Ask Jurishour AI

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
tdb_templates
saswp_reviews
saswp-collections
saswp_rvs_location
tdc-review-email
web-story-font
web-story
googlesitekit_email
tds_locker
tds_email
saswp
mailpoet_page
mailpoet_email
tdcpt_tunes
tdc-review
pronamic_payment
pronamic_gateway
pronamic_pay_subscr
wpcode
HomeIndirect TaxesMerely Reproducing SCN Reply Is Not Reasoned Adjudication: CESTAT 

Merely Reproducing SCN Reply Is Not Reasoned Adjudication: CESTAT 

Published on

🚀 Stay Connected With JurisHour

WhatsApp X Telegram

The Mumbai Bench of the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT) has set aside a service tax adjudication order concerning alleged copyright services after finding that the adjudicating authority reproduced the taxpayer’s detailed reply without properly examining its factual and legal submissions.

The bench of S.K. Mohanty (Judicial Member) and M.M. Parthiban (Technical Member) noted that the reply was reproduced from pages 126 to 158 of the adjudication order, while the findings were confined to two paragraphs containing barely 12–14 lines. The order was passed on the very next day after the reply was filed.

Buy Now: Indirect Tax Judgments E-Compilation – October 2026

The appeals challenged an Order-in-Original passed by the Commissioner of CGST, Mumbai West. The dispute concerned service tax liability in respect of alleged copyright services during 2012–15.

The company argued that the adjudicating authority had failed to properly examine the allegations in the show cause notices alongside the defence submissions made in response.

It specifically pointed out that its reply was filed on September 30, 2025, whereas the adjudication order was passed on October 1, 2025. According to the company, the arguments advanced in the reply were not properly considered before concluding that service tax was payable.

CESTAT found that the company’s reply had been extensively reproduced in the impugned order. However, the authority’s findings were limited to two short paragraphs.

The bench observed that a plain reading of the order demonstrated that the issues raised in the reply and the allegations contained in the show cause notices had not been considered in their proper perspective before deciding against the company.

The defect identified by the tribunal was therefore substantive: the order recorded the defence but did not adequately examine it or explain why the company’s submissions failed.

The tribunal emphasised that officials exercising quasi-judicial functions bear responsibility for maintaining credibility and instilling confidence in the adjudicatory process.

It held that a quasi-judicial authority cannot prejudge an issue or ignore the affected party’s reply while adjudicating allegations raised in show cause notices.

Applying this principle, the bench concluded that the original authority had not properly examined the factual and legal aspects before holding the company liable for service tax on the alleged copyright services.

The tribunal considered the absence of a proper discussion on the merits sufficient to warrant fresh adjudication.

CESTAT set aside the impugned order and expressly clarified that the matter was being sent back through an open remand.

The original authority must address all issues involved in the show cause notices. It must also provide the company with a reasonable opportunity of personal hearing before deciding the issues afresh.

The tribunal expected the authority to complete the de novo adjudication proceedings and pass a fresh order preferably within six months from November 11, 2026.

Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy

To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.

Membership Required

You must be a member to access this content.

View Membership Levels

Already a member? Log in here

Read More: ICAI Expands Tax Audit Review Tenfold, Selects 1,000 Companies With ₹100 Crore-Plus Turnover

Mariya Paliwala
Mariya Paliwalahttps://www.jurishour.in/
Mariya is the Senior Editor at Juris Hour. She has 7+ years of experience on covering tax litigation stories from the Supreme Court, High Courts and various tribunals including CESTAT, ITAT, NCLAT, NCLT, etc. Mariya graduated from MLSU Law College, Udaipur (Raj.) with B.A.LL.B. and also holds an LL.M. She started her career as a freelance tax reporter in the leading online legal news companies.

Latest articles

ICAI Expands Tax Audit Review Tenfold, Selects 1,000 Companies With ₹100 Crore-Plus Turnover

The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) has significantly expanded its tax audit...

Service Tax Dept.’s Appeal Below Appeal Limit Of Rs. Rs. 60 Lakhs Dismissed: CESTAT

The Mumbai Bench of the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT) has...

Milk-Based Coffee Drinks Attract 12% IGST, Not 28% As Caffeinated Beverages: CESTAT

The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Mumbai, has held that the...

Service Tax on Labour or Works Contracts? CESTAT Orders Fresh Adjudication of Exemption and Abatement Claims

The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), New Delhi, has set aside...

More like this

ICAI Expands Tax Audit Review Tenfold, Selects 1,000 Companies With ₹100 Crore-Plus Turnover

The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) has significantly expanded its tax audit...

Service Tax Dept.’s Appeal Below Appeal Limit Of Rs. Rs. 60 Lakhs Dismissed: CESTAT

The Mumbai Bench of the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT) has...

Milk-Based Coffee Drinks Attract 12% IGST, Not 28% As Caffeinated Beverages: CESTAT

The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Mumbai, has held that the...