The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Varanasi, has dismissed the Uttar Pradesh State Tax Department’s appeal seeking to restore a ₹51,23,201 penalty on a transporter whose e-way bills had expired 13 hours and 25 minutes before its truck was intercepted and found no evidence of an attempt or intention to evade tax and upheld the cancellation of the penalty under Section 129 of the CGST and UPGST Acts.
The bench of Narendra Bahadur Yadav (Judicial Member) and Ananjai Kumar Rai ( Technical Member) also allowed the transporter’s appeal against a separate ₹20,000 penalty imposed by the First Appellate Authority and held that the authority had failed to give the transporter an opportunity to respond to the proposed levy under Section 107(11).
Buy Now: All 200+ GSTAT Judgements Till November 2026 | Comprehensive E-Magazine
A State Tax mobile squad intercepted the truck in Siddharth Nagar district, Uttar Pradesh, at 1.25 p.m. on April 15, 2024. The e-way bills had been generated on April 8 and were valid through April 14. The driver could not produce an extension, and officers seized the vehicle and goods and issued a show-cause notice.
I.P. Roadlines (India) Limited said the consignment had started its journey with valid e-way bills and e-invoices. It attributed the delay to a vehicle breakdown amid road blockages linked to Lok Sabha election rallies in western Uttar Pradesh. The company said it missed the extension window because it did not receive information from the driver in time. It also said the truck was close to its destination when officers stopped it.
The adjudicating authority rejected the explanation and imposed a ₹51,23,201 penalty under Section 129(3), citing a breach of Rule 138. The First Appellate Authority set aside that penalty but imposed ₹20,000 under Section 122(1)(xiv), read with Section 20 of the IGST Act. The department challenged the cancellation of the larger penalty, while the transporter challenged the separate levy.
The department argued that failure to extend the e-way bills within eight hours of expiry breached Rule 138 and attracted a penalty under Section 129. The tribunal considered the circumstances of the journey, noting that election campaigning in western Uttar Pradesh at the time was undisputed. It accepted the breakdown explanation, found the delay reasonable and recorded that the evidence showed no attempt or intention to evade tax.
The bench relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in Assistant Commissioner (ST) v. Satyam Shivam Papers Pvt. Ltd. In that case, the Supreme Court declined to interfere with a Telangana High Court ruling that officers had inferred tax evasion from an expired e-way bill without properly considering the explanation that a traffic blockade delayed delivery. Applying that reasoning to the facts before it, the GSTAT upheld the cancellation of the ₹51,23,201 penalty.
Section 107(11) empowers the First Appellate Authority to confirm, modify or annul an order under appeal. Its first proviso requires the authority to give the appellant a reasonable opportunity to show cause against a proposed order enhancing a penalty. The tribunal applied that safeguard to the separate ₹20,000 levy and found that the transporter had received no opportunity to address it before the authority imposed it.
The tribunal allowed the transporter’s appeal, set aside the Rs. 20,000 penalty and dismissed the department’s appeal. Each side was directed to bear its own costs.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: Cess Credit Shown in GSTR-2A Can’t Offset GST Demand Without Timely GSTR-3B Claim: GSTAT

