The Supreme Court upheld the Delhi High Court’s determination of mesne profits payable by Goodyear India Ltd. for continuing to occupy a godown in Daryaganj after its tenancy ended.
The bench of Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice N.V. Anjaria also upheld simple interest at 7.5% per annum, calculated from the respective months in which the compensation became payable until realisation, subject to the High Court’s concession of a reduced rate of 6% per annum if the decretal amount was paid within two months as directed.
The bench held that the Delhi High Court was entitled to intervene in second appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC). The first appellate court had overlooked testimony from Goodyear’s own witness that local rents at the relevant time ranged from ₹5 to ₹8 per square foot per month. The Supreme Court agreed that overlooking evidence directly bearing on the amount payable raised a substantial question of law.
Buy Now: 90+ Supreme Court Judgments E-Magazine – October 2026
Possession decree had become final in 2001
The dispute concerned premises on Ansari Road in Daryaganj, New Delhi. The landlords terminated the tenancy with effect from midnight on December 31, 1989, and filed suit in 1990 seeking possession and damages for continued occupation. They claimed ₹1,47,500 per month from January 2, 1990, until vacant possession was delivered, along with interest at 15% per annum.
In December 1998, the trial court decreed recovery of possession. It rejected the damages claim for the single day before the suit was filed because the evidence did not establish that the property could have been let for one day at the rate claimed. It issued a preliminary decree under Order XX Rule 12 CPC for a separate inquiry into mesne profits for the period during and after the suit.
The Delhi High Court upheld the possession decree in November 2000. The Supreme Court dismissed Goodyear’s special leave petition in March 2001, making the possession decree final. The subsequent proceedings concerned the amount payable for continued occupation.
Why the nearby bank lease was an unreliable benchmark
In 2004, the trial court fixed mesne profits at ₹22 per square foot per month for the ground-floor carpet area and ₹11 for the mezzanine, with interest at 15% per annum. It relied substantially on evidence that nearby premises on Ansari Road had been let to Vijaya Bank at a consolidated rate of ₹22 per square foot for the ground floor and basement.
The first appellate court set aside that assessment in 2010. The godown occupied a ground floor and mezzanine in buildings said to date to the 1950s. The bank occupied a ground floor and basement in a building constructed in 1972. The record contained no valuation report, municipal valuation or evidence of comparable construction quality to support treating the two premises as equivalent. The first appellate court therefore assessed mesne profits using the admitted rent.
The landlords pursued two second appeals, which concerned the periods from January 2, 1990, to March 30, 2001, and from January 2, 1990, to April 30, 1999, respectively. They sought ₹30 per square foot per month for the ground floor and ₹15 for the mezzanine on the basis of covered area, with 15% annual interest running from each month’s due date.
Tenant’s witness put local rents at ₹5 to ₹8 per sq ft
The Delhi High Court found that the first appellate court had overlooked the testimony of Goodyear officer P.V. Ramani on prevailing rents. In its common judgment of August 11, 2011, the High Court considered that admission alongside the rest of the evidence and fixed the ground-floor and mezzanine rates at ₹7 and ₹5 per square foot per month, respectively.
The Supreme Court found that both rates fell within the range given by Goodyear’s witness and that the High Court had reasonably assessed the record as a whole. It dismissed the landlords’ appeals, leaving the High Court’s rates and interest directions in place.
Market rent must be assessed on the evidence
The Supreme Court explained that mesne profits compensate a property owner for loss caused by wrongful occupation. A fair estimate depends on the property’s nature and location, prevailing rental values, the evidence and the circumstances of the case. Appellate interference is ordinarily warranted only where the assessment is manifestly arbitrary, lacks support in the record or rests on a legal error.
The Court also treated interest as an integral part of mesne profits, compensating the owner for being deprived of the beneficial enjoyment of the property during wrongful occupation. The 7.5% award and conditional 6% rate were upheld on the facts of this dispute.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: JURISHOUR | TAX LAW DAILY BULLETIN : 19 NOVEMBER, 2026

