The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Prayagraj, has held that the Uttar Pradesh State Tax Department could not treat the entire difference between a company’s PAN-level Form 26AS and the combined GST returns of registrations across several states as taxable turnover of its Hamirpur registration.
The Division Bench of Judicial Member Mahtab Ahmad and Technical Member Ashish Varma has observed that the absence of evidence linking the disputed turnover to the Uttar Pradesh registration defeated the demand on jurisdictional grounds and also made the invocation of Section 74 against that registration unsustainable.
Buy Now: All 200+ GSTAT Judgements Till November 2026 | Comprehensive E-Magazine
The Bench inferred deliberate suppression from the taxpayer’s failure to produce records after repeated written queries, but held that the department still had to link the alleged short payment to the Uttar Pradesh GST registration.
The company held 13 GST registrations under a single PAN. For FY 2018–19, the department compared ₹10.33 crore reflected in Form 26AS with approximately ₹8.76 crore declared in the combined GSTR-3B returns of four registrations in Uttar Pradesh, Maharashtra, Telangana and Chhattisgarh. It treated the resulting ₹1.57 crore difference as consideration for intra-State construction services in Uttar Pradesh and applied GST at 18%.
The department’s own figures showed that the Uttar Pradesh registration reported identical turnover of ₹5.47 crore in GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B for FY 2018–19. The differences between those two returns arose in the other three registrations included in the comparison.
For FY 2019–20, the department compared approximately ₹20.54 crore in Form 26AS with ₹17.73 crore in combined GSTR-3B returns across five states, arriving at a difference of ₹2.81 crore. The show cause notice did not identify a mismatch within the Uttar Pradesh registration’s returns. The amounts ultimately confirmed were as follows.
| Component | FY 2018–19 | FY 2019–20 |
| CGST and SGST | ₹28,28,107.94 | ₹38,35,080.00 |
| Interest under Section 50 | ₹33,51,307.90 | ₹38,54,255.40 |
| Penalty under Section 74 | ₹28,28,107.94 | ₹38,35,080.00 |
| Total | ₹90,07,523.78 | ₹1,15,24,415.40 |
The Deputy Commissioner confirmed the demands on May 21, 2025. The first appellate authority upheld them on July 25, 2025, citing the company’s failure to produce supporting documents and inferring that it intended to evade tax. The company argued before the Tribunal that the department had attributed a multi-state discrepancy to Uttar Pradesh without establishing where the underlying supplies were made or which registration made them.
The Tribunal explained that GST registrations under the same PAN are treated as distinct persons under Section 25 of the GST law. Although the Hamirpur officer had jurisdiction over the Uttar Pradesh registration, a demand against that registration required material linking it to the alleged unpaid tax. The department also needed to establish the nature of the supplies before treating them as intra-State transactions liable to CGST and Uttar Pradesh SGST.
The Bench found that the department had identified no project site, recipient, invoice, payer or supplying registration tied to the disputed amounts. For FY 2018–19, the demand summary recorded the place of supply as “NA” and described the issue as excess input tax credit even though the dispute concerned outward supplies.
The Bench held that Form 26AS, which is compiled from deductors’ statements at the PAN level, can prompt an inquiry. Its entries can include advances, non-taxable receipts, amounts relating to other registrations and amounts later reversed. Here, the department had neither contacted a deductor or recipient nor examined any contract or invoice. The Tribunal drew on the reasoning in the CESTAT’s service tax decision in Kush Constructions v. CGST, NACIN, Kanpur, which required the department to examine the reasons for the difference and establish that the amount represented consideration for taxable services.
The Bench took a serious view of the company’s conduct. It recorded that the company had failed to respond to preliminary communications and replied to the show cause notices only after reminders. Although it submitted consolidated returns and a unit-wise turnover statement, it produced no work orders, payment certificates, bank statements or deductor-wise reconciliation. Its explanation also shifted from a GST portal difficulty to credit notes and turnover allocation issues.
The Tribunal treated the sustained withholding of records after repeated written queries as deliberate suppression and inferred an intent to evade tax. It nevertheless held that the department bore the initial burden of linking the alleged short payment to the registration it proceeded against. The adverse inference could undermine the company’s explanation, but it could not establish that the suppressed facts or any unpaid tax related to the Uttar Pradesh GST registration. The Tribunal confined its ruling to that registration and left liability in other states open.
The Tribunal declined to remand the matter under Section 113(1), reasoning that the department had held the underlying data from the outset and a remand would allow it to supplement a case that could not be sustained as framed. It set aside the adjudication and first appellate orders and quashed the show cause notices dated October 24, 2024, to the extent that they proposed demands against the Uttar Pradesh registration. The interest and penalties fell with the tax demands.
The company may apply for a refund of any appellate pre-deposits made under Sections 107(6) or 112(8). The Tribunal directed the authorities to consider such an application, including any interest payable under Section 115, within 30 days of receiving it with a copy of the judgment. The Bench made no order as to costs.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: Invoices and E-Way Bills Fail to Prove Receipt of Goods as GSTAT Finds Transport Receipts Fabricated

