The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Mumbai, has set aside a differential customs duty demand on second-hand crane imports.
The bench of S.K. Mohanty (Judicial Member) and M.M. Parthiban (Technical Member) has observed that Customs needed specific evidence of short payment to revise values that its officers had already determined after a physical examination at the port. In this case, the adjudicating authority relied on figures from a statement that had been partly retracted and failed to follow the prescribed sequence of valuation methods.
Buy Now: Indirect Tax Judgments E-Compilation – October 2026
The dispute concerned cranes imported between January 2006 and September 2010, both directly and through high-sea sales. Local Chartered Engineers physically examined the equipment before clearance. Customs officers used their reports to revise the declared values, and the importers paid duty on the revised assessments before taking delivery.
The Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI) later alleged that the importers had understated the purchase price, freight and insurance and had remitted part of the price through unofficial channels. The Principal Commissioner raised the assessable value of 36 directly imported cranes from about ₹3.39 crore to ₹6.84 crore. For 48 cranes and one consignment of accessories imported through high-sea sales, the value increased from about ₹3.80 crore to ₹9.28 crore. The order confirmed differential duty of about ₹3.14 crore, along with interest.
The Tribunal examined Section 14 of the Customs Act, 1962 and the Customs Valuation Rules, 2007. It explained that once the declared transaction value is rejected under Rule 12, Customs must apply the alternative valuation methods in the prescribed sequence. Rule 9, the residual method, is available after the earlier methods have been considered.
The Principal Commissioner relied on figures supplied by Pulkit Choudhary during the investigation. Choudhary had retracted part of his statement before a magistrate, alleging that it had been obtained under duress. The Tribunal found that the department had neither recorded a fresh statement to address the retraction nor provided an opportunity for cross-examination. It held that the figures could not sustain the revised valuation in those circumstances. The bench also followed its earlier ruling in Crown Lifters, recording that the Bombay High Court had granted no stay in the department’s appeals as of the date of decision.
The adjudicating authority had also adjusted part of a ₹4.14 crore investigation deposit against alleged short-paid duty on consignments outside the five-year recovery period under Section 28. The Tribunal found that the authority had not confirmed a duty demand for those consignments and that the record contained no documented admission of liability or express consent to the adjustment.
The bench allowed all 16 appeals and set aside the adjudication order in full, including the confiscation, redemption fines and penalties. It granted consequential relief in accordance with law.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: Coal Royalty Forms Part of Excise Value, Stowing Duty Excluded: CESTAT

