The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT), Principal Bench, New Delhi, has held that a subsequent GST assessment does not restart the deadline for submitting a claim in liquidation. It dismissed a Karnataka tax authority’s appeal against the rejection of its ₹8.10 lakh claim filed 896 days after the prescribed deadline.
The Bench of Justice Mohammad Faiz Alam Khan (Judicial Member) and Naresh Salecha, (Technical Member) upheld the NCLT Ahmedabad’s refusal to condone the delay. It held that the department could not justify waiting for adjudication to conclude when the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) recognised disputed and unquantified rights to payment as claims.
Buy Now: All 200+ GSTAT Judgements Till November 2026 | Comprehensive E-Magazine
The company, engaged in water treatment, industrial wastewater treatment and purification solutions, entered the corporate insolvency resolution process on August 31, 2021. The NCLT ordered its liquidation on October 3, 2023, appointing Sumedha Management Solutions Private Limited as liquidator.
A public announcement issued on October 11, 2023, fixed November 8, 2023, as the last date for submitting claims. The tax department did not submit the disputed claim within that period.
The demand related to supplies made between April 2019 and March 2020. According to the department, the company had paid IGST on certain works contract services under HSN 9954 even though the place of supply was within Karnataka. The department treated the transactions as intra-State supplies attracting CGST and Karnataka GST instead.
Following an assignment dated August 12, 2024, the department issued an intimation in Form GST DRC-01A on September 6, 2025, followed by a show-cause notice under Section 74 on September 23, 2025.
The liquidator informed the department about the liquidation through communications dated October 23 and November 14, 2025.
On February 21, 2026, the department passed an adjudication order determining liability of ₹8.10 lakh, comprising ₹4.05 lakh each towards CGST and Karnataka GST. The company’s rectification application was rejected on March 24, 2026.
The department submitted its proof of claim in Form C on April 22, 2026. The liquidator rejected it on May 2, 2026, because it had been filed beyond the prescribed period.
The department then approached the NCLT, seeking to set aside the rejection, condone the 896-day delay and direct verification and admission of its claim. The NCLT rejected the application on July 22, 2026.
Before the NCLAT, the department argued that the liability crystallised only through the February 2026 adjudication order and attained finality upon rejection of the rectification application in March. It emphasised that the claim had been submitted within 29 days of the rectification decision.
The department maintained that it had confined its action to determining statutory dues and had not initiated coercive recovery proceedings.
Relying on the Supreme Court’s judgment in Sundaresh Bhatt, Liquidator of ABG Shipyard v. Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs, it argued that permitting assessment during liquidation should enable consideration of the resulting claim after assessment concluded.
It also contended that the NCLT possessed jurisdiction under Sections 60(5) and 42 of the IBC to grant relief even if the liquidator lacked an independent power to condone delay.
Rejecting the explanation, the NCLAT relied on the definition of “claim” under Section 3(6) of the IBC. The provision recognises a right to payment even where it has not been reduced to judgment, remains unfixed or is disputed.
The tribunal explained that if the claim arose from taxable supplies made during 2019–20, it existed before the commencement of insolvency and liquidation. The department could therefore have submitted the claim by November 8, 2023, with the particulars available to it.
The later assignment of adjudication proceedings reflected when the department chose to scrutinise the returns. Its own delay in examining those returns could not be imposed on an ongoing liquidation conducted on public notice.
The tribunal held that waiting for adjudication to conclude was the department’s choice. The IBC did not require it to wait before submitting a disputed or unquantified claim.
The NCLAT distinguished the authority to determine tax liability from compliance with the liquidation claims process.
Discussing ABG Shipyard, it observed that a revenue authority may determine tax, interest, fine or penalty during the applicable moratorium, while enforcement and recovery remain subject to the insolvency framework.
However, permission to assess does not create a fresh claim-filing period beginning on the assessment date.
The tribunal reasoned that accepting the department’s interpretation would effectively leave tax authorities without an enforceable deadline and undermine the requirement to follow the IBC’s prescribed periods.
It also considered the department’s alternative position that the liability came into existence only on February 21, 2026. On that premise, the tribunal held that the claim fell outside Regulations 12 and 16 of the IBBI (Liquidation Process) Regulations, 2016, which contemplate claims as on the liquidation commencement date.
The Bench expressly found it unnecessary to choose between the two approaches. If the claim existed earlier, it was substantially delayed without sufficient explanation. If it arose only after liquidation commenced, it did not fit the regulatory framework applied in the case.
The NCLAT acknowledged that the department approached the NCLT within 14 days of the liquidator’s rejection, as contemplated under Section 42 of the IBC.
However, a timely challenge to rejection did not cure the delay in submitting the underlying claim.
Section 42 provides a remedy against the liquidator’s decision; it does not create a fresh entitlement to submit a claim after the prescribed process has closed, the tribunal held.
Similarly, the broad jurisdiction under Section 60(5) must operate within the statutory scheme. Even assuming that a power to condone the delay existed, its exercise required sufficient cause and consistency with the time-bound liquidation process.
The department’s explanation addressed, at most, the period after assessment. It did not explain the period exceeding two years and three months between the original deadline and the adjudication order.
The tribunal rejected the contention that the statutory character of the dues justified a longer filing period.
It observed that government dues must enter the liquidation process through the prescribed claims mechanism before being dealt with under Section 53 of the IBC.
The company had been in liquidation for approximately three years. Admitting the claim at that stage would require renewed verification and revision of the stakeholder list and could affect distribution and the expectations of creditors who complied with the deadline.
The relatively small amount did not determine the issue. The tribunal reasoned that allowing the claim could encourage similar requests from other delayed creditors, undermining the certainty that the prescribed timelines sought to secure.
The department’s distinction between proceedings under Sections 73 and 74 of the GST enactments also did not alter the result. The claim deadline arose under the IBC and liquidation regulations, irrespective of the GST provision used for adjudication.
The NCLAT upheld the liquidator’s rejection and the NCLT’s order, finding no sufficient cause to condone the 896-day delay.
The appeal was dismissed without costs, and pending interlocutory applications, if any, were closed.
The tribunal clarified that a separate pending appeal concerning an earlier claim arising from Section 73 proceedings was not before it and remained unaffected by this judgment.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: GST Registration Can’t Be Cancelled Over Pending Landlord–Tenant Dispute: Telangana High Court

