The Lucknow Bench of the Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) has held that listing a different vehicle in Part B of the e-way bill was a material discrepancy and the company failed to explain the change or provide evidence supporting it, even though the consignment carried a tax invoice and transport documents.
The bench of Santosh Kumar Srivastava (Judicial Member) and Arvind Kumar (Technical Member) has observed that entering a different vehicle registration number was materially different from leaving Part B of the e-way bill blank. The bench found that the company had failed to provide a satisfactory explanation or supporting evidence for the change.
Buy Now: All 200+ GSTAT Judgements Till November 2026 | Comprehensive E-Magazine
The dispute concerned whether the mismatch between the vehicle declared in the e-way bill and the one actually carrying the goods could be treated as a procedural lapse.
The mobile squad intercepted the consignment on April 15, 2025. Part B of the e-way bill listed vehicle MP09DZ2643, while the goods were being transported in vehicle NL01AD8767. The shipment was accompanied by a tax invoice, a bilty and other documents.
The first appellate authority upheld the penalty. The company then challenged that decision before the GSTAT.
The assessee argued that the goods matched the accompanying documents and that it had no intention to evade tax. It asked the tribunal to treat the vehicle number discrepancy as a procedural lapse.
The State Tax Department argued that the incorrect registration number breached the requirements governing goods in transit under Section 68 read with Rules 138 and 138A of the applicable GST rules. The dispute therefore turned on the accuracy of the transport details declared in the e-way bill, even though the consignment had supporting commercial documents.
The tribunal found that the accompanying documents left the vehicle discrepancy unresolved. The registration numbers identified different vehicles, and the company supplied no satisfactory explanation or evidence accounting for the change. The bench held that the contravention was established, dismissed the appeal and confirmed the order under challenge without remanding the matter.
The narrative portion of the tribunal’s Form GST APL-04A records the upheld penalty as ₹5,01,322. The demand table in the same form lists ₹5,01,319 as the determined total, a difference of ₹3. The form records zero tax and interest.
CBIC Circular No. 64/38/2018-GST, dated September 14, 2018, lists an error in one or two digits or characters of a vehicle number among the minor discrepancies for which Section 129 proceedings should not be initiated when the consignment carries an invoice or other specified document and an e-way bill. Here, the e-way bill listed a different registration altogether, and the tribunal’s summary identifies the lack of an explanation or supporting evidence as central to the outcome.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: E-Way Bill Generated After Interception Doesn’t Cure Violation: GSTAT

