Receiving an Income Tax notice from the Indian Income Tax Department can be unsettling for Non-Resident Indians (NRIs), particularly because compliance is often managed remotely. However, it is important to understand that an income tax notice does not automatically imply tax evasion or wrongdoing. In most cases, notices are triggered due to data mismatches, procedural lapses, or incomplete disclosures. A structured and timely response is usually sufficient to resolve the issue.
Common Reasons Why NRIs Receive Income Tax Notices
NRIs commonly receive notices due to discrepancies between income reported in the Income Tax Return (ITR) and information available with the department through third-party reporting mechanisms.
One of the most frequent causes is the non-reporting or under-reporting of interest income earned on NRO bank accounts or fixed deposits. Even when tax has been deducted at source, failure to disclose such income in the return often leads to system-generated notices.
Another major reason is non-filing or delayed filing of returns. Many NRIs assume that filing is unnecessary if tax has already been deducted, but the law mandates filing in several circumstances, including capital gains from property sales or investments.
Mismatches between Form 26AS, Annual Information Statement (AIS), and the ITR also trigger notices. Incorrect claims of Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) benefits without proper documentation such as Tax Residency Certificate (TRC) and Form 10F further invite scrutiny.
Types of Income Tax Notices Issued to NRIs
The Income Tax Act provides for different types of notices, each serving a distinct legal purpose.
A notice under Section 143(1) or 143(1)(a) is generally an intimation highlighting arithmetical errors or mismatches after return processing. Notices under Section 142(1) seek additional information or documents, while Section 143(2) notices indicate selection of the case for scrutiny assessment.
More serious notices are issued under Section 148 or 148A, which relate to reassessment proceedings where the department believes that income has escaped assessment. A defective return notice under Section 139(9) is issued when the return contains errors or missing information.
Understanding the section under which the notice is issued is crucial, as it determines the response strategy and timelines.
Immediate Steps to Take After Receiving a Notice
The first step upon receiving any notice is to remain calm and avoid hasty reactions. Most notices are procedural and can be resolved with documentation.
The authenticity of the notice must be verified using the Document Identification Number (DIN) on the Income Tax e-Filing portal. This step is essential, as fraudulent emails and messages impersonating tax authorities are common.
Once verified, the notice should be read carefully to identify the assessment year, applicable section, response deadline, issues flagged by the department, and documents required. Deadlines are statutory and missing them can result in adverse consequences.
Collecting Documents and Information
A complete and well-supported response requires proper documentation. Typically, NRIs should compile Form 26AS, AIS and TIS reports, bank statements of NRO and NRE accounts, TDS certificates, proof of residential status, and previous years’ income tax returns.
In cases involving property or investment transactions, sale deeds, purchase documents, and capital gain computation statements should be kept ready. For DTAA claims, the Tax Residency Certificate and Form 10F are mandatory and must be furnished to avoid denial of treaty benefits.
Responding Through the Income Tax e-Filing Portal
Most income tax notices today are handled through faceless electronic proceedings. Responses must be submitted through the Income Tax e-Filing portal under the “Pending Actions” or “e-Proceedings” section.
The reply should be precise, factual, and supported by documentary evidence. Irrelevant explanations or excessive attachments should be avoided. Informal responses via email or physical correspondence should not be used unless specifically permitted in the notice.
Drafting an Effective Legal Response
The response to a notice should begin with a clear reference to the notice number, section, and assessment year. Facts should be stated logically, followed by an explanation addressing the issue raised. Supporting documents must be clearly labelled and uploaded.
Where discrepancies arise due to clerical or reporting errors, the same should be acknowledged and corrected transparently. Defensive or argumentative language should be avoided, as it often complicates proceedings.
Legal Tips and Strategic Measures to Overcome Notices
One of the most effective strategies is proper use of DTAA provisions. NRIs must ensure that treaty benefits are claimed only after furnishing TRC and Form 10F. Failure to do so often results in higher tax demands and reassessment notices.
Timely response is critical. Non-compliance or delayed replies can lead to best judgment assessments under Section 144, where the tax officer determines liability without considering the taxpayer’s explanation, usually resulting in higher tax demands.
Engaging a Chartered Accountant or tax lawyer experienced in NRI taxation is strongly advisable in scrutiny or reassessment cases. Professional representation helps in accurate drafting, legal positioning, and procedural compliance.
Regular reconciliation of AIS and Form 26AS before filing returns significantly reduces the likelihood of future notices.
Consequences of Ignoring an Income Tax Notice
Failure to respond to an income tax notice can have serious legal and financial consequences. These include imposition of penalties, levy of interest, best judgment assessment, initiation of recovery proceedings, and complications in filing appeals at later stages.
Additionally, unresolved notices may delay refunds and create compliance barriers for future transactions involving property or investments in India.
Follow-Up After Submitting the Response
After submission, the acknowledgment number and response copy should be preserved. The status of proceedings should be monitored periodically on the e-Filing portal. In some cases, additional clarification or virtual hearings may be scheduled, particularly in scrutiny or reassessment proceedings.
Conclusion
An income tax notice received by an NRI is not necessarily an indicator of tax evasion. In most cases, it arises due to reporting mismatches, documentation gaps, or procedural errors. Prompt verification, careful analysis, timely response, and proper documentation are the key to resolving such notices efficiently.
With structured compliance and professional guidance where required, NRIs can successfully address income tax notices and prevent future litigation or financial exposure.
Read More: Wrong Deduction Claim Alone Doesn’t Attract Penalty If MAT Tax Is Paid: ITAT
