The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Ahmedabad, has allowed 18 appeals against the denial of customs duty refunds on the ground of unjust enrichment. The importers relied on Chartered Accountant certificates backed by worksheets and sales records to show that they had borne the duty themselves.
The bench of Somesh Arora (Judicial Member) followed earlier Tribunal rulings endorsed by the Gujarat High Court and allowed all the appeals with consequential relief and the claims listed in the order add up to ₹88,68,534.
Buy Now: Indirect Tax Judgments E-Compilation – October 2026
The dispute turned on whether the importers had recovered the customs duty from their buyers. Section 27 of the Customs Act, 1962 requires a refund claimant to furnish evidence that the duty burden was not passed on to another person. Section 28D presumes that the person who paid the duty passed its full burden on to the buyer, unless that person proves otherwise.
Advocate Rahul Gajera, appearing for the appellants, submitted that each appeal included a Chartered Accountant’s certificate confirming that the duty burden had not been passed on. The appellants also relied on supporting worksheets, sale invoices and bills of entry. Sunita Menon, Superintendent and authorised representative for the department, reiterated the findings under challenge when the earlier rulings were put to her.
The Tribunal followed the Gujarat High Court’s August 4, 2026 ruling in Commissioner, Customs (Preventive) v. Dynamic Ship Recyclers Pvt. Ltd. In that case, bunker oil was sold for less than the import value on which customs duty was assessed. The High Court upheld the Tribunal’s finding that the evidence showed the importer had absorbed the duty. Once the importer produced sufficient evidence, the burden shifted to the department to show that the duty had been recovered from buyers.
The High Court also held that recording customs duty as an expense in the profit and loss account did not, by itself, establish that the importer had passed the duty on to customers. It dismissed the department’s appeals after finding that the Tribunal’s factual conclusions raised no substantial question of law.
CESTAT found that the same issue had already been decided in cases where Chartered Accountant certificates showed that the importers had borne the duty. With certificates and supporting records before it, the bench applied the Gujarat High Court precedent and allowed all 18 appeals.

