The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Ahmedabad, directed the Assessing Officer to apply the 25% basic corporate tax rate for assessment year 2020–21 after the Centralised Processing Centre (CPC) raised it to 30% without prior intimation.
The bench of Soundararajan K. (Judicial Member) and Waseem Ahmed (Accountant Member) separately denied the company’s claim for the 22% concessional rate under Section 115BAA because it had neither selected the regime in its return nor filed Form 10-IC for that year.
Buy Now: Direct tax (Income Tax) Judgments E-Magazine October 2026
CPC accepted the declared income but raised the tax rate
The company, which provides marine transportation and logistics services, filed its ITR-6 on 31 January 2021, declaring income of about ₹3.52 crore. It selected Section 115BA in the return, which it described as a clerical error, and computed its tax at the 25% basic rate. The return showed a tax liability of ₹98,00,202, including applicable surcharge and cess.
The CPC accepted the returned income but applied a 30% rate in its Section 143(1) intimation dated 18 December 2021. The company challenged the resulting differential demand of ₹25,36,230. Its rectification application under Section 154 was rejected, and the first appellate authority upheld the denial of the concession on the ground that the company had failed to furnish Form 10-IC.
Prior intimation was mandatory under Section 143(1)(a)
The tribunal found that the CPC had issued no prior intimation of the proposed adjustment and gave no reason for applying the higher rate. Relying on the Bombay High Court’s decision in Bax India Ventures Pvt. Ltd. v. Central Processing Centre, the bench held that the first proviso to Section 143(1)(a) requires prior intimation and that the adjustment was procedurally unsustainable without it.
The bench also found that the company’s turnover or gross receipts for FY 2017–18 were below ₹400 crore, making it eligible for the 25% basic rate under the normal provisions for AY 2020–21. Its tax computation was consistent with that rate. The tribunal accordingly directed the Assessing Officer to apply the correct rate.
Form 10-IC filed for the next year could not secure the 22% rate
The company argued that it had selected Section 115BA by mistake in the first year of the concessional regime. The bench examined both the return and the tax computation. The return contained no election under Section 115BAA, and the company had calculated tax at 25%. The Form 10-IC filed on 22 February 2022 related to AY 2021–22, the first year for which the company exercised the option.
CBDT Circular No. 6/2022 allowed eligible domestic companies extra time to file Form 10-IC for AY 2020–21. Among its conditions, the company had to select Section 115BAA in ITR-6 and submit the form by the extended deadline. The tribunal found that the company met neither condition for AY 2020–21.
The bench distinguished the Gujarat High Court’s ruling in Surat Smart City Development Ltd. v. PCIT. That taxpayer had selected Section 115BAA in ITR-6 and calculated its tax at 22%, giving it a basis to seek condonation for the delay in furnishing the form. Here, the return and the computation showed that the company had never opted into the regime for the year in dispute.
The ITAT condoned a 367-day delay in filing the tribunal appeal after considering the company’s explanation that the first appellate order was sent to other email addresses despite the address specified in its appeal form. It partly allowed the appeal, directing application of the 25% basic rate and rejecting the claim for the 22% concession.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: Different FY Alone Can’t Disqualify Transfer Pricing Comparable if Reliable Data Is Available: ITAT

