One of the most common dilemmas faced by policyholders of endowment and ULIP plans is whether to surrender their existing policy or continue till maturity. While surrendering can provide immediate liquidity, it also carries significant long-term consequences for your financial security, returns, and tax benefits. Therefore, the decision must not be made hastily or emotionally. Instead, it should be based on careful evaluation of your goals, family’s protection needs, and financial planning horizon.
Before taking a final call, ask yourself these five essential questions.
1. Do You Need a Term Plan?
The foremost consideration before surrendering any life insurance policy is your family’s safety. If you do not have a sufficient term plan in place, it is unwise to cancel your existing policy. Life insurance serves as a financial safety net for your dependents, ensuring that they remain secure in your absence. Even if the investment component of your policy is underperforming, do not surrender it until a robust term insurance plan is active and adequate coverage is assured. In short, financial protection should never be compromised for short-term liquidity.
2. Is the Maturity Date Still Far Away?
If your policy has a long tenure left — say ten years or more until maturity — surrendering early might not be ideal. Long-term insurance-cum-investment products rely heavily on the power of compounding. The longer you stay invested, the greater the benefit from accumulated bonuses and returns. Exiting early disrupts this compounding effect and can significantly reduce your overall earnings. Hence, if you have ample time for your new investments to grow and catch up, patience may yield better results than a premature surrender.
3. Will the Total Money Gained Be Worth It?
Surrendering a policy often results in an immediate loss because you forfeit accumulated bonuses or incur surrender charges. The key question to consider is whether reinvesting the surrendered value elsewhere can compensate for that loss. For example, if your surrendered amount could be reinvested into higher-yield instruments such as equity mutual funds or NPS, and these generate substantially better returns, the switch might be financially prudent. However, this requires careful analysis of your risk appetite, return expectations, and time horizon. In essence, do the math before deciding — the grass may look greener, but only numbers can confirm it.
4. Am I Just Stressed About Money Right Now?
A sudden cash crunch often tempts people to liquidate long-term investments or surrender their policies. However, if your financial stress is temporary, surrendering a policy can do more harm than good. In such situations, a policy loan might be a better alternative. Most life insurance policies allow loans against their surrender value at reasonable interest rates. This option enables you to meet short-term needs while retaining the long-term benefits of the policy. Canceling a good insurance plan for a temporary money shortage is rarely a wise move.
5. Am I Almost Done With the Policy?
If your policy is close to maturity — for instance, within the next two years — surrendering it makes little financial sense. The surrender value at this stage is often not much higher than what you would receive upon maturity, but the process of surrendering involves unnecessary paperwork, processing delays, and fees. The small gain you might recover will likely not compensate for the effort and the lost insurance coverage. In such cases, continuing till maturity is almost always the better option.
A Practical Example: Mr. X’s Case
Consider the example of Mr. X, who has been paying an annual premium of ₹50,000 for his endowment policy. After four years, the policy offers him a surrender value of ₹1.25 lakh. He is now deciding whether to continue or surrender and reinvest.
If Mr. X continues with the same policy for the remaining 16 years, he can expect a maturity value of around ₹12 lakh with an assumed return rate of approximately 6%. His sum assured remains ₹10 lakh.
However, if Mr. X decides to surrender after four years and reinvests the ₹1.25 lakh surrender value, while redirecting ₹35,000 annually into new investments and ₹15,000 towards a fresh term plan, the projections look more favorable. Over the same tenure, his reinvested corpus and higher-yield instruments could potentially grow to around ₹19.58 lakh, offering returns of approximately 10%. Moreover, his term insurance coverage increases significantly — from ₹10 lakh to ₹1 crore.
In monetary terms, Mr. X could end up earning nearly ₹7.58 lakh more than if he continued with the old policy. However, this advantage hinges on disciplined reinvestment and consistent returns. Without proper investment management, the benefits of surrendering could easily diminish.
Understanding Tax Implications on Surrendering
Surrendering a policy can also trigger tax consequences, which differ based on the type of policy you hold.
For traditional life insurance policies, if surrendered within two years, all tax deductions claimed under Section 80C are reversed, effectively increasing your tax liability in that financial year.
For Unit Linked Insurance Plans (ULIPs), the rules are even stricter. If you exit within five years, the profits are taxable, and the Section 80C deductions are withdrawn. However, if you stay invested beyond five years, ULIPs shift to a discontinued fund that offers a fixed 4% payout until withdrawal, providing a small but safe return.
It’s important to note that under the revised norms, proceeds remain tax-free only if annual premiums stay below ₹5 lakh for non-ULIPs (post-April 2023) and ₹2.5 lakh for ULIPs (post-February 2021).
The Bottom Line
Surrendering your insurance policy is not just a financial choice — it is a long-term decision that impacts your protection, savings, and taxation. While surrendering may seem appealing for quick liquidity or better returns elsewhere, it must be backed by sound financial reasoning.
Evaluate your family’s insurance needs, the time remaining until maturity, the comparative returns from reinvestment, and the applicable tax implications. If done strategically — by ensuring term coverage and disciplined reinvestment — surrendering can enhance returns. But if done impulsively, it can erode years of accumulated benefits and expose your family to financial risks.
In conclusion, think long-term. Review your policy carefully, consult a financial advisor if needed, and make a decision that aligns not just with your present cash needs but also your future security. The right choice will depend on your unique financial landscape — but in every case, protection should precede profit.
Read More: AIBE-XX Exam Rescheduled: BCI Announces Fresh Registration and Exam Dates