The Delhi High Court has held that using automated machinery to cut, slit and blank steel coils does not, by itself, justify treating those operations as a separate manufacturing segment for transfer pricing.
The bench of Justice Subramonium Prasad and Justice Renu Bhatnagar ordered a fresh review of a dispute involving a ₹2.51 crore adjustment after finding that the tax authorities had inadequately examined the company’s functions, assets and risks.
Buy Now: Direct tax (Income Tax) Judgments E-Magazine October 2026
The company traded and processed steel coils and supplied steel products to Honda Group companies in the automobile, motorcycle and power equipment sectors. For assessment year 2016–17, it used the Transactional Net Margin Method (TNMM) to benchmark its international transactions with associated enterprises at the entity level. The Income Tax Department had accepted that approach in scrutiny assessments for AYs 2012–13, 2013–14 and 2014–15.
The Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO) divided the business into manufacturing and trading segments and initially proposed a ₹41.33 crore upward adjustment. A rectification order restricted the adjustment to transactions with associated enterprises, reducing it to ₹7.30 crore. The Dispute Resolution Panel upheld the split but allowed a working capital adjustment and directed changes to the manufacturing comparables. Those directions eliminated the manufacturing adjustment and brought the trading adjustment down to ₹2,50,85,515 in the final assessment order.
The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) upheld separate benchmarking. It granted limited relief by excluding one company from the trading comparables and directing that the State Bank of India’s Base Rate be used to compute the working capital adjustment. It later dismissed the company’s rectification application, which alleged that several grounds remained unresolved.
The ITAT relied on the company’s automated machinery and financial records, including ₹69.94 crore in excise duty, finished-goods inventories, power and fuel costs, and depreciation. The High Court found that the tribunal had relied on those entries without verifying the underlying transactions or determining which activities the figures reflected.
The company stated in an affidavit that most coils imported from associated enterprises underwent only slitting and attracted no central excise duty. A smaller portion underwent further manufacturing alongside substantial local purchases from unrelated parties. The court recorded that the Revenue’s reply to the affidavit was absent from the record.
The bench referred to Faridabad Iron & Steel Traders Association v. Union of India, an excise ruling that held that cutting or slitting steel sheets does not amount to manufacture where no new and distinct article emerges. For transfer pricing, the bench said the authorities had to examine the functions the taxpayer actually performed, the assets it used and the risks it assumed.
The High Court found that the company’s business model had remained unchanged and that the Revenue had shown no change in circumstances that warranted departing from the approach accepted in earlier scrutiny assessments. It also found that the ITAT had inadequately addressed the company’s functional analysis and audited segmental data and had left material grounds on consistency and the allocation of income and expenses unresolved.
The court set aside the challenged portions of the two ITAT orders and remanded the matter to the Assessing Officer. The Assessing Officer and TPO must reconsider the company’s transfer pricing study, its objections, the appropriate segmentation, the choice of comparables and the adjustments claimed. The company must receive an effective hearing before a reasoned order is passed. The appropriate benchmarking method and any resulting adjustment remain open for fresh determination.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.

