The Calcutta High Court set aside the dismissal of a GST appeal filed beyond the three-month filing period and the additional one-month window for condonation under Section 107.
The bench of Justice Smita Das De accepted the petitioners’ explanation for the delay and directed the appellate authority to hear the appeal against the GST demand for FY 2018–19 and pass a reasoned order within six weeks of communication of the High Court’s order.
Buy Now: 210+ GST Judgments E-Magazine – October 2026
The dispute arose from a demand order dated 19 April 2024 under Section 73 of the Central and West Bengal GST Acts, accompanied by a summary in Form GST DRC-07. The petitioners challenged both the demand and the subsequent dismissal of their appeal on limitation grounds.
The petitioners said the department had uploaded the demand order under the GST portal’s “Additional Notice and Orders” tab and that they had missed it. They attributed the lapse to their tax consultant’s serious illness and to several proceedings running at the same time. According to their submissions, they discovered the order around the time their GSTR-9 annual return was due.
The petitioners told the Court that the extended filing window ran until 19 August 2024. They filed the appeal on 1 January 2025 after depositing 10% of the disputed tax. The appellate authority dismissed it as time-barred.
The State argued that the petitioners knew of the proceedings arising from the audit. It said the department issued personal hearing notices on 2 January and 18 April 2024, but the petitioners did not appear.
The State also said the petitioners did not respond to the show-cause notice dated 26 December 2023, despite reminders and a further opportunity to submit a reply by 18 April 2024.
Section 107(1) of the CGST Act gives an aggrieved taxpayer three months from communication of the adjudication order to appeal. Section 107(4) provides for a further month where the appellate authority is satisfied that sufficient cause prevented timely filing.
The petitioners relied on Ram Kumar Sinhal v. State of West Bengal, (2025) 33 Centax 175 (Cal.), in which the High Court discussed the applicability of the Limitation Act to delayed appeals under the WBGST Act. They also cited GSPR Developers Private Limited v. State of West Bengal, WPA 263 of 2026, where the Court found sufficient cause to condone a delay after the taxpayer’s chartered accountant failed to inform it of the order.
Justice Das De found the petitioners’ explanations for missing the deadline and failing to respond to the show-cause notice sufficient to warrant intervention. The Court held that the dismissal was arbitrary, illegal and contrary to the principles of natural justice.
The Court directed the appellate authority to give the petitioners a personal hearing and dispose of the appeal by a reasoned order within six weeks from communication of the High Court’s order. The authority must communicate its decision within a further week. The merits of the FY 2018–19 GST demand remain open for the appellate authority to decide.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: Omitted Rule 96(10) Can’t Bar Rs. 4.39 Crore IGST Export Refund: Karnataka High Court

