The Patna High Court has upheld a 5% GST levy on atta, maida and sooji sold by a Gaya flour mill in 50 kg bags during FY 2018–19. The court held that the manufacturer’s name, printed three times on the bags, qualified as a brand name under the GST notifications applicable to the disputed period.
A division bench of Justices Anil Kumar Sinha and Vikash Kumar denied the flour mill’s exemption claim for FY 2018–19 after finding that its packaging bore a brand name and that it had failed to file the affidavit required to give up its rights over that name.
Buy Now: 210+ GST Judgments E-Magazine – October 2026
The mill had reported its outward supplies as exempt or non-GST in its returns. An audit treated the flour mill’s supplies as exempt and recommended proceedings under Section 47 for failure to file Form GSTR-9C. The assessing authority subsequently initiated proceedings under Section 73, alleging that the mill had sold branded products in unit containers and wrongly claimed an exemption.
The mill argued that it printed its name and address on the bags to comply with the Legal Metrology rules. It also said that its packaging and invoices carried a disclaimer about its rights over the name and that the central notification referred to an affidavit before the jurisdictional Central Tax Commissioner.
The bench found that the mill’s name, as used on the bags, served as a brand name under the amended definition. The assessment order recorded that the name had been used locally since the late 1980s and that the mill was known for its fine white maida. The court rejected the argument that the printing could be explained solely by the Legal Metrology labelling requirements.
The 2017 GST framework covered specified goods in unit containers bearing a registered brand name or a brand name over which an actionable claim or enforceable right was available. The exception for voluntarily giving up such rights required an affidavit and a declaration printed on the packaging in English and the local language. Bihar’s corresponding Notification No. 27/2017–State Tax (Rate), published as S.O. 189 on September 21, 2017, expressly required filing the affidavit with the jurisdictional Commissioner of State Tax. The mill had filed no such affidavit.
The bench also considered the mill’s reliance on the Madras High Court’s ruling in M/s Guru and Co. v. Union of India. It held that the ruling, which had struck down the expression “enforceable right” to a limited extent, did not assist the mill in this case. The mill had not challenged the notification itself.
The High Court held that Section 73 could be invoked independently where the proper officer found grounds to proceed. The audit’s recommendation concerning late fees did not prevent the officer from initiating a separate tax determination.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: Patna High Court Restores GST Appeal Rejected as Late After Department Dropped Proceedings

