The Supreme Court has held that a claim for interest on delayed salary arrears can arise independently of the original service dispute. The Court said the Punjab and Haryana High Court should have heard a retired Central Bank of India employee’s fresh writ petition on its merits because the delay on which he based his interest claim arose after he filed his original petition.
The Bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu has observed that the employee could not seek that substantive relief through a miscellaneous application in the original writ petition, which had already been decided. Taking account of the employee’s age and decades of litigation, the Court invoked Article 142 of the Constitution and directed the bank to pay an additional ₹5 lakh in full and final settlement of his dues.
Buy Now: 90+ Supreme Court Judgments E-Magazine – October 2026
Ashok Kumar joined Central Bank of India in 1969 and was suspended in 1978 following allegations of defalcation. A criminal court acquitted him in 1983. The High Court dismissed the State’s appeal and the bank’s revision in 1991, and the acquittal attained finality.
The bank had initiated departmental proceedings in May 1990. Kumar challenged those proceedings in June 1991, relying on his acquittal on the same charge. In October 2007, the High Court quashed the departmental proceedings and directed that he be reinstated with consequential benefits if he had yet to retire. If he had already retired, he would receive the consequential benefits alone.
The bank’s intra-court appeal failed. During its subsequent challenge before the Supreme Court, an interim order permitted the bank to conclude the disciplinary proceedings and pass a final order, but required it to obtain the Court’s leave before giving effect to that order. The bank issued a dismissal order on 30 March 2009, which could not be enforced under the interim order. Kumar retired the following day while still under suspension. The Supreme Court dismissed the bank’s special leave petition in July 2011.
Kumar sought release of his dues and later initiated contempt proceedings. The bank paid ₹37,07,445.61 on 1 December 2011 and subsequently released ₹4,89,198 in provident fund dues. The High Court disposed of the contempt proceedings in October 2013 after recording compliance with its 2007 order.
In May 2015, Kumar filed a fresh writ petition seeking 18% annual compound interest on the delayed salary payments until 1 December 2011 and further compound interest at 24% a year on the interest amount until payment. A single judge dismissed the petition in December 2023, reasoning that Kumar had omitted the interest claim from his original case and that granting it later would modify the 2007 judgment.
The Supreme Court identified 11 June 1991, the date Kumar filed the original petition, as the key date for deciding whether the claim was barred. At that point, he was challenging the initiation of disciplinary proceedings and seeking to resume work. The later delay in resolving the litigation and paying the consequential benefits had yet to occur.
The bank relied on CIT v. T.P. Kumaran, which applied constructive res judicata and Order II Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure to an interest claim that could have been raised earlier. The Bench explained that these procedural bars apply to claims that could have been raised when the earlier proceedings began. Kumar’s claim for interest arose from subsequent events and therefore rested on a separate cause of action. A fresh proceeding could examine his entitlement, the delay attributable to each party and the appropriate rate of interest.
After the dismissal of his fresh writ petition, Kumar filed a miscellaneous application under Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure in the original case. A single judge dismissed the application in March 2024, and a Division Bench upheld that decision in May 2024.
The Supreme Court agreed that the application was not maintainable. It explained that a miscellaneous application in a concluded writ petition has a limited role. It can address matters such as correcting clerical errors, clarifying an ambiguous direction or extending time for compliance. An independent claim for interest requires a substantive adjudication. Once the fresh petition was dismissed, Kumar’s proper remedy was an intra-court appeal against that dismissal.
The Bench described the interest claim as a request for restitution for the delay during litigation. It referred to Alok Shanker Pandey v. Union of India on the compensatory character of interest and recalled the principle that an act of the court should harm no litigant.
The Court considered that Kumar, by then in his seventies, had spent about a dozen years contesting criminal proceedings and more than three decades in writ litigation. It directed Central Bank of India to pay a lump sum of ₹5 lakh under Article 142. The bank must pay within two months of a copy of the judgment being produced before its competent authority. The amount constitutes full and final settlement of Kumar’s dues against the bank.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: Highway Demolitions Must Follow Law, Protects Disputed Structures in Phalodi Case: Supreme Court

