The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) has significantly expanded its tax audit quality review programme, selecting 1,000 companies with turnover of ₹100 crore or more for examination of their reports for assessment year 2024–25.
The expanded sample represents a tenfold increase from the 100 companies covered in the previous selection year. Approximately 867 reports had been examined when the development was reported, with recurring reporting deficiencies identified during the exercise.
According to the Financial Express clipping reproduced in ICAI’s journal, the institute also intended to widen the review further in the following cycle, signalling a sustained focus on improving tax audit reporting.
Buy Now: All 200+ GSTAT Judgements Till November 2026 | Comprehensive E-Magazine
Greater Focus on Compliance and Audit Quality
ICAI President Prasanna Kumar D said the expansion was aimed at improving compliance and strengthening quality checks.
The larger sample gives the institute a broader basis for examining reporting practices across businesses. It can also help reveal recurring issues that may not become apparent when a relatively small number of reports are reviewed.
The exercise concerns the quality of tax audit reporting. Selection for review does not, by itself, establish tax evasion by a company or professional misconduct by its auditor.
Companies Across Five Turnover Categories Selected
The selected companies fall within five turnover categories, covering businesses in the ₹100 crore–₹1,000 crore range as well as enterprises with turnover of ₹10,000 crore or more.
The exercise extends across manufacturing and trading, banking, financial services, insurance, information technology, services, infrastructure and other businesses.
Coverage across different industries allows the institute to examine reporting practices in companies with varied financial structures and transaction patterns. Comparing observations across turnover groups may also help distinguish isolated mistakes from wider reporting problems.
Quality Review Board Examines Reporting Requirements
The review is being conducted through ICAI’s Taxation Audit Quality Review Board (TAQRB), which examines compliance with applicable reporting requirements.
The board’s involvement places the completeness and accuracy of tax audit disclosures under closer examination. The exercise is intended to strengthen reporting standards and identify areas where auditors need to improve their work.
For the profession, the expanded review reinforces the importance of examining supporting records carefully and ensuring that disclosures accurately reflect the information available.
Recurring Deficiencies Found, Detailed Breakdown Not Disclosed
While recurring deficiencies were identified, the institute had not publicly provided a detailed classification of the issues found in the reviewed reports.
It also did not disclose how many of the approximately 867 reports examined contained deficiencies. The review count therefore cannot be treated as the number of defective reports.
Without a report-wise or category-wise breakdown, the available information does not establish the prevalence or seriousness of the observations across the selected companies.
The reported information also did not confirm whether any cases had been escalated for disciplinary action. Identifying a reporting deficiency during a quality review is distinct from reaching a final finding of professional misconduct.
Auditors Informed of Gaps and Observations
ICAI stated that the tax auditors of the reviewed companies had been informed of the relevant gaps and observations.
Communicating these findings gives auditors an opportunity to examine the concerns and improve their reporting processes. The effectiveness of the exercise will depend partly on whether the issues identified are addressed in subsequent audit work.
The expanded coverage also creates an opportunity for the institute to identify areas where additional professional guidance or clarification may be useful.
Broader Review Signals Closer Professional Oversight
The tenfold increase in the selection sample indicates greater attention to the quality of tax audit reporting across large businesses.
For companies and their auditors, the development highlights the importance of reliable records, complete disclosures and careful review before reports are finalised.
However, the specific nature of the recurring deficiencies, the number of affected reports and any resulting disciplinary action remain matters requiring further disclosure.
Read More: Service Tax Dept.’s Appeal Below Appeal Limit Of Rs. Rs. 60 Lakhs Dismissed: CESTAT

