The Kolkata Bench of the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT) has sent a ₹15.66 lakh service tax dispute back to the adjudicating authority and directed it to furnish the annexures to the show-cause notice that explain how the demand was calculated. The taxpayer will have one month after receiving the annexures to file its reply and supporting documents.
The Bench of R. Muralidhar (Judicial Member) and K. Anpazhakan (Technical Member) directed the authority to pass a reasoned decision within six months of receiving the Tribunal’s order, after following the principles of natural justice. The remand covers three disputed heads of service tax and requires the authority to verify a claimed payment and review the interest calculation.
Buy Now: Indirect Tax Judgments E-Compilation – October 2026
The department issued the show-cause notice after auditing assessee. The notice concerned business auxiliary services, clearing and forwarding agency services, renting of immovable property and construction of residential complexes. The Tribunal’s order records confirmed demands under three heads.
| Service | Confirmed demand |
| Business auxiliary service | ₹8,46,464 |
| Renting of immovable property | ₹1,31,002 |
| Construction of residential complex | ₹5,89,008 |
| Total | ₹15,66,474 |
The Commissioner (Appeals) dismissed the company’s appeal on December 14, 2017. Before CESTAT, the company argued that it had never received the annexures to the show-cause notice and therefore could not determine how the department had arrived at the figures.
The company said it had already paid service tax on the commission it earned. It argued that the department had also included reimbursements from its principals in the taxable consideration. The Tribunal directed the company to produce documentary evidence of those reimbursements during fresh adjudication.
On the rental demand, the company said that it had leased the premises to Vijay Electricals, which had certified that it used the property exclusively for residential purposes. The company also argued that the rental receipts adopted for the demand did not match the rental income reflected in Form 26AS. CESTAT directed the company to submit evidence establishing the residential use of the premises.
On the construction demand, the company said it had handed the flats in question to the landowner as his share and argued that this allotment did not attract service tax. The Tribunal directed the company to place all supporting details before the adjudicating authority. The taxability of each disputed head remains open for fresh adjudication.
The department defended the confirmed demand and flagged two issues for verification. The company had claimed that it paid ₹46,900 along with ₹3,641 in interest, but the supporting challans had not been enclosed. The Revenue representative also pointed to an error in the interest calculation chart in paragraph 51 of the original adjudication order.
CESTAT directed the authority to verify both issues, consider the company’s evidence and cited case law, and issue a fresh decision after giving the company an opportunity to respond to the calculations.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: Customs Broker’s Licence Suspension Void After 15-Day Deadline Is Missed: CESTAT

