The Delhi High Court has held that a holding or group company supplies a taxable service when it guarantees a related company’s borrowings from a bank or financial institution, even if it charges no fee. The court also held that the deemed valuation of 1% per annum under Rule 28(2) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Rules cannot operate as an irrebuttable minimum. A supplier can displace it by establishing a lower open market value with cogent and verifiable evidence.
A Division Bench of Justices Anil Kshetarpal and Bharat Parashar read down Rule 28(2), allowing suppliers to establish a lower open market value. It also held that a guarantee does not become a fresh supply each year simply because it remains in force.
The bench set aside the challenged show cause notices, orders and demands to the extent they conflicted with its findings, and directed the proper officers to determine liability afresh after giving the petitioners an adequate opportunity to be heard.
Buy Now: 210+ GST Judgments E-Magazine – October 2026
Why a guarantee attracts GST even without a fee
The petitioners/assessee challenged the taxability of corporate guarantees and the notifications and circulars governing their valuation. The threshold question was whether a parent or group company supplies a service when it undertakes to cover the default risk on another group company’s borrowing without charging for that undertaking.
The Bench held that the service consists of assuming the risk of default and extending the guarantor’s creditworthiness to the related borrower. Under Section 7(1)(c) of the CGST Act, read with Entry 2 of Schedule I, supplies between related persons in the course or furtherance of business can attract GST even without consideration.
The related borrower is the recipient of the service under Section 2(93)(c), even though the guarantee is furnished to the lender. The court also rejected the claims that providing the guarantee falls outside the levy as an actionable claim under Schedule III or as a security excluded from the definition of services. It distinguished the Supreme Court’s decision in Edelweiss, explaining that the service tax provision at issue there made consideration part of the definition of a service.
Rule 28(2) survives, but the 1% benchmark can be rebutted
Notification No. 52/2023–Central Tax introduced Rule 28(2) with effect from 26 October 2023. Notification No. 12/2024–Central Tax, dated 10 July 2024, amended the rule with effect from the same date. As amended, the rule generally values a covered guarantee for a related recipient located in India at 1% of the amount guaranteed per annum or the actual consideration, whichever is higher, subject to the full input tax credit proviso.
The court upheld the rule-making power under Sections 15 and 164 of the CGST Act. It held, however, that applying the 1% benchmark as a fixed floor, even where reliable evidence establishes a lower open market value, is arbitrary under Article 14 of the Constitution. The Bench read down the rule to allow the supplier to prove that lower value. The proper officer can examine the evidence, and an agreed intra-group fee or the absence of a fee does not by itself establish market value.
The court upheld the proviso that deems the value declared in the invoice to be the value of the service where the recipient is eligible for full input tax credit. Whether a particular recipient meets that condition remains a factual question.
Execution and later changes determine when a supply occurs
The Bench held that the supply takes place when the guarantee is executed. A renewal, extension of tenure or enhancement of the guaranteed amount gives rise to a further supply, valued by reference to the additional period or amount, as applicable. The court held that a corporate guarantee is outside the definition of a continuous supply of services under Section 2(33), and that the time of supply is governed by Section 13(2)(a) or (b).
For a guarantee with a fixed tenure, the tax is computed at execution for the entire tenure. The court allowed the department to collect it in annual instalments. If the guarantee is released or discharged early, the supplier may reduce the value attributable to the unexpired period through a credit note under Section 34, subject to its conditions and time limits.
Which valuation rules apply to older guarantees?
| When the guarantee was executed or changed | Delhi High Court’s ruling |
| Executed before 1 July 2017, with no subsequent renewal, extension or enhancement | The guarantee does not attract GST. |
| Executed from 1 July 2017 through 25 October 2023 | GST applies. Valuation follows the rules then in force, including Rules 28, 30 and 31 as applicable. Rule 31 cannot be used to import the later 1% benchmark as a uniform measure. |
| Executed, renewed, extended or enhanced on or after 26 October 2023 | Rule 28(2) applies where its conditions are met, subject to the court’s reading down and the full input tax credit proviso. |
A guarantee executed before 26 October 2023 does not come within Rule 28(2) simply because it remains outstanding after that date. The Bench upheld the 2024 amendment’s retrospective operation from 26 October 2023 and directed that CBIC Circular Nos. 204/16/2023-GST and 225/19/2024-GST be applied consistently with the judgment.
Where Delhi differed from the Gujarat High Court
The Delhi High Court agreed with the Gujarat High Court’s decision in Torrent Power that a related-party corporate guarantee can be taxable without consideration, that the related borrower receives the service, and that the deemed value cannot operate as an inflexible minimum. It differed on what can displace the benchmark. The Delhi Bench required proof of a lower open market value, subject to the full-credit proviso. It also rejected a recurring annual time of supply and held that the valuation rules in force before 26 October 2023 could be used to determine liability for guarantees executed during the earlier GST period.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: Centre Can Decline Anti-Dumping Duty Despite Positive Recommendation: Delhi High Court

