Ask Jurishour AI

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
tdb_templates
saswp_reviews
saswp-collections
saswp_rvs_location
tdc-review-email
web-story-font
web-story
googlesitekit_email
tds_locker
tds_email
saswp
mailpoet_page
mailpoet_email
tdcpt_tunes
tdc-review
pronamic_payment
pronamic_gateway
pronamic_pay_subscr
wpcode
HomeGSTGSTAT Allows Tax-Inclusive Pricing After Composition Scheme Exit, Denies Time-Barred ITC

GSTAT Allows Tax-Inclusive Pricing After Composition Scheme Exit, Denies Time-Barred ITC

Published on

🚀 Stay Connected With JurisHour

WhatsApp X Telegram

The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Dehradun, has held that the sale proceeds of a bicycle dealer who continued paying tax under the composition scheme after losing eligibility had to be treated as inclusive of GST. The bench sustained a differential tax demand of ₹8,92,274 for FY 2019–20 after rejecting the department’s attempt to apply 12% GST over and above the amount collected from customers.

The bench of Naresh Katyal (Judicial Member) and Amand Shah (Technical Member) also rejected the dealer’s claims for input tax credit (ITC) on purchases made during FY 2019–20 and on stock held on 31 March 2019 and upheld interest and a penalty of ₹89,228 under Section 73, while setting aside a separate ₹50,000 general penalty under Section 125.

Buy Now: 210+ GST Judgments E-Magazine – October 2026

The appellant/assessee is a Dehradun dealer in bicycles, tricycles and certain toys, reported ₹1,42,97,621 in outward supplies for FY 2018–19. Its turnover exceeded the ₹75 lakh composition threshold applicable in Uttarakhand. The bench held that the dealer became liable to pay GST under the regular scheme from 1 April 2019. 

The dealer nevertheless paid 1% composition tax on its reported FY 2019–20 turnover of ₹91,85,178. It said its part-time accountant had advised that the threshold was ₹1.50 crore. The dealer accepted liability at the regular rate but sought tax-inclusive valuation, credit for purchases and opening stock, and relief from penalties on the ground that its mistake was bona fide.

The adjudicating authority applied the 12% rate to the full turnover, arriving at gross tax of ₹11,02,222. After deducting ₹91,852 already paid under the composition scheme, it confirmed differential tax of ₹10,10,370, along with interest and penalties. The Commissioner (Appeals) reduced the differential tax to ₹8,92,274 under Rule 35 but rejected the ITC claims. The dealer pursued the credit issue before the tribunal, while the department challenged the tax-inclusive calculation.

The tribunal relied on Section 10(4) of the CGST Act, which prohibits a composition dealer from collecting GST from customers. The dealer had sold the goods without charging GST separately. The bench therefore held that the amount already collected had to be treated as a tax-inclusive price under Section 15(1) read with Rule 35 of the CGST Rules.

Using the Rule 35 formula, the Commissioner (Appeals) calculated the GST embedded in the ₹91,85,178 turnover by multiplying that amount by 12 and dividing by 112. This yielded ₹9,84,126 in gross tax. Deducting the ₹91,852 already paid brought the demand to ₹8,92,274, a reduction of ₹1,18,096 from the original differential demand.

The bench relied on the Hyderabad GSTAT’s ruling in Shri Parameshwara Bricks v. State Tax Office, where the tribunal took the same approach to sale proceeds already realised when a composition dealer was retrospectively assessed under the regular scheme. The Dehradun bench dismissed the department’s cross-objection.

The dealer sought to offset the revised liability with credit on purchases made during FY 2019–20, including about ₹6.29 lakh in integrated GST. The bench held that the claim remained subject to the time limit under Section 16(4).

Section 16(5), inserted by the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024, gave retrospective relief for invoices or debit notes relating to FY 2017–18 through FY 2020–21 where the credit was taken in a return filed by 30 November 2021. The tribunal found that the dealer had filed composition returns and had taken no such credit in a qualifying GSTR-3B. It held that a claim made in response to the 2024 show-cause notice could not satisfy that filing requirement.

The bench also recorded that the dealer had not argued that the composition status on the GST portal made filing GSTR-3B impossible. The tribunal decided the proposed credit adjustment on the case and arguments before it.

The tribunal accepted that Section 18(1)(c) could apply to stock held on 31 March 2019 because the dealer became liable under the regular scheme the following day. The claim was subject to Section 18(2), which bars credit under that provision after one year from the date of the relevant tax invoice.

The bench explained that the deadline ran separately for each invoice. Even an invoice issued on 31 March 2019 would have fallen outside the one-year window by the end of March 2020. By the time the show-cause notice was issued in 2024, the deadline for the entire opening-stock claim had expired.

The tribunal upheld interest under Section 50 on the revised differential tax. It also sustained penalties of ₹44,614 each under the central and Uttarakhand GST laws under Section 73. The dealer’s reliance on the accountant’s advice did not persuade the bench to waive those amounts.

The bench set aside the additional general penalties of ₹25,000 each under the two laws, citing Sections 125 and 75(13). The written order thus sustained ₹8,92,274 in differential tax, applicable interest and ₹89,228 in penalties, with the ₹50,000 general penalty deleted.

Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy

To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.

Membership Required

You must be a member to access this content.

View Membership Levels

Already a member? Log in here

Read More: Allahabad High Court Urges GST Portal to Show Separate Upload Date for Notices and Orders

Nikhil Bhandari
Nikhil Bhandari
Nikhil Bhandari is a Chartered Accountant and a Indirect Tax professional with over 5 years of post-qualification experience in tax advisory, compliance management, and tax process optimization. Associated with SDU LLP since August 2015 spanning his articleship through to his current role as Manager Nikhil has uniquely navigated India’s transition from the legacy tax regime into the GST era.His expertise encompasses both strategic advisory and Indirect Tax litigation, where he represents clients in complex disputes across the manufacturing, service, and e-commerce sectors. By providing high-level counsel to corporate leadership, he ensures that tax positions are not only robust and compliant but also structured for long-term operational efficiency.Beyond his core practice, Nikhil is a proactive contributor to the GST ecosystem. He is dedicated to tracking and analyzing judicial precedents from various High Courts and the Supreme Court, fostering greater clarity and ease of access to tax intelligence for the wider professional community.

Latest articles

Allahabad High Court Urges GST Portal to Show Separate Upload Date for Notices and Orders

The Allahabad High Court has suggested that the GST Common Portal display the date...

CBIC Cuts Silver Import Tariff Value by 10% to US$1,496 per Kg From November 20

The Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC) has reduced the tariff value...

GSTAT to Examine GST Credit on Employee Uniforms Used as Protective Gear

The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Jaipur Bench, is examining whether a...

GSTAT Upholds ITC Denial After Supplier Fails to Pay GST, Orders Interest Recalculation

The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Kolkata Bench, has upheld the denial...

More like this

Allahabad High Court Urges GST Portal to Show Separate Upload Date for Notices and Orders

The Allahabad High Court has suggested that the GST Common Portal display the date...

CBIC Cuts Silver Import Tariff Value by 10% to US$1,496 per Kg From November 20

The Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC) has reduced the tariff value...

GSTAT to Examine GST Credit on Employee Uniforms Used as Protective Gear

The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Jaipur Bench, is examining whether a...