Ask Jurishour AI

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
tdb_templates
saswp_reviews
saswp-collections
saswp_rvs_location
tdc-review-email
web-story-font
web-story
googlesitekit_email
tds_locker
tds_email
saswp
mailpoet_page
mailpoet_email
tdcpt_tunes
tdc-review
pronamic_payment
pronamic_gateway
pronamic_pay_subscr
wpcode
HomeDirect TaxCapital Loss Set-Off Alone Can’t Trigger GAAR: Telangana High Court

Capital Loss Set-Off Alone Can’t Trigger GAAR: Telangana High Court

Published on

🚀 Stay Connected With JurisHour

WhatsApp X Telegram

The Telangana High Court has held that a tax benefit resulting from the set-off of a genuine short-term capital loss cannot, by itself, justify invoking the General Anti-Avoidance Rules (GAAR). 

The bench of Acting Chief Justice P. Sam Koshy and Justice Narsing Rao Nandikonda set aside directions treating a taxpayer’s share transactions as an impermissible avoidance arrangement and upheld the set-off of ₹49.32 crore against long-term capital gains arising from a slump sale.

The Bench has held that the Revenue had failed to establish the statutory ingredients necessary to invoke GAAR.

Buy Now: Income Tax Appeal Lies Before HC Where AO Is Located, Not ITAT: Karnataka High Court

The dispute arose following the transfer of the business operated under the “Mebaz” brand to Vedant Fashions for approximately ₹210.46 crore on June 13, 2017.

The business was originally carried on by New Meena Bazar International Private Limited. Following amalgamations sanctioned by the National Company Law Tribunal, the tax dispute was pursued by the assessee as successor.

After discharging liabilities of approximately ₹59.40 crore, the transaction left a surplus of about ₹151.06 crore. Excluding a deferred payment of approximately ₹20 crore, around ₹130 crore was available for investment.

The taxpayer consulted several financial institutions and an internal consultant about deploying the funds. Pending a final decision, it invested the surplus in liquid mutual funds. It subsequently decided to allocate approximately ₹50 crore to listed equities and ₹80 crore to bonds and debt mutual funds.

As part of its equity investment strategy, the taxpayer purchased shares of large listed companies before bonus allotments and sold shares after the allotments.

The taxpayer explained that its advisers had identified the possibility of short-term returns of approximately 1% to 3% from post-bonus price movements.

It invested an aggregate of ₹106.31 crore in pre-bonus shares, sold shares worth ₹57.24 crore after bonus allotments and retained a net investment at cost of ₹49.07 crore.

The transactions generated a short-term capital loss of ₹49,32,71,673, which the taxpayer claimed as a set-off under Section 70(2) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, against long-term capital gains of ₹1,75,91,50,508 computed under Section 50B on the slump sale.

The Income Tax Department questioned the adjustment and initiated GAAR proceedings. On February 23, 2022, the Approving Panel issued directions under Section 144BA(6), treating the share transactions as an impermissible avoidance arrangement.

The Department argued that the taxpayer had structured the transactions so that the statutory treatment of bonus shares and the First-In-First-Out (FIFO) method worked together to generate short-term capital losses.

According to the Revenue, the requirement to treat the acquisition cost of bonus shares as nil, coupled with the FIFO method referred to in CBDT Circular No. 704 dated April 28, 1995, enabled the taxpayer to create losses for adjustment against its slump-sale gains.

The Department maintained that obtaining this tax benefit was the purpose of the transactions and that the arrangement involved abuse of the Act’s provisions.

The taxpayer disputed this characterisation. It argued that the shares were traded transparently on recognised stock exchanges at prevailing market prices, with unidentified counterparties and outcomes dependent on market movements. Claiming a set-off expressly permitted by the statute, it submitted, did not establish an avoidance arrangement.

The High Court emphasised that the serious consequences of Chapter X-A required strict examination of the conditions for its application.

It explained that Section 96(1) requires the main purpose of an arrangement to be obtaining a tax benefit, together with satisfaction of at least one of the additional conditions specified in clauses (a) to (d). There must first also be an “arrangement” within the statutory definition.

The Bench held that the burden of establishing these ingredients rested on the Revenue. Mere suspicion or disapproval of a taxpayer’s chosen commercial course could not justify disregarding or recharacterising transactions.

The Court noted that the taxpayer purchased and sold shares of large, reputed listed companies on a recognised stock exchange at prevailing market prices through transparent, arm’s-length transactions.

Reading the expressions in Section 102(1) in their context, the Bench reasoned that they contemplated a degree of concert or design between identifiable parties, or at least preordained steps whose outcome was within the taxpayer’s control.

In this case, the quantum of gain or loss depended on market prices over which the taxpayer exercised no control. On the admitted facts, the Court rejected the Panel’s characterisation of the dealings as an “operation” or “scheme” attracting the statutory definition.

The Court further held that, even assuming the transactions constituted an arrangement, the Revenue had not established that their main purpose was to obtain a tax benefit.

The investment history provided a commercial explanation for deploying a substantial surplus. The taxpayer had sought professional advice, initially parked funds in liquid mutual funds and adopted an allocation across equity and debt investments.

The Bench considered the continued holding of investments worth ₹49.07 crore significant. It observed that a taxpayer whose sole objective was manufacturing a capital loss would have had no reason to remain invested to that extent.

The Panel had inferred an avoidance purpose from the resulting tax benefit instead of independently establishing the dominant purpose of the investment decisions, the Court held.

It reiterated that a lawful commercial course does not become impermissible merely because it is also tax-efficient.

The High Court explained that income tax is a unified annual levy and that taxable income is computed after adjusting eligible losses against gains.

Section 70(2) permitted the short-term capital loss to be set off against capital gains arising in the same year. In claiming the adjustment, the taxpayer had computed its income in the manner prescribed by the Act.

On the facts before it, the Court distinguished a benefit obtained by circumventing the statutory scheme from a consequence flowing directly from applying a computation provision to a genuine, commercially sustained loss.

The Bench also rejected the allegations under Section 96(1)(b) and (d).

It found that the taxpayer had applied the provisions governing capital loss set-off, bonus-share cost, FIFO accounting and slump-sale gains according to their terms. Its use of a regulated stock exchange was an ordinary and conventional means of investing in securities.

The Court additionally noted that the search conducted in November 2018 had yielded no incriminating material against the taxpayer.

Of approximately 105 assessments reopened across the group following the search, 104 had been completed with nil or minimal adjustments.

Against that background, invoking GAAR required a careful and reasoned demonstration of its statutory ingredients. The Court found that such a demonstration was absent from the impugned directions.

Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy

To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.

Membership Required

You must be a member to access this content.

View Membership Levels

Already a member? Log in here

Read More: Income Tax Appeal Lies Before HC Where AO Is Located, Not ITAT: Karnataka High Court

Mariya Paliwala
Mariya Paliwalahttps://www.jurishour.in/
Mariya is the Senior Editor at Juris Hour. She has 7+ years of experience on covering tax litigation stories from the Supreme Court, High Courts and various tribunals including CESTAT, ITAT, NCLAT, NCLT, etc. Mariya graduated from MLSU Law College, Udaipur (Raj.) with B.A.LL.B. and also holds an LL.M. She started her career as a freelance tax reporter in the leading online legal news companies.

Latest articles

Income Tax Appeal Lies Before HC Where AO Is Located, Not ITAT: Karnataka High Court

The Karnataka High Court has held that territorial jurisdiction to challenge an Income Tax...

Later Sale Deed Can’t Defeat Capital Gains Exemption Where Sale Agreement And Possession Support Claim: Karnataka High Court

The Karnataka High Court has upheld capital gains exemption in a case involving the...

Excise Rebate Can’t Be Withheld On Vague Document Objections When Duty Payment And Export Are Proved: Calcutta High Court

The Calcutta High Court has dismissed the Revenue’s appeal against an order allowing an...

GST Assessment Doesn’t Restart Liquidation Claim Deadline: NCLAT 

The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT), Principal Bench, New Delhi, has held that...

More like this

Income Tax Appeal Lies Before HC Where AO Is Located, Not ITAT: Karnataka High Court

The Karnataka High Court has held that territorial jurisdiction to challenge an Income Tax...

Later Sale Deed Can’t Defeat Capital Gains Exemption Where Sale Agreement And Possession Support Claim: Karnataka High Court

The Karnataka High Court has upheld capital gains exemption in a case involving the...

Excise Rebate Can’t Be Withheld On Vague Document Objections When Duty Payment And Export Are Proved: Calcutta High Court

The Calcutta High Court has dismissed the Revenue’s appeal against an order allowing an...