The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Dehradun, held that GST had to be calculated within the prices a bicycle dealer had already charged customers after it became liable to pay tax under the regular scheme.
The bench of Naresh Katyal (Judicial Member) and Amand Shah (Technical Member) upheld a differential GST demand of ₹8.92 lakh in its signed ruling and set aside a separate ₹50,000 general penalty and rejected the dealer’s input tax credit (ITC) claims on purchases and opening stock, holding that the later assessment at the regular rate did not reopen the statutory deadlines.
Buy Now: 210+ GST Judgments E-Magazine – October 2026
The dealer reported outward supplies of ₹1,42,97,621 for FY 2018–19, exceeding the ₹75 lakh composition threshold that the tribunal held was applicable to it in Uttarakhand. It therefore became liable to pay regular GST from April 1, 2019. The dealer continued paying GST at 1% for FY 2019–20, saying its part-time accountant had advised that the threshold was ₹1.5 crore. It accepted liability under the regular scheme but sought credit for tax paid on its purchases and stock.
The department applied the 12% GST rate directly to the dealer’s FY 2019–20 turnover of ₹91,85,178. After deducting ₹91,852 already paid, it confirmed a demand of ₹10,10,370. The first appellate authority reduced the demand to ₹8,92,274. The dealer appealed to GSTAT over the denial of ITC, while the department filed a cross-objection challenging the tax calculation.
The bench noted that Section 10(4) of the CGST Act bars composition taxpayers from collecting GST from customers. The dealer had charged no GST separately, so the tribunal upheld the treatment of the amounts already received as tax-inclusive under Section 15(1) of the Act read with Rule 35 of the CGST Rules.
Applying the fraction 12/112 to the turnover yielded ₹9,84,126 in gross tax. Deducting the ₹91,852 already paid left ₹8,92,274 in differential tax, a reduction of ₹1,18,096 from the original demand. The bench relied on the Hyderabad GSTAT ruling in Shri Parameshwara Bricks v. State Tax Office and dismissed the department’s cross-objection.
For purchases made during FY 2019–20, the bench applied Sections 16(4) and 16(5) of the CGST Act. Section 16(5) retrospectively permits eligible ITC for FY 2017–18 through FY 2020–21 where the relevant return under Section 39 was filed by November 30, 2021. The dealer had filed composition forms but had filed no GSTR-3B claiming the credit by that date. GSTAT held that the dealer’s 2024 reply to the show-cause notice could not serve as a fresh claim for the credit.
For stock held on March 31, 2019, the bench recognised that the switch to regular taxation brought the dealer within Section 18(1)(c) in principle. Section 18(2), however, gave the dealer one year from the date of each invoice to take the credit. Even for an invoice dated March 31, 2019, the window had expired by March 31, 2020. The subsequent assessment at the regular rate did not revive that claim.
The GSTAT upheld interest under Section 50 and sustained penalties of ₹44,614 each under Section 73 of the central and Uttarakhand GST laws, totalling ₹89,228. It set aside the two general penalties of ₹25,000 each under Section 125, relying on that provision and Section 75(13), which bars a further penalty for the same act or omission when a Section 73 penalty has already been imposed.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: GSTAT Restores ITC Demand as GSTR-3B Was Filed After Extended Deadline

