The Jharkhand High Court has ruled against the Income Tax Department in a reassessment dispute, holding that an assessee’s participation in the proceedings cannot cure the failure to issue a mandatory notice under Section 143(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961.
The Bench of Chief Justice M. S. Sonak and Justice Manoj Prasad held that the omission is a substantive defect going to the root of the assessment proceedings. It cannot be treated as a mere technical objection or overcome by invoking waiver on account of the assessee’s participation.
Buy Now: Direct tax (Income Tax) Judgments E-Magazine October 2026
The dispute arose from reassessment proceedings in which, as the High Court recorded, no notice under Section 143(2) had admittedly been issued to the assessee. The ITAT quashed the assessment on that ground, prompting the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (Central), Patna, to approach the High Court.
The High Court condoned the delay in filing the appeal and admitted it on three substantial questions of law. These concerned the effect of the assessee’s participation, the application of Section 292BB, and whether the Tribunal could set aside the assessment without examining the additions on merits or recording prejudice to the assessee.
The department’s challenge questioned whether the Tribunal was justified in entertaining the objection when the assessee had fully participated in the assessment proceedings without raising it before the second appeal.
It also invoked Section 292BB and the doctrine of waiver or acquiescence, arguing through the questions framed for consideration that the assessee’s conscious participation affected its ability to challenge the absence of the notice later.
The third question challenged the Tribunal’s decision to set aside the assessment solely on a procedural ground, without recording prejudice or adjudicating the additions on merits in its capacity as the final fact-finding authority.
A decisive development occurred on October 28, 2026, the very day the High Court admitted the appeal. The Supreme Court delivered its judgment in Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Bhubaneshwar v. Orissa Mining Corporation Ltd., reported as 2026 INSC 1171.
The High Court noted that this development was naturally unknown to both the Court and the Revenue’s counsel when the appeal was admitted.
As recorded in the High Court’s order, the Supreme Court held that a Section 143(2) notice is an indispensable requirement for commencing the proceedings in question. The Revenue remains obliged to serve that notice even where the assessee requests that its earlier return under Section 139 be treated as the return filed in response to a Section 148 notice.
Reproducing the operative conclusions of the Supreme Court judgment, the High Court noted that Section 292BB does not prevent an assessee from objecting to the non-issuance of a Section 143(2) notice merely because it appeared and cooperated during reassessment without raising the objection.
The Supreme Court ruling also clarified that treating an earlier return as the return furnished in response to Section 148 does not dispense with the Revenue’s obligation to serve the mandatory notice.
Further, a letter under Section 142(1), requiring the assessee to explain the grounds on which reassessment was proposed, does not sufficiently comply with the obligation to serve a Section 143(2) notice.
These conclusions addressed the Revenue’s attempt to rely on participation and waiver to sustain an assessment made without issuance of the required notice.
The High Court emphasised that no Section 143(2) notice had admittedly been issued during the reassessment proceedings in the present case.
It noted that the Supreme Court had also held that mere participation by the assessee, in the absence of such a notice, does not confer jurisdiction on the Assessing Officer to frame an assessment under Section 143(3).
Consequently, the argument that the assessee had waived its objection through conscious participation stood answered against the Revenue. The defect concerned the authority to complete the assessment and went to the root of the proceedings.
The High Court held that the substantial questions of law framed in its October 28 order had to be decided against the Revenue.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: Delhi HC Rejects Rule 46A Objection Not Raised Before ITAT, Upholds Relief In Unexplained Money Case

