The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), Chennai, has held that a manufacturer cannot be denied CENVAT credit of service tax paid on television broadcasting services merely because the channels issued their invoices to the advertising agency through which the advertisements were booked.
The bench of Vasa Seshagiri Rao (Technical Member) and Ajayan T.V. (Judicial Member) upheld CENVAT credit of ₹1,58,15,615 for March 2011 to February 2013. It found that the manufacturer had commissioned the advertisements, paid the broadcasting charges and service tax, and received and used the services for its products.
Buy Now: Indirect Tax Judgments E-Compilation – October 2026
The Bench further found that the sole reason for authorising the Revenue’s appeal—to keep the issue alive pending a challenge to an earlier precedent—had ceased to exist.
The appellant/assessee manufactures hosiery garments under the “LUX” brand. It engaged Prachar Communications Limited, Mumbai, to arrange television advertisements for its products.
Prachar booked airtime with Zee Entertainment Enterprises Limited, Sony Entertainment Television and other channels. The channels billed Prachar and paid service tax on the broadcasting charges.
Prachar subsequently raised invoices on Lux Industries, showing the broadcasting charges and corresponding service tax as reimbursements. Its agency commission and service tax on that commission were shown separately.
The manufacturer availed CENVAT credit of service tax on both components.
During the audit, the Department accepted credit on Prachar’s commission but disputed credit on broadcasting charges. Its objection was that the channels had invoiced Prachar rather than Lux Industries.
A show cause notice dated March 15, 2016 proposed denial of ₹1,58,15,615 in credit by invoking the extended limitation period, along with interest and penalty under Section 11AC of the Central Excise Act, 1944, read with Rule 15(2) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. The adjudicating authority confirmed the proposals.
The Commissioner (Appeals) reversed the adjudication order on July 20, 2018.
The appellate authority found that Prachar’s consolidated invoices disclosed the service tax paid by the channels and the agency, together with the requisite particulars. The channels’ invoices identified Lux Industries as the advertiser, while Prachar acted only as a pure agent.
Payment of service tax, receipt of the broadcasting service, its use in relation to the manufacturer’s goods and ownership of the LUX brand were undisputed.
The Commissioner (Appeals) held that any documentary deficiency was covered by Rule 9(2) of the CENVAT Credit Rules. Reliance was placed on Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. CCE, Mumbai-II and Zapak Digital Entertainment Ltd. v. CST, Mumbai-II.
Before CESTAT, the Revenue maintained that Prachar received the broadcasting services because the television channels addressed their invoices to it. According to the Department, only Prachar could claim the corresponding input service credit.
The Revenue also argued that Prachar paid service tax only on its commission, without including broadcasting charges in the taxable value of its own services. It alleged violations of the CENVAT Credit Rules and Rule 4A of the Service Tax Rules, 1994.
It further contended that Rule 9(2) could not cure credit claimed on invoices not issued by the service provider.
Lux Industries countered that payment of tax, receipt of the service and its business use were undisputed. It also argued that the Department could not accept credit on the commission paid for procuring the broadcast while denying that the manufacturer received the broadcast itself.
Examining the review proceedings, CESTAT found that both members of the Committee of Commissioners agreed that the Commissioner (Appeals)’ order deserved acceptance on merits.
Their difference concerned whether an appeal should nevertheless be filed because the Department had challenged one of the precedents relied upon in that order.
The Tribunal found that the appeal was authorised to “keep the issue alive” pending the Bombay High Court’s decision in Zapak Digital Entertainment, rather than because the Committee doubted the appellate order’s correctness on merits.
The Department’s appeal against Zapak Digital Entertainment had subsequently been dismissed, as reported in 2018 (18) GSTL 583 (Bom.). Consequently, the foundation for the present appeal no longer existed.
The Bench did not consider it necessary to examine the extent of the Principal Chief Commissioner’s power on the reference under Section 35B(2) of the Central Excise Act.
CESTAT noted that the Commissioner (Appeals) had independently relied on Indian Oil Corporation Ltd., 2014 (36) S.T.R. 833 (Tri.-Mum.). The review order did not address that decision, and the Revenue did not claim that it had been challenged.
That precedent allowed credit where advertisements were broadcast on behalf of the assessee, the bills identified it as the advertiser, and it bore the tax burden. The same factual features existed in the present case.
The Tribunal also referred to Kellogg India Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner, 2022 (9) TMI 1280-CESTAT Mumbai, which followed Indian Oil Corporation and Zapak Digital Entertainment.
In Power Soap Ltd., 2018 (7) TMI 254-CESTAT Chennai, credit had similarly been allowed where the invoices identified the agency, the assessee and its product, and payment of tax and receipt of service were established.
The Madras High Court dismissed the Revenue’s appeal against Power Soap on January 3, 2019, holding that no substantial question of law arose. CESTAT observed that the jurisdictional High Court had thus declined to interfere on the identical issue.
On merits, the Tribunal rejected the argument that broadcasting became Prachar’s input service merely because the channels invoiced the agency.
Prachar had neither paid output service tax on the broadcasting charges nor availed credit of the service tax charged by the channels. The broadcasting charges and tax passed through the agency to Lux Industries as reimbursements.
The Bench referred to the Board’s Circular F. No. 341/43/96-TRU dated October 31, 1996, extracted in Indian Oil Corporation, concerning the exclusion of payments for electronic media space and time from the advertising agency’s taxable value, apart from its commission.
The advertisements concerned Lux Industries’ products. The company commissioned them, paid for their broadcast, bore the service tax and used the service in relation to manufacture and clearance of its goods.
CESTAT held that the manufacturer received the service within the meaning of Rule 3 of the CENVAT Credit Rules. Advertisement also expressly falls within the inclusive portion of the definition of “input service” under Rule 2(l).
The Tribunal found an internal inconsistency in the Department’s position.
The Revenue had allowed credit of service tax on Prachar’s commission under the same invoices. That commission represented consideration for procuring airtime for Lux Industries.
Having accepted that the manufacturer received the agency service of procuring the broadcast, the Department could not contend that it did not receive the resulting broadcast.
Both components arose from a single transaction, the Bench reasoned.
CESTAT held that Prachar’s invoices disclosed the service tax paid by the channels, the description and value of the service, and the parties’ particulars. The Commissioner (Appeals) had therefore correctly applied Rule 9(2).
The Tribunal relied on Shivraj Cable Network v. CCE, Raigad, 2015 (39) S.T.R. 670 (Tri.-Mum.), where credit was allowed despite invoices naming another person because the records established receipt, payment and accounting of the service by the assessee.
The present case was stronger because the channels’ invoices identified Lux Industries as the advertiser and Prachar’s invoices were issued to it.
There was also no risk of duplicate credit, since Prachar had not claimed the disputed credit.
The Tribunal dismissed the Revenue’s appeal and upheld the Commissioner (Appeals)’ order allowing ₹1,58,15,615 in CENVAT credit. It granted consequential relief, if any, in accordance with law.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: Reimbursable Expenses Not Taxable For Pre-2015 Period: CESTAT Quashes Service Tax Demand

