The Delhi High Court has upheld the Centre’s decision to decline anti-dumping duty on polystyrene imports from six countries and territories, even after the Designated Authority found that dumped imports had injured Indian producers and recommended a definitive levy.
The bench of Justices Anil Kshetarpal and Harish Vaidyanathan Shankar has observed that the Centre could weigh the needs of downstream manufacturers, the availability of competitively priced imports and the risk of concentrating domestic supply in the hands of two producers.
Buy Now: Indirect Tax Judgments E-Compilation – October 2026
The Bench rejected the constitutional challenge to Section 9A(1) of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 and Rule 18 of the 1995 Anti-Dumping Rules. It also upheld the Centre’s Office Memorandum dated November 11, 2020 declining to impose the duty.
The investigation covered polystyrene other than expandable polystyrene, originating in or exported from Iran, Malaysia, Singapore, Chinese Taipei, the United Arab Emirates and the United States. In its final findings dated June 12, 2020, the Designated Authority recommended definitive duties on a country- and producer-specific basis.
The petitioner/assessee is a domestic polystyrene producer, argued that the statutory framework gave the Centre unguided discretion to disregard the recommendation. It asked the Court to quash the Office Memorandum and direct the government to implement the recommended duties. It also challenged the Centre’s reliance on material that had not been disclosed to it before the decision.
The Bench held that Article 9.1 of the WTO Anti-Dumping Agreement gives importing members discretion over whether to impose duty even when the requirements for a levy are met. It also allows members to allocate those functions within their domestic systems.
Under India’s framework, the Designated Authority examines dumping, injury to the domestic industry and the causal link between the two. It makes a recommendation under Rule 17. The Centre then decides under Section 9A(1) and Rule 18 whether to impose the duty. The Court held that the authority’s findings, the public interest and the purpose of the anti-dumping regime guide that discretion. It therefore rejected the challenge under Article 14 of the Constitution.
The Designated Authority had recorded a decline in domestic capacity utilisation and market share over the period it examined, while the market share of imports from the investigated sources nearly doubled. The Centre considered a subsequent development. One of the three domestic producers had ceased operations following a fire.
The Centre obtained an assessment from NITI Aayog and other government agencies on the likely demand and supply effects of the proposed levy. The Court found that the plant closure and the assessment gave the government a rational basis to examine whether the two remaining producers could adequately supply downstream manufacturers if access to competitively priced imports was curtailed.
The Bench explained that the Designated Authority’s findings addressed what had caused injury during the period under investigation. The Centre’s assessment addressed future supply after the domestic production base changed. In deciding whether to impose the levy, the Centre could balance the interests of domestic producers, downstream manufacturers and consumers.
The High Court described the Designated Authority’s investigation and final findings as quasi-judicial. The domestic producer had received a hearing during that investigation. The Bench characterised the Centre’s subsequent decision to decline the levy, in the circumstances of this case, as legislative or quasi-legislative.
The Court held that the statute and rules did not require a second oral hearing before the Centre or prior disclosure of the NITI Aayog assessment at that stage. It distinguished the Supreme Court’s decision in Reliance Industries, which concerned the calculation of the non-injurious price in a case where anti-dumping duty had been recommended and imposed.
The Bench held that the Centre’s decision remains reviewable under Article 226. A court can examine whether the government acted within its statutory authority, respected fundamental rights and relied on relevant material rationally connected to its conclusion. It can also examine whether irrelevant considerations or mala fides influenced the decision.
The Court reviewed the record as a whole, including the Centre’s counter-affidavit, and found a rational connection between the material before the government and its decision. It left open the separate question of whether an appeal against a Central Government decision lies before CESTAT under amended Section 9C of the Customs Tariff Act, an issue pending in another case.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: Specialised Eye-Care Chairs, Tables And Trolleys Attract 18% GST As Medical Furniture: AAR

