The Additional/Joint Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-5, Mumbai, has allowed a resident individual’s claim for rebate under Section 87A against tax payable on short-term capital gains covered by Section 111A for Assessment Year 2024–25, holding that a combined reading of the two provisions did not bar the relief.
Allowing an appeal against a rectification order passed by the Centralised Processing Centre (CPC), Bengaluru, the appellate authority held that the CPC had erred in restricting the rebate in respect of short-term capital gains. It directed the Assessing Officer to allow the rebate in accordance with the applicable provisions.
Buy Now: Direct tax (Income Tax) Judgments E-Magazine October 2026
The dispute arose from the taxpayer’s income-tax return for AY 2024–25, filed on July 29, 2024. Her income included short-term capital gains and income from other sources, with the reported total income remaining below ₹7 lakh.
The appellate authority recorded that the taxpayer had not exercised the option under Section 115BAC(6) to move out of the default new tax regime. Her income was therefore governed by Section 115BAC(1A).
The taxpayer claimed a rebate of ₹25,000 under Section 87A against the tax payable on her short-term capital gains and remaining income. However, while processing the return under Section 143(1), the CPC disallowed the rebate in respect of short-term capital gains and raised a demand.
She subsequently filed a rectification application under Section 154, arguing that the failure to grant the rebate constituted a mistake apparent from the record. The CPC’s rectification order dated April 8, 2025, left the earlier processing outcome undisturbed, leading to the appeal.
Taxpayer Challenges Denial Of Statutory Rebate
The taxpayer contended that the CPC had incorrectly evaluated her eligibility for Section 87A relief despite the total income disclosed in the return.
She argued that the consequential demand arose from the failure to apply an available statutory rebate and ought to have been corrected through rectification proceedings.
The taxpayer also objected that the demand had been raised without providing an opportunity of being heard.
Since the first three grounds of appeal concerned the disallowance of the Section 87A rebate, the appellate authority adjudicated them together.
Delay Of 32 Days Condoned
Before considering the merits, the appellate authority condoned a 32-day delay in filing the appeal.
The taxpayer explained that she had initially relied on a local accountant who possessed limited knowledge of income-tax litigation and appellate procedures. According to her explanation, the accountant treated the issue as a return-utility error and advised filing a rectification application.
She further submitted that the accountant failed to communicate the subsequent rectification order. Upon discovering the order on the income-tax portal, she approached a tax practitioner familiar with litigation and took steps to file the appeal.
Accepting the explanation, the authority condoned the delay in the interests of justice and fair play and admitted the appeal for adjudication.
Whether Special-Rate Capital Gains Prevent Section 87A Relief
The principal issue was whether short-term capital gains taxable at the special rate under Section 111A prevented the taxpayer from claiming the rebate available under Section 87A for the assessment year concerned.
The appellate authority reproduced the applicable Section 87A provisions. Under the provision quoted in the order, a resident individual whose total income was chargeable under Section 115BAC(1A) and did not exceed ₹7 lakh could claim a rebate equal to the income-tax payable or ₹25,000, whichever was lower.
The authority concluded that Section 87A, read with Section 111A, did not prohibit the taxpayer’s rebate claim in the circumstances of the case.
Chapter VI-A Restriction Does Not Extend To Chapter VIII Rebate
A central part of the authority’s reasoning was the distinction between deductions under Chapter VI-A and the tax rebate under Chapter VIII.
The authority noted that the restriction concerning short-term capital gains related to deductions under Chapter VI-A. Section 87A, however, falls within Chapter VIII.
Consequently, it held that the restriction on Chapter VI-A deductions did not operate to deny the Section 87A rebate in this case.
On a composite reading of Sections 87A and 111A, the authority concluded that the CPC had erred in restricting the rebate in respect of the taxpayer’s short-term capital gains.
Chennai ITAT Decision Supports Rebate On Section 111A Gains
The appellate authority relied on the Chennai ITAT’s decision in Seshank Mahadev v. Income Tax Officer, Corporate Ward 3(1), Chennai, ITA No. 2274/Chny/2025.
As reproduced in the appellate order, the Chennai Bench found no express bar under either Section 87A or Section 111A against granting the rebate on tax payable on short-term capital gains arising from the transfer of listed equity shares taxable under Section 111A.
That ruling supported the conclusion that the inclusion of such short-term capital gains did not, by itself, make the taxpayer ineligible for Section 87A relief under the provisions considered.
Other Tribunal Decisions Considered
The authority also referred to the Bengaluru ITAT’s decision in Shevgoor Namratha Kamath v. ITO, Ward-2(1), Mangaluru, ITA No. 3054/Bang/2025.
That decision concerned Section 87A rebate against tax payable on long-term capital gains taxable under Section 112, where the taxpayer’s total income did not exceed ₹7 lakh.
The order further referred to the Ahmedabad ITAT’s decision in Jayshreeben Jayantibhai Palsana v. ITO, Ward-1(9), Ahmedabad, ITA No. 1014/Ahd/2025, while discussing the supporting tribunal authorities.
Allowing the substantive grounds of appeal, the appellate authority directed the Assessing Officer to allow Section 87A relief in accordance with the provisions.
The fourth ground, reserving the taxpayer’s right to add or modify grounds, was treated as general and was not separately adjudicated.
The ruling concerns AY 2024–25 and the provisions considered for that year. The operative direction requires the rebate to be granted as per law; the order does not provide a fresh computation of the final tax liability.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: Capital Loss Set-Off Alone Can’t Trigger GAAR: Telangana High Court

![S. 87A Rebate Can’t Be Denied On S. 111A Short-Term Capital Gains: CIT(A) [READ ORDER] S. 87A Rebate Can’t Be Denied On S. 111A Short-Term Capital Gains: CIT(A) [READ ORDER]](https://www.jurishour.in/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/S.-87A-Rebate-Cant-Be-Denied-On-S.-111A-Short-Term-Capital-Gains-696x392.jpg)