Ask Jurishour AI

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
tdb_templates
saswp_reviews
saswp-collections
saswp_rvs_location
tdc-review-email
web-story-font
web-story
googlesitekit_email
tds_locker
tds_email
saswp
mailpoet_page
mailpoet_email
tdcpt_tunes
tdc-review
pronamic_payment
pronamic_gateway
pronamic_pay_subscr
wpcode
HomeDirect TaxFaceless Assessment Notice Can’t Replace Mandatory Draft Order: Telangana High Court

Faceless Assessment Notice Can’t Replace Mandatory Draft Order: Telangana High Court

Published on

🚀 Stay Connected With JurisHour

WhatsApp X Telegram

The Telangana High Court has held that a show-cause notice issued under the faceless assessment procedure cannot substitute for the mandatory draft assessment order required under Section 144C of the Income Tax Act, 1961, where the proposed variation arises from a Transfer Pricing Officer’s order.

The Bench of Acting Chief Justice P. Sam Koshy and Justice Narsing Rao Nandikonda set aside a final assessment order involving a proposed transfer-pricing adjustment of ₹65.79 crore, holding that the omission deprived the taxpayer of its substantive right to approach the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP).

Buy Now: All 200+ GSTAT Judgements Till November 2026 | Comprehensive E-Magazine

The Court also set aside the consequential demand notice and directions for initiating penalty proceedings. However, it did not examine the merits of the transfer-pricing adjustment, which remains open for consideration through the statutory procedure.

The petitioner company manufactured hermetically sealed compressors used in air conditioners, refrigerators and commercial refrigeration applications. It also provided engineering solutions through computer-aided designing, engineering and manufacturing.

For Assessment Year 2018-19, the company filed a revised return on November 30, 2018, declaring nil total income after setting off current-year losses of ₹14,31,785.

Following selection of the case for scrutiny, a reference was made to the Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO) on March 1, 2021, to determine the arm’s length price of international transactions entered into with associated enterprises.

On July 31, 2021, the TPO proposed adjustments aggregating to ₹65,78,92,738. These comprised ₹63,92,95,748 relating to sale and manufacture of goods, ₹34,82,917 towards interest on external commercial borrowings, ₹40,13,628 for business support services and ₹1,11,00,445 towards interest on trade receivables.

The TPO’s order expressly stated that the Assessing Officer was mandatorily required to follow Section 144C before passing the final assessment order.

On September 1, 2021, the assessing authority issued a show-cause notice under the faceless assessment procedure, proposing variations arising from the transfer-pricing adjustments.

The company responded on September 3, 2021, disputing the proposed variations and relying on its submissions before the TPO. It also filed a rectification application under Section 154 before the TPO and requested consideration of the rectified amounts.

Nevertheless, the authority passed a final assessment order on September 14, 2021, under Section 143(3) read with Section 144B, without first forwarding a draft assessment order under Section 144C.

A demand notice under Section 156 accompanied the assessment order, which also directed initiation of separate penalty proceedings.

Challenging the assessment, the company argued that bypassing the draft-order stage had denied it the statutory opportunity to raise objections before the DRP.

The High Court explained that Section 144C prescribes a special procedure for eligible assessees. This category includes a person whose proposed variation arises as a consequence of a TPO’s order under Section 92CA(3).

Since the petitioner fell within that category, the Assessing Officer was required to first forward a draft assessment order proposing the prejudicial variation.

The taxpayer could then accept the proposed variation or raise objections before the DRP and the Assessing Officer. The DRP considers those objections and issues directions, following which the assessment is completed in conformity with its directions.

The Bench emphasised that review by this collegiate authority before a final assessment is made represents a substantive statutory right.

Distinguishing the two statutory provisions, the Court held that Section 144B regulates the manner in which faceless assessments are conducted, while Section 144C governs the special draft-order and DRP procedure applicable to eligible assessees.

Compliance with Section 144B therefore does not dispense with compliance with Section 144C.

A show-cause notice proposing a variation does not carry the same consequences as a draft assessment order. The former cannot replace the latter merely because the taxpayer has been given an opportunity to respond to the proposed addition.

Accordingly, the notice issued on September 1, 2021, could not fulfil the mandatory requirement under Section 144C(1).

The Bench also noted that Section 144C(1) contains an overriding clause and takes precedence over the general assessment power under Section 143(3) in cases falling within its scope.

The company pointed out that the Income Tax Department’s e-proceedings portal offered only an option to appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), without providing a facility to file objections before the DRP.

The Court found that the portal’s treatment of the order was consistent with its final character. The accompanying demand notice and directions for penalty proceedings further demonstrated that the order was a final assessment order.

The Bench also noted that the Department had followed the draft-order procedure for the company’s preceding assessment year, but had offered no explanation for adopting a different procedure in a similar case for the following year.

It held that a statutory right cannot be lost because of the manner in which a portal is configured. The taxpayer could not be faulted for failing to approach the DRP when no draft order had been served.

Relying on the Bombay High Court’s decision in SHL (India) (P) Ltd. v. CIT, the Bench reiterated that the procedure prescribed under Section 144C is mandatory.

Failure to follow it constitutes a jurisdictional error, rather than a mere procedural irregularity. Section 292B cannot cure such a defect because it cannot confer jurisdiction on the Assessing Officer where none exists.

The Court also relied on its earlier decision in Principal Commissioner of Income Tax-2, Hyderabad v. Hyundai Motor India Engineering Pvt. Ltd., decided on September 11, 2023, concerning the validity and character of an assessment order in the context of Section 144C.

The Revenue relied on Interglobe Enterprises (P) Ltd. v. NFAC to contend that the availability of a statutory appeal rendered the writ petition not maintainable.

The High Court rejected that submission, explaining that the rule of alternative remedy is discretionary. Writ intervention remains available where the impugned action is without jurisdiction, violates natural justice or breaches mandatory statutory procedure.

The Bench found that Interglobe itself supported the taxpayer. In that case, the Delhi High Court had intervened despite an alternative remedy because mandatory assessment safeguards had not been followed.

An appeal against a final assessment order could not substitute for the taxpayer’s entitlement to DRP consideration before the final assessment was made.

The High Court set aside the final assessment order dated September 14, 2021, the consequential demand notice under Section 156 and the accompanying directions for initiating penalty proceedings.

The Court identified the proper course as restoring the proceedings to the stage following the TPO’s order, allowing the statutory assessment procedure to take its course.

Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy

To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.

Membership Required

You must be a member to access this content.

View Membership Levels

Already a member? Log in here

Read More: Rajasthan High Court Upholds Rule 36(4) Restricting GST ITC For Invoices Not Uploaded By Suppliers

Mariya Paliwala
Mariya Paliwalahttps://www.jurishour.in/
Mariya is the Senior Editor at Juris Hour. She has 7+ years of experience on covering tax litigation stories from the Supreme Court, High Courts and various tribunals including CESTAT, ITAT, NCLAT, NCLT, etc. Mariya graduated from MLSU Law College, Udaipur (Raj.) with B.A.LL.B. and also holds an LL.M. She started her career as a freelance tax reporter in the leading online legal news companies.

Latest articles

Rajasthan High Court Upholds Rule 36(4) Restricting GST ITC For Invoices Not Uploaded By Suppliers

The Rajasthan High Court has upheld the constitutional validity of Rule 36(4) of the...

Customs Brokers Can’t Rely Solely On Importer’s Documents When Gold-Origin Certificates Remain Unverified: Madras High Court

The Madras High Court has dismissed a customs broker’s writ petition challenging an adjudication...

CESTAT Has No Jurisdiction Over Baggage Disputes: Madras High Court Condones 37-Day Delay In Gold Confiscation Revision

The Madras High Court has held that the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate...

More like this

Rajasthan High Court Upholds Rule 36(4) Restricting GST ITC For Invoices Not Uploaded By Suppliers

The Rajasthan High Court has upheld the constitutional validity of Rule 36(4) of the...

Customs Brokers Can’t Rely Solely On Importer’s Documents When Gold-Origin Certificates Remain Unverified: Madras High Court

The Madras High Court has dismissed a customs broker’s writ petition challenging an adjudication...