The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT), Prayagraj Bench, has upheld a ₹4.17 lakh GST demand against an iron goods manufacturer after finding that the transport receipts it produced to support two purchases were fabricated.
The bench of Mahtab Ahmad (Judicial Member) and Ashish Varma (Technical Member) has observed that the manufacturer failed to establish actual receipt of the goods, a condition for claiming input tax credit (ITC) under Section 16(2)(b) of the CGST and SGST Acts.
Buy Now: 210+ GST Judgments E-Magazine – October 2026
The Bench also upheld the Section 74 show-cause notice even though it omitted the statutory phrase “fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax.” Judicial Member Mahtab Ahmad and Technical Member Ashish Varma found that the notice set out the alleged collusion, the use of invoices for goods that were never received, and the intent to evade tax.
The appellant/assessee claimed and used ₹1,40,827.50 in ITC on two invoices issued by Ganesh Enterprises, Kanpur, on June 2 and June 6, 2018. The invoices covered purchases with a combined taxable value of ₹7,82,375 and appeared in the buyer’s GSTR-2A.
The department inspected the supplier’s registered premises in 2022 and reported that it could not find the firm there. The proper officer issued a notice in Form GST DRC-01 on June 16, 2022, alleging that the buyer and supplier had colluded to claim credit on fictitious purchases. The officer confirmed the demand on June 2, 2023. The first appellate authority dismissed the manufacturer’s appeal on January 30, 2024.
The manufacturer argued that the supplier held an active GST registration when the purchases took place and that the registration was cancelled on the supplier’s own application on November 10, 2020. It said the inspection took place after the business had closed and relied on tax invoices, e-way bills, bank payments, accounting records and GST returns to support the purchases.
The manufacturer produced two goods receipts purportedly issued by Ajanta Carriers and two weighbridge slips for the first time before the GSTAT. The Bench noted that the buyer had filed them without seeking permission to introduce additional evidence and went on to examine the documents.
One receipt was marked as the consignor’s copy even though the manufacturer was the consignee. The Tribunal found that the last digit of the second receipt number appeared to have been altered from a zero to an eight. The first receipt lacked a truck number and showed apparent erasures in the entries for the goods description, weight and rate. Both receipts left the vehicle owner and driver fields blank.
The Tribunal found the receipts fabricated. It also gave little weight to the weighbridge slips because they could show that goods had been weighed at the destination but could not establish that the supplier had transported those goods to the manufacturer. The Bench acknowledged that the supplier’s returns showed the sales had been reported and the tax liability discharged. It found that the buyer had failed to establish actual receipt of the goods under Section 16(2)(b).
The Bench found that the notice and adjudication order described the conduct attributed to the buyer. Both alleged that the buyer had colluded with the supplier, used invoices that did not represent actual deliveries, and claimed and utilised ITC with the intent to evade tax.
The Tribunal relied on Section 160(1), which preserves a notice or proceeding despite an omission or defect if it conforms in substance and effect to the Act’s requirements. It held that the allegations in the notice and the findings in the order satisfied Section 74 despite the omission of the provision’s exact wording.
The Tribunal considered the Allahabad High Court decisions in Khurja Scrap Trading Company, Singhal Iron Traders and Saniya Traders. Those decisions held that later cancellation of a supplier’s GST registration could not by itself defeat a buyer’s ITC claim where the grounds for invoking Section 74 were absent. The GSTAT distinguished those cases because the discrepancies in the transport receipts supported its finding that the supplies were fictitious. It also distinguished Suncraft Energy, which concerned invoices missing from GSTR-2A.
The GSTAT dismissed the appeal and confirmed the original and first appellate orders. The demand of ₹4,16,849.40comprises ₹1,40,827.50 in tax, ₹1,35,194.40 in interest and a ₹1,40,827.50 penalty. The Bench made no order as to costs.
Membership Required to Access Case Details & Order Copy
To view the complete Case Details and Download Order Copy, you must have an active membership. Please subscribe to continue.
Read More: Supreme Court Leaves Assessment Order to Statutory Appeal, Allows Plea for Pre-Deposit Waiver

