The Rajasthan High Court has upheld the constitutional validity of Rule 36(4) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017, rejecting a batch of petitions challenging restrictions on input tax credit (ITC) relating to invoices or debit notes not uploaded by suppliers.
The Bench of Justice Arun Monga and Justice Yogendra Kumar Purohit also declined to interfere with the impugned notices, observing that the challenge to them was primarily founded on the challenge to the validity of the rule. However, preserved the petitioners’ liberty to contest adverse assessment orders in accordance with law or place supporting material before the competent authorities where proceedings remained pending.
Buy Now: All 200+ GSTAT Judgements Till November 2026 | Comprehensive E-Magazine
The Court decided three connected writ petitions through a common order, taking the facts from the petition filed by an Udaipur-based government contractor engaged in constructing roads and other infrastructure projects.
As recorded in the order, Rule 36(4) was introduced through a notification dated October 9, 2019. It restricted ITC on invoices or debit notes not uploaded by suppliers under Section 37(1) of the CGST Act to 20% of the eligible credit relating to uploaded invoices or debit notes.
Through a subsequent notification dated December 26, 2019, this limit was reduced to 10% with effect from January 1, 2020.
The department issued Form GST DRC-01A dated February 6, 2020, asking the company to reverse ITC of approximately ₹1.22 crore because of a mismatch between the credit availed and the amounts reflected in GSTR-2A.
The company submitted a detailed reply on February 13, 2020, explaining the alleged mismatch. It subsequently challenged the departmental action along with the validity of Rule 36(4).
The petitioners contended that Rule 36(4) travelled beyond Section 16 of the CGST Act.
They argued that once a taxpayer satisfied the conditions prescribed under Section 16(2), credit could not be restricted merely because the supplier had failed to upload invoice details. According to them, delegated legislation could not introduce an additional restriction that the parent statute did not contemplate.
They relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in Union of India v. Intercontinental Consultants and Technocrats Pvt. Ltd., concerning the limits of rule-making powers under a statute.
The petitioners further submitted that Sections 37 and 42 already provided a framework for uploading, matching and rectifying supply details. They argued that taxpayers could not be subjected to credit restrictions when the statutory matching mechanism had not been effectively implemented because of the Government’s lack of technical preparedness.
Another contention concerned Section 43A, which had not been brought into force at the relevant time. The petitioners maintained that restrictions contemplated under that provision could not be introduced through Rule 36(4).
They also argued that the rule unfairly penalised bona fide recipients for suppliers’ defaults and violated Articles 14, 19 and 300A of the Constitution.
The respondents maintained that Rule 36(4) was supported by Sections 16 and 164 of the CGST Act.
They submitted that Section 16 permits ITC subject to prescribed conditions and restrictions, while Section 164 confers rule-making powers on the Government.
According to the respondents, the rule operated independently of Section 43A. Consequently, the fact that Section 43A had not been notified did not undermine the rule’s validity.
The Government also defended the restriction as a policy measure introduced on the GST Council’s recommendations to curb fraudulent ITC claims and protect revenue. It argued that ITC was a statutory concession whose availability could be regulated through prescribed conditions.
The Rajasthan High Court noted that the Gauhati, Madras and Kerala High Courts had already upheld the challenged provision.
It reproduced relevant portions of the Gauhati High Court’s decision in M/s High Tech Ecogreen Contractors LLP v. The Joint Director & Others. That decision held that Rule 36(4) derived authority from Section 16 and the general rule-making powers under Section 164.
The reproduced reasoning also rejected the argument that the rule became valid only upon the enforcement of Section 16(2)(aa) from January 1, 2022.
On Section 43A, the Gauhati High Court had reasoned that a provision which never came into operation could not be treated as the source of power for the rule.
The Rajasthan High Court additionally referred to the Madras High Court’s decision in M/s L. & T Geostructure LLP v. Union of India and the Kerala High Court’s decision in Nahasshukoor v. Assistant Commissioner & Others.
The Bench stated, “We are in respectful agreement with the view taken therein and see no reason to take a contrary view.”
The Bench held that the challenge to the notices rested primarily on the asserted invalidity of Rule 36(4). Since that challenge had failed, the Court found no basis to quash the notices.
It also relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in M/s Trillion Lead Factory Private Limited v. Superintendent of Central Tax, concerning the maintainability of writ petitions against show cause notices.
The Court accordingly declined interference at the notice stage, while allowing the petitioners to pursue appropriate remedies and present their supporting material before the competent authorities.
During the hearing, counsel for the parties could not confirm whether assessment orders had already been passed. The Court noted that there had been no interim stay on further proceedings.
It clarified that its order would have no bearing on proceedings that had already attained finality. If adverse assessment orders had been passed, the petitioners could challenge them in accordance with law. If favourable orders had been passed, nothing further would survive for consideration.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.

