Ask Jurishour AI

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
tdb_templates
saswp_reviews
saswp-collections
saswp_rvs_location
tdc-review-email
web-story-font
web-story
googlesitekit_email
tds_locker
tds_email
saswp
mailpoet_page
mailpoet_email
tdcpt_tunes
tdc-review
pronamic_payment
pronamic_gateway
pronamic_pay_subscr
wpcode
HomeSupreme CourtDissenting Lenders Can’t Be Forced To Accept Debentures: Supreme Court Upholds Remand...

Dissenting Lenders Can’t Be Forced To Accept Debentures: Supreme Court Upholds Remand Of ₹2,962-Crore Videocon RP

Published on

🚀 Stay Connected With JurisHour

WhatsApp X Telegram

The Supreme Court has upheld the setting aside of the ₹2,962.02-crore resolution plan for 13 Videocon group companies, holding that dissenting financial creditors cannot be compelled to accept long-term non-convertible debentures in place of the monetary payment required under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016.

A Bench comprising Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe dismissed the appeals challenging the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal’s decision to return the matter to the Committee of Creditors (CoC). 

The Court also upheld the exclusion of foreign oil and gas assets held through subsidiaries from Videocon Industries Limited’s insolvency estate and laid down safeguards governing the NCLAT’s power to remit approved resolution plans.

Buy Now: 90+ Supreme Court Judgments E-Magazine – October 2026

Background: Plan Approved By 95.09% Of Creditors

The dispute arose from consolidated corporate insolvency resolution proceedings involving Videocon Industries Limited and 12 group companies. The NCLT, Mumbai, ordered consolidation of their insolvency proceedings on August 8, 2019.

Twinstar Technologies Limited submitted an amended resolution plan on November 7, 2020, with a total financial outlay of ₹2,962.02 crore. Creditors holding 95.09% of the voting share approved the proposal on December 11, 2020.

The plan provided for an upfront payment of ₹200 crore to financial creditors, ₹52 crore towards admitted workmen and employee dues, and ₹10 crore to operational creditors.

It also envisaged issuing non-convertible debentures with a face value of ₹2,700 crore, carrying an annual coupon of 6.65%, to financial creditors. Redemption was spread across five installments, beginning 25 months after the closing date and extending to the sixth year.

Financial creditors were additionally to receive 8% equity in Videocon Industries and the corporate debtors’ cash balances.

Four financial creditors dissented. Bank of Maharashtra, IFCI and SIDBI subsequently challenged the NCLT’s approval.

NCLT Approved Plan But Directed Upfront Cash Payment To Dissenters

The NCLT approved the plan on June 8, 2021. It recorded that the proposal against admitted claims of ₹64,838.63 crore entailed a haircut of 95.85%, while operational creditors would receive 0.72% of their admitted claims.

Although it deferred to the CoC’s commercial wisdom, the NCLT directed that dissenting financial creditors receive their liquidation entitlement in cash, upfront, before any payment to assenting financial creditors.

On January 5, 2022, the NCLAT set aside the approval and remitted the matter to the CoC.

The Supreme Court upheld that course, finding that the plan’s treatment of dissenting financial creditors violated the statutory requirements and that the NCLT could not cure the defect by changing the payment structure itself.

Dissenting Creditors’ Statutory Entitlement Must Be Paid In Money

Section 30(2)(b) of the IBC protects financial creditors who do not vote in favour of a resolution plan by prescribing a minimum payment linked to what they would receive under Section 53(1) in liquidation.

Regulation 38(1)(b) of the CIRP Regulations further requires payment to those dissenting financial creditors in priority over financial creditors who voted in favour of the plan.

Applying its three-judge Bench ruling in Jaypee Kensington Boulevard Apartments Welfare Association v. NBCC (India) Ltd., the Supreme Court held that the payment contemplated by the provision must be in money.

A financial creditor choosing to exit by dissenting cannot be compelled to remain attached to the corporate debtor through financial instruments imposed by the resolution plan.

In this case, the dissenting creditors had not been expressly separated from the debenture-based payment structure. Their dues were, in substance, to be discharged through securities redeemable over several years.

The Court also found that the plan failed to secure the payment priority required by Regulation 38(1)(b). These defects furnished grounds for interference under Section 61(3) of the IBC.

General Promise To Comply With Law Cannot Save A Defective Plan

The resolution applicant relied on a clause stating that payments to dissenting financial creditors would strictly comply with Section 30(2)(b).

The Supreme Court rejected that argument. A general assurance of compliance could not substitute for specific provisions explaining how, when and in what form dissenting creditors would be paid.

Compliance had to emerge from the operative terms of the resolution plan itself. A broadly worded legal-compliance clause could not cure a payment mechanism that failed the statutory requirements.

Tribunal Cannot Rewrite The Plan To Cure Its Defects

The Supreme Court held that the NCLT’s direction requiring upfront cash payment altered the plan’s financial structure.

The ₹200-crore upfront payment had been earmarked for financial creditors as a class. Directing that dissenters be paid first in cash necessarily changed the allocation and order of disbursement among financial creditors.

That amounted to modification of the resolution plan—a commercial decision reserved for the CoC.

The Court held that a statement by counsel for the CoC promising upfront payment could not authorise the NCLT to undertake that modification. The proper course was to return the defective plan to creditors for reconsideration.

NCLAT Has Power To Remit A Non-Compliant Plan

The Supreme Court affirmed that neither the NCLT nor the NCLAT can substitute its commercial judgment for that of the CoC. Their examination must remain within the statutory grounds prescribed by the IBC.

However, that limitation does not prevent the NCLAT from returning a legally defective plan to the CoC.

The Court explained that the appellate power carries the necessary incidental authority to order a remand. Otherwise, setting aside an approved plan after the insolvency period has expired could push the corporate debtor towards liquidation, which the Code treats as a last resort.

Remand preserves the possibility of resolution while ensuring that commercial choices remain with creditors.

The Court also declined to direct the CoC to consider only a modified version of the existing proposal. Once approval of a non-compliant plan is set aside, the decision whether to revisit that proposal or invite fresh plans belongs to the CoC.

CoC’s Role Does Not End Immediately After Plan Approval

The Supreme Court rejected the argument that the CoC had become functus officio, meaning that its authority had ended, after approving the plan.

It noted that the CoC continues to exist until implementation of the plan or an order of liquidation.

Here, the NCLT’s approval had been challenged in statutory appeals, stayed by the NCLAT, and ultimately set aside for legal non-compliance. Against that background, creditors holding approximately 95% of the voting share had sought reconsideration.

The Court upheld reconsideration in those circumstances. It distinguished the case from an attempt to withdraw approval of an otherwise compliant plan merely because the corporate debtor’s financial position had improved.

Supreme Court Corrects Finding On Competition Approval

The Supreme Court did not endorse every reason given by the NCLAT.

The appellate tribunal had found that prior approval of the Competition Commission of India had not been obtained as required under the proviso to Section 31(4).

However, the resolution applicant produced a CCI communication dated December 8, 2020. Since voting concluded on December 11, 2020, the Supreme Court held that the statutory requirement had been satisfied.

The remand nevertheless stood because of the unlawful treatment of dissenting financial creditors and the NCLT’s impermissible modification of the plan.

Foreign Subsidiaries’ Assets Cannot Be Included In Parent’s Insolvency Estate

The connected appeals concerned interests in oil and gas concessions in Brazil and Indonesia held through Videocon’s subsidiaries.

The Court relied on Explanation (b) to Section 18 of the IBC, which excludes assets of an Indian or foreign subsidiary from the assets over which the interim resolution professional takes control.

Section 36(4)(d) reflects the same principle by excluding subsidiary assets from the parent company’s liquidation estate.

The Court explained that a holding company and its subsidiary are separate legal persons. Even complete ownership of a subsidiary’s shares does not make its assets the property of the holding company.

The beneficial ownership agreements relied upon by the promoter did not transfer the subsidiaries’ assets to Videocon Industries. Similarly, correspondence and descriptions in financing arrangements could not override the statutory exclusion or establish a transfer of title.

The Court further held that the promoter’s earlier conduct—including requests to separate financing arrangements and the exclusion of offshore assets from his own proposal—prevented him from taking an inconsistent position.

Large Haircut Alone Does Not Justify Interference

The Supreme Court rejected the promoter’s objections concerning the extent of the haircut and the adequacy of valuation.

Evaluation of a resolution plan and the commercial acceptability of recovery fall within the CoC’s commercial wisdom. The liquidation value had been determined using the average estimates of two registered valuers and placed before creditors.

The judgment therefore preserves the distinction between dissatisfaction with a low commercial recovery and an identifiable violation of the IBC. The statutory violations justified interference with this plan.

Court Sets Safeguards Against Routine Remands

The Supreme Court held that remand must advance the objectives of the IBC, including preserving the corporate debtor as a going concern, ensuring fair and reasonable recovery for creditor classes, and maximising asset value.

It must rest on a finding of legal non-compliance and be exercised sparingly and with caution. It cannot bypass procedures expressly prescribed by the Code.

Where the adjudicating authority has itself modified a plan to cure a defect, remand may restore the proper division of responsibility between the tribunal and the CoC.

Every remand must also carry strict directions to observe statutory and regulatory timelines. The Court highlighted the costs of prolonged litigation, uncertainty, additional financial burdens and depletion of asset value.

Final Decision

The Supreme Court dismissed the resolution applicant’s appeals and the connected appeals concerning foreign oil and gas assets, without orders as to costs.

The VIL Vendors Association was granted liberty to pursue remedies available under law. The Court observed that challenges to allegedly improper transactions must be pursued through the appropriate statutory provisions, including Sections 43 to 51 and 66, rather than by treating subsidiary assets as belonging to the parent.

GAIL’s claim was left to be dealt with by the resolution professional in accordance with the IBC and CIRP Regulations, with its contentions preserved.

Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy

To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.

Membership Required

You must be a member to access this content.

View Membership Levels

Already a member? Log in here

Read More: Automatic Vesting Applies Only To Private Forests: Supreme Court Rejects Kerala’s Claim Over 12-Acre Land

Amit Sharma
Amit Sharma
Amit Sharma is the Content Editor at JurisHour. He has been writing about the Indian legal market. He has covered tax & company litigation stories from the Supreme Court, High Courts and Various Tribunals. Amit graduated from MLSU Law College with B.A.LL.B. and also holds an LL.M. from MLSU, Udaipur, Rajasthan. An Advocate in Taxation, and practised in Tribunals as well as Rajasthan High Court and pursued Masters in Constitutional Law. He started out small with little resources but a big plan to take tax legal education to the remotest locations across India and eventually to the world. His vision is to make tax related legal developments accessible to the masses.

Latest articles

Automatic Vesting Applies Only To Private Forests: Supreme Court Rejects Kerala’s Claim Over 12-Acre Land

The Supreme Court has dismissed the Kerala Government’s appeal against a judgment declaring that...

Old VAT Bill Book Alone Can’t Prove GST Evasion: GSTAT 

The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Prayagraj Bench, has set aside a...

GST Credit on IPO Expenses: Who Bears the Tax When Promoters Sell Their Shares?

A fresh issue raises capital for the company. An offer for sale pays the...

Customs Penalties U/s 112, 114 Doesn’t Bar Special Warehouse Licence: CESTAT

The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Kolkata, has held that penalties...

More like this

Automatic Vesting Applies Only To Private Forests: Supreme Court Rejects Kerala’s Claim Over 12-Acre Land

The Supreme Court has dismissed the Kerala Government’s appeal against a judgment declaring that...

Old VAT Bill Book Alone Can’t Prove GST Evasion: GSTAT 

The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Prayagraj Bench, has set aside a...

GST Credit on IPO Expenses: Who Bears the Tax When Promoters Sell Their Shares?

A fresh issue raises capital for the company. An offer for sale pays the...