interest under Section 75.
It also set aside the equivalent penalty under Section 78 and the ₹2,98,000 penalty under Section 77(1)(c)(ii) for failure to produce documents.
However, the tribunal expressly declined to interfere with the ₹10,000 penalty under Section 77(2). The adjudication order was modified accordingly, with consequential relief, if any, as permitted by law.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.

