The Delhi High Court has struck down a ₹1,20,37,863 income-tax addition relating to an alleged undisclosed HSBC account in Switzerland and held that the Income Tax Department could not use Section 153A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 to disturb a completed assessment for assessment year 2006–07 when the search yielded no incriminating material supporting the addition.
The bench of Justices Subramonium Prasad and Renu Bhatnagar allowed both appeals filed by the taxpayer and set aside the ITAT’s remand and all orders that followed, holding that showing a document already in the tax department’s possession during a search did not amount to discovering incriminating material in that search.
Buy Now: Direct tax (Income Tax) Judgments E-Magazine October 2026
The department already held the seven-page document on which it relied. Officers showed it to the taxpayer during the search, but recovered no material linking the document to the alleged undisclosed income. The ruling turned on the Assessing Officer’s jurisdiction under Section 153A.
The taxpayer filed his original return on 30 October 2006, declaring income of ₹20,73,131. During a search of his residence on 20 January 2012, officers confronted him with a seven-page document that purportedly identified him as a beneficial owner of accounts with HSBC in Switzerland. The document contained personal details including his name, date of birth and address. The taxpayer denied having the alleged account in his statement recorded under Section 132(4).
The department issued a Section 153A notice on 17 October 2012. The taxpayer again declared income of ₹20,73,131. The Assessing Officer treated ₹1,20,37,863 as an unexplained investment under Section 69 and separately added ₹1,23,130 as alleged interest on the foreign deposit. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) deleted the interest addition but sustained the addition relating to the deposit.
In February 2018, the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal sent the matter back to the Assessing Officer to obtain a verification report. The Tribunal observed that the taxpayer had denied ownership and that the material then available did not conclusively establish that the alleged accounts belonged to him.
In the second round, the department sought a signed consent waiver to obtain bank details from the Swiss authorities. The taxpayer declined to sign, and the Assessing Officer did not obtain a verification report. In August 2024, the ITAT held that the remand was confined to verification and that the first round had already decided the jurisdictional challenge. It drew an adverse inference from the taxpayer’s refusal to sign the waiver and dismissed his appeal.
The High Court applied the Supreme Court’s ruling in Principal Commissioner of Income Tax v. Abhisar Buildwell Pvt. Ltd. and its own decision in CIT v. Kabul Chawla. Under those decisions, assessments pending on the date of the search abate. For a completed or unabated assessment, an addition under Section 153A requires incriminating material unearthed through the search or requisition. The Supreme Court separately preserved the power to reopen an assessment under Sections 147 and 148 where the statutory conditions are satisfied.
The bench found that the department’s pre-existing document, which it said it had obtained under a double taxation agreement, could not supply that jurisdictional basis. The search also yielded no material connecting the document to the alleged undisclosed income. The ITAT therefore erred in ordering verification of the document in 2018. The High Court pointed out that Kabul Chawla had already been decided in August 2015, before the ITAT ordered the remand.
The department also relied on the taxpayer’s post-search offer to pay tax on the deposits, which he withdrew around nine months later. The High Court held that the offer could not cure the jurisdictional defect in the Section 153A proceedings. It answered the questions of law in the taxpayer’s favour, set aside the remand and held that all orders arising from it had to be set aside.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.

